Hal tersebut jelas bertentangan dengankaidah fikhi yang lafaznya sebagai berikut :usle P22 .wla.oJl $yele oJ! ut>Artinya: Meninggalkan kemudaratan harus didahulukan dari pada mencarikemaslahatan.Menimbang, bahwa berdasarkan pertimbanganpertimbangantersebut di atas, maka permohonan Pemohon dan Pemohon II patutdikabulkan ;Hal. 18 dari 20 hal.

Llgl Lege ULI alll 25 gyee 4 aillue YeLe till J gue Ud Jlas go deze OF slyly gale obi Gig ciao UI Gad 9 cla dd rudy eleg( Sle dx m42 9 d9!o 931 9 weal olay) eSa5 elle dy Gol cul, aArtinya: Dari Abdullah bin Amr R.A.

yesid eAuipelia, edepuadieg WDE H giolew ynqesisIsyesisyes ueBbuBleiey ueyesepiegq eyew BAUUIE vives njes uelensasisqBuyes uep Wipues1 ues eALUeNYeebUuad ueeseRIs4 prsyeuip uebueleyeyeueley BEPJad HMM ECSl esed uep 2064. jesed of Bay 60 leseduep (,) 1eAe BOE eSBe Lenjusey uebuap. leriges yele Lue sijefew) yunuswinqasia Isyes enpey ueBuesJeey sewed, eplt eBn uoyouwe; UBP UOYOWs, ueyUnynew ynjuN ebrenjay feud usio WeyNAeIIp BuedA iewep eAedn ueyyeq"He, ueyynpied Buyjes yepry yepns Bas Inst wens iebeqss

Hal tersebut jelas bertentangan dengankaidah fikhi yang lafaznya sebagai berikut :ule P20 .wlaoJl $yele oJ!

Yele a: Ngesia UaHay uejipebueySIWONOMAL te angasip edugnfuajeg vLO% snysnBy 1 peBbBue pLOz/illAJONSSAV/2S JowoN snsnyy eseny yeing ueyesepleg eyeyer vey UUWeULIf SOL # 7 lejue UUWeY eeUusy Bunpas Ip yewejesoq diysioupeg S4yWINN JoUey eped yeyorpy syeuey ed ewysyD epedey eseny vaquiewyela lu!

,)njuapa; ner, eliey uelluelieg nyens uebueyepueuaw jjeyes ewes Yyeuledyep yebnbuey uep yebnbiey uemedrey yejueyng yebnBbued emyeg 1MVHId HV1VS NVO NYMSy ONVA NVLVONDHWIWdvY LVONOYSL VdWdSy Il LVDNOONAd H31IO NVYMNFVIC ONVANVLV9ND WOYNH VEVOSS VV LYONDONSd NVMVAYNVY NVNIVISWLVONOYMSL NVMVANYY HVINVHNG I LVYSNOONSd WNAeVy HA10VYNOS&dAd NI dOudsond e ueyeingd uejnqeousd eped jeqnjejeq Bued ueyeindueueqnied ueynyejsw ynjUN Bulpueys jebe7 pyjlwew yep eYes UeyxVEqIp HueAuebueuemey inedwejew/ueyueqip yele

, UEP UOYOWs, elelue ebnlni ewejes uep ewe dryro Sued njpyem ununy weep uoyoue UEP UOYOWAadelejue ueyesidied eped Buninieq eyeAueyeAu yele Inqasie uereyHuayedueyyeq Wipuss ny efbue yeuins wejep wisi wens Isejas Ueyinoueybuewyeja efbulyes snieuew sna tpelie yee inqasie ueleyBuapyeduep ueuylsiesied ibejede ueulmerya4 Buelusl pel unyel JowoyNBuepupbuepun ueeuesyejag Buewel se, unueL g JOWON YelUeWwedueInjelag () jniny 6 jeseg of wes) WnynH Isejidwoy (J) Ininu gLL jesegweep Ip pnsyewip Gued uesnuuns

Dengan demikian, Penggugat diwajibkan untukmembuktikan dalildalil yang dikemukakannya sebagaimana ketentuan Pasal163 HIR;Menimbang, bahwa Majelis sependapat dan mengambil alih hujjahsyariah dalam Kitab AlAnwar Juz II halaman 55 yang untuk selanjutnya diambilalin sebagai pendapat Majelis yang berbunyi sebagai berikut:= fy aa e 1 . e = a a. ias, = 1h yele eh Sle eG = we oo) .Y78 aterm F 1S400 4555) je Ane 5! : : 13Mi le) Sm Bee 9!

