1. Beranda
  2. Pengadilan
  3. PN BATAM
  4. Pidana Umum

Putusan PN BATAM
941/Pid.Sus/2023/PN Btm

    Putusan PN BATAM Nomor 941/Pid.Sus/2023/PN Btm
    Tanggal 10 Juli 2024 —Penuntut Umum:
    1.KARYA SO IMMANUEL, S.H.
    2.MARTHYN LUTHER, S.H., M.H.
    Terdakwa:
    MAHMOUD ABDELAZIZ MOHAMED
    Nomor 941/Pid.Sus/2023/PN Btm
    Tingkat Proses Pertama
    Klasifikasi Pidana Umum
    Pidana Khusus Lingkungan Hidup
    Kata Kunci Perlindungan dan Pengelolaan Lingkungan Hidup
    Tahun 2024
    Tanggal Register 14 Desember 2023
    Lembaga Peradilan PN BATAM
    Jenis Lembaga Peradilan PN
    Hakim Ketua Hakim Ketua Sapri Tarigan
    Hakim Anggota Hakim Anggota Setyaningsih, Br Hakim Anggota Douglas R.p. Napitupulu
    Panitera Panitera Pengganti Syufwan. Dm
    Amar Lain-lain
    Amar Lainnya PIDANA PENJARA WAKTU TERTENTU
    Catatan Amar

    MENGADILI:

    1. Menyatakan Terdakwa MAHMOUD MOHAMED ABDELAZIZ MOHAMED HATIBA tersebut telah terbukti secara sah dan meyakinkan bersalah melakukan Tindak Pidana ?Dengan sengaja melakukan kegiatan yang mengakibatkan dilampauinya baku mutu air laut? sebagaimana dalam dakwaan alternatif kesatu;
    2. Menjatuhkan pidana kepada Terdakwa tersebut oleh karena itu dengan pidana penjara selama 7 (tujuh) tahun dan pidana denda sejumlah Rp5.000.000.000,00 (lima miliar rupiah) dengan ketentuan apabila pidana denda tersebut tidak dibayar maka diganti dengan pidana kurungan selama 6 (enam) bulan;
    3. Memerintahkan agar Terdakwa ditahan ;
    4. Menetapkan barang bukti berupa :
    1. Barang bukti sampel dari Komandan Kapal Nasional Pulau Marore-322, Badan Keamanan Laut Ri berupa:

    Kode Sampel

    Titik Koordinat

    Lokasi

    Jenis

    Volume

    Jumlah

    ARM-1

    03014?19? U

    104049?31? T

    Laut Natuna Utara Kabupaten Natuna Provinsi Kepulauan Riau

    Air laut tercemar tumpahan minyak

    500 ml

    1 (satu) botol kaca

    DIRAMPAS UNTUK DIMUSNAHKAN

    2). Barang bukti dokumen dari Sdr. Muh. Kurniawan, S.Si., MT., Ph.D. LEMIGAS berupa :

    No.

    Nama Dokumen

    Jumlah

    1.

    Laporan Hasil Uji Identifikasi Sidikjari Biomarka Sampel Tumpahan Minyak di Laut Natuna Utara Nomor : LHU/5.05.13.4.99/202370195 tanggal 2 Agustus 2023 dengan Laporan Rahasia Nomor: 023/DPMR.4/VII/2023 yang dikeluarkan oleh Balai Besar Pengujian Minyak dan Gas Bumi LEMIGAS

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    2.

    Laporan Analisa dan Evaluasi Pencemaran Di Air Laut (ARM) Oleh Tumpahan Minyak di Natuna Utara, Kepulauan Riau Dengan Nomor: 01/LAP/DPMP/VIII/2023 yang dikeluarkan oleh Balai Besar Pengujian Minyak dan Gas Bumi LEMIGAS

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    TERLAMPIR DALAM BERKAS PERKARA

    3). Barang Bukti dokumen dari Komandan KN Pulau Marore-322 pada Badan Keamanan Laut RI berupa:

    No.

    Nama Dokumen

    Jumlah

    1.

    Imo Crew List Name and Type of Ship Arman 114 IMO Nomor 9116412

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    2.

    Passenger List Name and Type of Ship Arman 114 IMO Nomor 9116412

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    3.

    Ship Particular Ship Name Arman 114 IMO No. 9116412

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    4.