dere uep uojeqBulpulp yILUBJSy leyUR ace Zp Jeqe) Wajeu og Buelued uemyniogBued tejue (enp) Z usueuLed (oyNyY) oyOL YeWINyY UeUNBUeg LIpIAqeAuseye Ip uep aja Gg seqsy Joyew og Huelued yeue: Buepig (Nes) fp 'Zednieg Bued eueueyey ueyeiehuayy ZzQebnbbusey uejyeinb ueyjngebuey 1IEWAnyueq leBegas uesnjnd ueyequiow JseBe jul eieyjodjIpeBuew uep BsyJewew BueA wiyey siyaleyy 99 nAeyes ewedSy ue oeBusgenjay epedey uoyouw eb 756ue, seje Ip jngesle uelewn veyesepiega)al eyse7 nNAy :eweussq yeue Bueloss sYe Yele

eyeAUJe jnqesua WeSe7nAy eweweary susAuoy yednbie; uebuep isusAuoy yeEnfbued yeue emyeg (uzye6n5 eg eySue yalqo) Vr PSLL Od JOAO XK YNZNg gow yun njesuep (ueye6nb6 1 eySue yalqo) 1eyue; enp oyny eAuseye ip yeur BuepigasNSE BYEL YyRunies yayouedua Yele IsSuUsAUOY yeBnGie uep suaAUuOyye6nbbued SGLGg tedwes og6, unyel Wep ueuimexyied Weep e.uelas BMYeg py .Og UNYye eped elunp jebbuluaw yela jnqesie WeysanAy eweujeq isuaauoy jJefinbiay uebuap isuesuoy jyebnGbuey yeue emueg LLOZ UNYe Eped isweds uiq YS

eAuueueleyJeBuepip yajoq yepg Guek Buelo yejueynq eAuenpey uep uebuepisied Ip uefueleyeyyequueuw uep yeduunsieq ueBuepisied depeyfuew mun eAuUegfemsy IynueWeWYyeja Inqesiey yeGnbGuey yao ueynfeip BueA isyes enpey emyeq Buequmueyyguep J 9g pr'e 'z ay uiod eAusnsnyyyeBn6Gueg ueyeinb eyisod jyepyep Gunynpuew yeje uep uerensesiegG6uijes yepns jnqgesie isyes enpey ueBHueisjey emyeq Buequwiusyy UBWIEJOIIP leg YIqe UB;NdUISeyJeq eEAUeBNpeyuep jiseyjog yepy ideja ueye yebnbia, uebuap yebnbbuey eiseyue ueyunyneweAedniag yele

edue seye ip ynqesie) Bueieq depeyia ueesenyeyyajoJedweaw emyepsey yenquiew Yele jnqesia emyepsa uUeyenqJed emyegugiNduiseyieq Wey sijafew seye ip uelein wep emyeg Buequiueyyynlue Yyiqe WNyNy sasoid ynJUN UeesyeWed UeyNyeIIP yNJUNdeyBueyp jiseyioq emyepsa ueIPNWey UeWe ELEN Yasog ay IU ueipefeyueyodejaw Bunsbue; uegioy isyes eAujnfuejag emyeq BuequwiueyySUBqIOY ISHes y!

Ueyeipesip Bued seyep Yenges Weyep jeyeolp ynyUN uUeUMeNJEdeAuuey6unsbuelip yecwe) jweAemow Bued uep yeuld yejeq enpey jebbhuryjedwa iyeAejimeu BueA uejeweocey eweby uesnipn Jojuey UeYIN Teleouedremebed epedey yej2 Jely uUedeousg UeUITeES ueyedweAusW ynJUN NAexaSeweby uenpeBueg ele.Uueq UBYYEJUNSWeW O/OYJO Xa eReOeS eAUUREqe:euarey WIyeH sijefeyy wes; winyny Isejiduoy (Zz) yeAy spL Jeseq ojoun/600Z UNnYe) Og JcWON Buepun Buepup uebusp enpey ueyeqnisd uep 900ZUNYE JOWON Buepuy Buepury uebusep yegnip yele

Hal tersebut jelas bertentangandengan kaidah fikhi yang lafaznya sebagai berikut :usle P22 .wla.oJl $yele oJ! ut>Artinya: Meninggalkan kemudaratan harus didahulukan dari pada mencarikemaslahatan.Menimbang, bahwa berdasarkan pertimbanganpertimbangantersebut di atas, maka permohonan Pemohon dan Pemohon II patutdikabulkan ;Hal. 19 dari 21 hal.

uowey Uabay esag Yele ay df Yld ONE 7 I!

eyeyer Waban uelpebueg eped jeLysnpu; ueBungny uejipebus,gInjejaw ninyep yigeye iInip yejsniey eAuueseuaqey jyngesia ueseyeebbujyes uebuepunHuepunied ueinye wejep injeip Bued efioy ueBungnyuesnnwWeq UueNjUsey ejebes depeyia, ueBuedwikued ueynyejewAMUN LVONOYSAL uebuguadey juinw yeyepe jul efiey ueBungny uesmnwedwejep ueseje euewiebeges WONOONAdd eAWGuew jeqiye emyuegLWONOYAL wep efiey ueBungnyuesnjnued jeins yepenjay eBBuiyes ay uep ay uelHGued yeuns injejaw"66uedip Yel uep yey (ew) g ewejes spjbuew yele