    Ship Tanks Ullage Report After Loading MT Arman 114 To Load Crude Oil At Anchorage

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    5.

    Document Eurofins Mechem Vessel : MT Arman 114

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    6.

    Minimum Safe Manning Certificate : 9713719 Name of Ship: Arman 114 Date of Issue: 15/12/2020 Place of Issue: Tehran - Iran

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    7.

    Certificate Of Registry Name Of Vessel Arman 114 No. & Date Of Registry 1391 - 15/07/2019

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    8.

    International Tonnage Certificate (1969) Cert. No. ICS21481GT02 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 07.12.2020

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    9.

    Certificate Of Classification (Hull & Machinery) Arman 114 Cert No. ICS21481HM03 From 17.07.2019 up to 30.03.2022 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 26.05.2017

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    10.

    Fotokopi Certificate Of Classification (Hull & Machinery) Arman 114 Cert No. ICS21481HM07 From 12.02.2023 up to 31.07.2023 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 14.06.2023

    3 (Tiga) Lembar

    11.

    Cargo Ship Safety Construction Certificate Cert. No. ICS21481 Cert. No. ICS21481SC03 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 07.12.2020

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    12.

    Fotokopi Cargo Ship Safety Construction Certificate Cert. No. ICS21481SC07 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 14.06.2023

    4 (Empat) Lembar

    13.

    International Load Line Certificate Cert. No. ICS21481LL02 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 07.12.2020

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    14.

    Fotokopi International Load Line Certificate Cert. No. ICS21481LL06 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 14.06.2023

    4 (Empat) Lembar

    15.

    Cargo Ship Safety Equipment Certificate Cert. No. ICS21481SE02 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 15.03.2021

    4 (Empat) Lembar

    16

    Cargo Ship Safety Radio Certificate Cert. No. ICS21481SR04 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 14.03.2022

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    17.

    Fotokopi Cargo Ship Safety Radio Certificate Cert. No. ICS21481SR09

    Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 14.06.2023

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    18.

    Examption Certificate Cert. No. ICS21481EX06 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 14.03.2022

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    19.

    Record of Equipment for the Cargo Ship Safety Radio (From R) Cert. No. ICS21481SR04 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 14.03.2022

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    20.

    Periodical survey in accordance with regulation I/14(h)(iii) Cert. No. ICS21481SR04

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    21.

    International Oil Pollution Prevention Certificate No. ICS21481IP02 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 07.12.2020

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    22.

    International Sewage Pollution Prevention Certificate No. ICS21481SW02 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 07.12.2020

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    23.

    Fotokopi International Sewage Pollution Prevention No. ICS21481SW06 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 14.06.2023

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    24.

    International Air Pollution Prevention Certificate No. ICS21481AP02 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 07.12.2020

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    25.

    International Ballast Water Management Certificate No. ICS21481BW02 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at Tehran - Iran on the 07th day of December, 2020

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    26.

    Fotokopi International Ballast Water Management Certificate No. ICS21481BW06 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at Tehran ? Iran Date of issue 14.06.2023

    4 (Empat) Lembar

    27.

    International Energy Efficiency (IEE) Certificate No. ICS21481IE02 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 07.12.2020

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    28.

    Safety Management Certificate No. ICS21481IM09 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 05.09.2021

    3 (Tiga) Lembar

    29.

    Maritime Labour Certificate No. ICS21481ML07 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 05.09.2021

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    30.

    DMLC PARTII - Letter Of Review No. 1505ICS Name of Ship Arman 114 Our Ref: 23/21/0028 Date: 10.10.2021

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    31.

    Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance-Part I No. ICS21481DM02 Name of Ship Arman 114

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    32.

    International Code For The Security Of Ships And Port Facilities No. 0017297 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 13 September 2021

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    33.

    Document Of Compliance No. 0017258 Issued at: Tehran - Iran Date od issue 10/08/2021

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    34.

    International Anti-Fouling System Certificate No. ICS21481AF02 Name of Ship Arman 114 Issued at: Tehran - Iran On: 07.12.2020

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    35.

    International Anti-Fouling System Certificate The Republic Of Panama No. SNG 1700597 Name of Ship Grace 1 Issued at Singapore on 26 May 2017

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    36.

    Certificate Of Insurance Or Other Financial Security In Respect Of Liability For The Removal Of Wrecks No. 0017433 Date Of Issue: 19 February 2022

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    37.

    Certificate Of Insurance Or Other Financial Security In Respect Of Liability For Bunker Oil Pollution Damage No. 0017434 Date Of Issue: 19 February 2022

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    38.

    Certificate Of Insurance Or Other Financial Security In Respect Of Civil Liabiliby For Oil Pollution Damage No. 0017435 Issued at: Tehran - Iran Date Of Issue: 19 February 2022

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    39.

    Certificate of Entry Policy No. 9116412/2022/0211 Name Arman 114 Date 16 February 2022

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    40.

    Fotokopi Certificate of Entry Policy No. 9116412/2023/0207 Date 18 May 2023

    4 (Empat) Lembar

    41.

    Tanker Blue Card Civil Liability For Oil Pollution Damage Certificate No.: 9116412/TBC/2022/0211 Date 16 February 2022

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    42.

    Bunker Blue Card Civil Liability For Bunker Oil Pollution Damage No.: 9116412/BBC/2022/0211 Date 16 February 2022

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    43.

    Certificate Of Insurance Of Liability For The Removal Of Wrecks No.: 9116412/WBC/2022/0211 Date 16 February 2022

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    44.

    Port And Maritime Organization Conformance Test Report Name of Ship Arman 114

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    45.

    Continuous Synopsis Record (CSR) Document Number 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 19, 21, 22, 23

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    46.

    Republic Of The Marshall Islands Maritime Administrator 31-Jan-2016

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    47.

    Continuous Synopsis Record (CSR) From Bundesrepublik Deutschland

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    48.

    Model Ship Sanitation Control Examption Certificate / Ship Sanitation Control Certificate Port Of Tartous Date 25 - 11 - 2021

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    49.

    Certificate M/T Arman 114 (IMO NO.9116412)

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    50.

    Program Installation Test Certificate Number: ULS9500008 Date: 31st March 1997

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    51.

    LOADMETER BY HZS V.3.54.24.OCT.96 Loading Condition test-2.stb date 25 March 2019

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    52.

    Suez Canal Special Tonnage Certificate No. YCD 621067

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    53.

    Condition Assessment Programme Certificate Name Of Ship: Grace 1 Date of issue 25th September 2017

    2 (Dua) Lembar

    54.

    Condition Assessment Programme Certificate Name Of Ship: Meridian Lion Date of issue 25th Desember 2012

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    55.

    Certificate Of Calibration No. C0012146001 Date of issue 15 Mar 2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    56.

    Certificate Of Calibration No. C0012146002 Date of issue 15 Mar 2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    57.

    Certificate Of Re - Inspection & Inflatable Liferaft Service Report Serial No.15A25143, 15A25120, 12115504, 15A25121, 15A25141

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    58.

    Inspection Certificate Of E.E.B.D No. 02 ID EE Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    59.

    Inspection Certificate Of Medical Oxygen Apparatus No. 02 ID MO Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    60.

    Inspection Certificate Of Breathing Apparatus No. 02 ID B Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    61.

    Inspection Certificate Of Foam Concentrate Test No. 02 DC S Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    62.

    Certificate Of Inspection / Test Of Portable Foam Applicator No. 02 GD FA Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    63.

    Certificate Of Inspection / Test Of Firemen?s Outfit No. 01 ID Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    64.

    Certificate Of Inspection / Test Of Foam Installation High Expansion System No. 02 ID EE Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    65.

    Certificate Of Inspection / Test Of Fire Blankets No. 01 ID Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    66.

    Certificate Of Inspection/Test Of Portable Fire Extinguishers No. 01 EE Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    67.

    Certificate Of Ship?s Co2 System No. 01 LC S Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    68.

    Inspection Report Of Co2 System No. 01 LC S Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    69.

    Service Chart Of Compressed Co2 cylinders No.02 LC S Name Of Ship Arman 114 Date of Inspection 03.02.2023

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    70.

    Record Of Approved Cargo Ship Safety Equipment Record No. 9116412/06 Name Of Ship Grace 1 On 26 May 2017

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    71.

    International Convention On Load Lines, 1966 LR Number 9116412 Date 07/03/1999

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    72.

    Fotokopi Marine Hull and Machinery, Increased Value And War Etc. Package Insurance Policy No. 1402/304/110/9495/704 Vissel Arman 114 Date 15th April, 2023

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    73.