TLGO95) eSale yele abl aiLoL bgoiisl eSils sLuuJl 29 all lgailsMa 2b YeigwSyArtinya :Takutlah kamu kepada Allah tentang isterimu, karena engkau mengambil diadengan amanat Allah, kamu wajib memberi nafkah dan pakaian kepadanyasecara baik.Menimbang, bahwa terhadap perkara ini dapat diterapkan pula yurisprudensiMahkamah Agung RI Nomor 09 K/AG/1994, tanggal 25 November 1984 yang abstraksihukumnya menyatakan Hakim berkeyakinan bahwa rumah tangga kedua belahpihak antara Pemohon dan Termohon benar telah

OLVLIVH 4Jew weyy eusem BunSbund se ueuidies yeng (Wedws) 7 yejwuntieg yepjoo elem UeGye UBUIdJes WU LO'Z Jejewelp ueBuep Yeng (uejiquies)6 yejwnlieq Buluny uep weyy yeJew euJeMm jnqeles jeqey ueHuocjod WEYBUJEM SS) yew OA ZL nooe ueyidies yeng (jedwe ynind eb) pe eAuBunge dnjnuad teBeqes jndwep ueyeped yeng (enp)@ yedepse uep ww ZL'Z jeqe uep wo ore) Buelued ueBuep By se6 Bunge qedas epnu nefiy eusem weGoj ueyiduas yeng (uedejep) g weGoj je ueBuep ueHue wel ueyidies eyeweoey yeng (enp) Zz yesni yele

IGSVWNHY YEP NVAMAVINENY INA NVIG uebuapeuwesewesioq emyepio, BHuejewed yeseep ip ipueo ueseyequiedIp yeAyewe isyeisye ueynyejew yNJuN jeyeynuJeq/eueoUslEqBind yele yeAlewe ynjueq ieBeqes (eAuejobbuemes yeyes leBeqes emyepia; euewip) jeBba yejelpy Josuy yeALpnyyoduojey ny!

p UOYOWWS iLUBWd BlweseWwesieq ueyynqewaw Buek uewnulw IswnsuoyBuaw Buuase6nf uoyouwe ue; 1yeI1ye UeBUap YnyBuIjesJeq Yele UOYOWS) BusleyyeO uexqegesip uejeyBueped uep ueyisiasied ipelia; Buuas iHe; siuowweyep yepns Bued eAueBbue yewns isipuoy euehuew eAuueuoyouwedwuiejep ueyI!

Budiey Yao emUueg Zzgebn6bbuedyao yijidip BueX jebn6ie; Bueioes yejes jedwejyp ueBeu ueypebuedenjay epeday ueynfeip nj uejnjun eyew ewes Buex ueBeu uejipebuaedwininy yesesep ip jebbuly yepy eyesau Buepas Buesoasas uep yigajebnbip Bue eyip, ueyeyeAuew Bued YH gL jesed uenjuajey ueyesepiegVI sejay Buouqig webenN uelpebued isuajedwoy jeuebuew emueg nye lebeqaes uejebnb ueynfebuew yele 1G Nd/LZ0Z/9 Wd /E9Jajsibay sowoN uebuep z0zZ wenige+ 9g, jebbue, eped BuouigioWaHeN uejlpebuedq ueelaiuedesy ip ueyeyepip

sueprudsun,) uesnjng yejepeseye tp (ey uebuap ueeueyieg sialey spuapioap oges emUeg Guequiusyy(DIBEPLIOASyfjEYUEAIUO JOIN) BLLiaRp yedep yepR ueyPyeAUID jnyed IsuaAUOYyeY JeGnbbuedjsuaaucyas upyein6 yedepuodieq wey siyafeyy eBBuiyas uo, yeueAslynusWwalu yep jnqesie isusAuoys: ueyebnh ebBbuiyss aq 4nnosqe) ngeynejye Guess yep, jnqessa isusauoyai ueyeing ejexHuas yelgo ipefueu Bued(edesag unye UeieNnjey yNseUUEe) UeeIepUSy siuef Uep (yeWN) Ueunduegsen jnyveq yeue; sen, yeuel seyeqsejeq Iseyo neye yele

LLL 7L LL 7LF7 fad35Ce3 OTE VEEL VLEEVELO VEEL LOE VELL VEEL ILE TES IOVS ALObayV ELT LILVE LE VIEL Lt EEf7LLL7LLL739678 4108 4105a6bffQ7fLFL7LFLL7 LL LTE LL TELL LLCTEfL7 LLC 7LFCL7 fc6ls84a29ffL7FLL7LLLVLLL7 LLL TELL LL LTC LE VLLL7LLL7LLLVLLLE7 LLL 7Ef7LFLL7LLFL7fad35b55e6fL7F 7FF 7 7EF7 7 L7EFF7EC7EfL7 LLC 7F734e0000e F3dfL7 LF L7L LL VELL L7LLET7ELL7 LL L7L LLC TEFL L7 fde5ae71c6b2d0821e71c00000000 4208e71c08214a296b2dd65a9c737F 7FF7fEF7EEL/LEEELET EEL TELE VEEL LEE /O4o24208o24datr EEL ELE yELE