    Chief Engineer?s Log Book Of The Ship Arman 114 From 20 - Jun - 2023

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    74.

    Chief Officer?s Log Book MT Arman 114 From 4 May 2023

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    DIRAMPAS UNTUK NEGARA

    75.

    Copy Foto dan Video Tumpahan Minyak dari Kapal MT Arman 114

    1 (Satu) Buah Flashdisk

    TERLAMPIR DALAM BERKAS PERKARA

    4). Barang Bukti Dokumen dari Komandan KN Pulau Marore-322 pada Badan Keamanan Laut RI berupa:

    No.

    Nama Dokumen

    Jumlah

    1.

    Berkas Pemeriksaan MT Arman 114 tanggal 10 Juli 2023 dari Badan Keamanan Laut Republik Indonesia (Bakamla RI)

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    2.

    Fotokopi Oil Record Book Part I Machinery Space Operations Ship MT ARMAN 114 From 28 March 2022

    1 (Satu) Dokumen

    TERLAMPIR DALAM BERKAS PERKARA

    5). Barang Bukti Dokumen dari Sdr. Albina Apriadsa, S.Si., Surveyor Pemetaan Pertama pada Badan Informasi Geospasial :

    Nama Dokumen

    Jumlah

    Surat Digital Kepala Pusat Pemetaan Batas Wilayah, Badan Informasi Geospasial (BIG) Nomor R-4.23/PBW-BIG/IGD.04.02/8/2023 tanggal 4 Agustus 2023 Hal Informasi Posisi Pengambilan Sampel Tumpahan Minyak dan posisi Kapal MT Arman 114
    1. 2 (Dua) Lembar

    6). Barang Bukti Dokumen dari Sdr. Agus Basana Chris Abrin, S.Si. (PNS Kementerian Lingkungan Hidup dan Kehutanan) :

    Nama Dokumen

    Jumlah

    Fotokopi Surat Direktur Pengelolaan Limbah Bahan Berbahaya dan Beracun dan Non Bahan Berbahaya dan Beracun Nomor S.564/PLB3/PK/PLB.3/8/2023 tanggal 31 Agustus 2023 Hal Perizinan Dumping Limbah B3

    1 (Satu) Lembar

    TERLAMPIR DALAM BERKAS PERKARA

    7). Barang Bukti Kapal dan Muatan dari Mr. Mahmoud Abdelaziz Mohamed (Nakhoda Kapal MT ARMAN 114 berbendera Iran Nomor IMO 9116412):

    1. Nama Kapal : ARMAN 114

    Bendera : Iran

    IMO : 9116412

    Length Overall : 330.26 meter

    Moulded Breadth : 58 meter

    Moulded Depth : 20.00 meter

    Type of Ship : Oil Tanker

    GT : 156880

    NT : 107698

    Call Sign : EPLQ7

    Place Of Built : S.Korea (Republic of Korea)

    Year Of Builit : 1997

    1. Muatan (cargo) : Light Crude Oil

    Jumlah : 166,975.36 Metrik Ton

    DIRAMPAS UNTUK NEGARA

    1. Barang Bukti Dokumen dari Mr. Mahmoud Abdelaziz Mohamed (Nakhoda Kapal MT ARMAN 114 berbendera Iran Nomor IMO 9116912) berupa:

    No.

    Nama Dokumen

    Jumlah

    1.

    Fotokopi dokumen Outbond Cargo Manifest MT Arman 114 dated 10.06.2023

    1 lembar

    2.

    Fotokopi dokumen MT Arman 114 Muster List Organize of Emergency Teams

    1 lembar

    3.

    Fotokopi dokumen Safety Management System Manual ? Part A issued date September 2019

    1 lembar

    4.

    Fotokopi Document of Compliance atas nama Amitis Jazireh Kish company IMO Number 6221126 date of issued 10/08/2021

    1 lembar

    TERLAMPIR DALAM BERKAS PERKARA

    1. Membebankan biaya perkara kepada Terdakwa sejumlah Rp5.000,00 (lima ribu rupiah);
    Tanggal Musyawarah 10 Juli 2024
    Tanggal Dibacakan 10 Juli 2024
    Kaidah —
    Abstrak

  • Putusan terkait tidak ada

291
285