FX.SUPRIYONO (DIREKTUR PT.PERTALAHAN ARNEBETARANATUNA) >< PT.CALDIVE OFF SHORE INDONESIA

CAL DIVE OFF SHORE INDONESIA:;Yang berkedudukan di Jl. Denpasar Raya Unit 10. D GrahaParamita, Blok D2, Kuningan Jakarta Selatan 12940, dalam halini diwakili oleh Christian Budianto Teo selaku Direktur Perseroan,dan memberikan kuasa kepada Tony Budidjaja, SH.

PT ANDALAN MITRA BAHARI, Dkk vsPT BH MARINE & OFF SHORE ENGINEERING, Dkk

S.Parman, Kav. 12, Jakarta Barat, berdasarkan Surat KuasaKhusus tanggal 30 Maret 2015;Pemohon Kasasi /Termohon Kasasi Il dahulu Penggugat/Pembanding/Terbanding;LawanPT BH MARINE & OFF SHORE ENGINEERING, yang diwakilioleh Lim Huay Hua, selaku Direktur, berkedudukan di YardDapur 12 Sei.

PT BH MARINE & OFF SHORE ENGINEERING tersebut harus ditolak;Menimbang, bahwa oleh karena permohonan kasasi dari PemohonKasasi dan II ditolak dan Pemohon Kasasi ada di pihak yang kalah, makaPemohon Kasasi dihukum untuk membayar biaya perkara dalam tingkat kasasiint;Memperhatikan UndangUndang Nomor 48 Tahun 2009 tentangKekuasaan Kehakiman, UndangUndang Nomor 14 Tahun 1985 tentangMahkamah Agung sebagaimana telah diubah dan ditambah dengan UndangUndang Nomor 5 Tahun 2004 dan perubahan kedua dengan UndangUndangNomor

PT BH MARINE & OFF SHORE ENGINEERINGtersebut;Halaman 60 dari 61 Hal. Putusan Nomor 2735 K/Pdt/2015Menghukum Pemohon Kasasi I/Penggugat/Pembanding untuk membayarbiaya perkara dalam tingkat kasasi ini sejumlah Rp500.000,00 (lima ratus riburupiah);Demikianlah diputuskan dalam rapat musyawarah Mahkamah Agungpada hari Rabu, tanggal 27 Januari 2016, oleh Syamsul Ma/arif, S.H., LL.M.,Ph.D., Hakim Agung yang ditetapkan oleh Ketua Mahkamah Agung sebagaiKetua Majelis, Dr.

CAL DIVE OFF SHORE INDONESI

CAL DIVE OFF SHORE INDONESIA, yang berkedudukan di Jl.Denpasar Raya Unit 10.

Pertalahan Arne Batara Natuna (PT.PAN),dengan Tergugat (PT.CAL DIVE OFF SHORE INDONESIA) mengadakanperjanjian mengenai Jasa Saturation Diving, untuk mendukung terlaksananyakegiatan pihak Penggugat yaitu pemasangan pipa 8 flexible hose di dasar lautNatuna dari SBM PLEM di lapangan Udang, Natuna;Menimbang, bahwa dalam perjanjian tersebut disepakati Tergugatsebagai pihak kedua wajib melaksanakan pekerjaan sebagaimana yangdiuraikan pada lingkup pekerjaan yang tercantum dalam lampiran A secaraprofessional

menyatakan bahwa penyelesaian sengketaterhadap pihak Penggugat dan Tergugat telah diajukan ke Arbitrase.Menimbang, bahwa akan tetapi setelah sidang dilanjutkan para pihakdiberi kesempatan untuk membuktikan dalil gugatan untuk Penggugat, dandiberi kKesempatan untuk membuktikan dalil sangkalannya untuk Tergugatternyata bukti P25 yang sama dengan bukti T5 adalah berupa salinan otentikPutusan badan Arbitrase Nasional Indonesia (BANI) Nomor : 591/V/ARBBANI/2014 tertanggal 13 April 2015 antara PT.CALDIVE OFF

C/26/II/2018 dan bukti pembayaranLift Off ;Hal. 10 Putusan No.607/Pid.B/2019/PN.Jkt.Utr.

Nota kasbon tanggal 2 MaretLift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 2 MaretLift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 3 MaretLift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 7 MaretLift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 7 MaretLift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 8 MaretLift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 9 MaretLift Off ;Nota kasbon tanggal 10 MaretLift Off ;Nota kasbon tanggal 12 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ;2018 No.2018 No.2018 No.2018 No.2018 No.2018 No.2018 No.2018 No.C/27/1I/2018 dan bukti pembayaranC/28/11/2018 dan bukti pembayaranC/29/1I/2018 dan bukti

C/25/II/2018 ; Nota kasbon tanggal 1 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 2 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 2 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 3 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 7 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 7 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 8 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 9 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ;Nota kasbon tanggal 10 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ;Nota kasbon tanggal 12 Maret 2018 No.Lift Off ;C/26/1I/2018 dan

C/26/II/2018 danbuktipembayaran Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 2 Maret 2018 No. C/27/II/2018 danbuktipembayaran Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 2 Maret 2018 No. C/28/II/2018 danbuktipembayaran Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 3 Maret 2018 No. C/29/II/2018 danbuktipembayaran Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 7 Maret 2018 No. C/30/II/2018 danbuktipembayaran Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 7 Maret 2018 No. C/31/II/2018 danbuktipembayaran Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 8 Maret 2018 No.

C/32/II/2018 danbuktipembayaran Lift Off ; Nota kasbon tanggal 9 Maret 2018 No. C/33/II/2018 danbuktipembayaran Lift Off ;Nota kasbon tanggal 10 Maret 2018 No. C/34/II/2018 danbuktipembayaran Lift Off ;Nota kasbon tanggal 12 Maret 2018 No.

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE

Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK354 ASK000122Truk2. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK355 ASK000125Truk3. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK356 ASK000144Truk4 Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK357 ASK000145Truk5. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK358 ASK000146Truk6. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK359 ASK0O00155Truk7. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK360 ASK000156Truk8. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK361 ASKO00160Truk9. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK362 ASKO00161Truk10.

Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK371 ASK000138Truk19. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK372 ASK000139Truk20. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK374 ASKO000140Truk21. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK375 ASK000258Truk22. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK376 ASKO00151Truk23. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK377 ASK000152Truk24. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK378 ASKO000153Truk25. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK379 ASK000212Truk26. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK380 ASKO000213Truk27.

Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK389 ASK000254Truk36. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK390 ASK000256Truk37. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK391 ASK000257Truk38. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK392 ASK000259Truk39. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK393 ASK000334Truk40. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK394 ASK000322Truk41. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK395 ASK000323Truk42. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK396 ASK000324Truk43. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 E BK397 ASK000333Truk44.

Off Highway Caterpillar 773 BK355 ASK000125Truk E2. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 BK369 ASK000192Truk E3. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 BK374 ASK000140Truk EA. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 BK377 ASK000152Truk E5. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 BK378 ASKO000153Truk E6. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 BK381 ASKO000214Truk E7. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 BK382 ASK000245Truk E8. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 BK386 ASK000248Truk E2. Off Highway Caterpillar 773 BK387 ASK000253Truk E10.

Off Highway Truk Caterpillar 773 BK355 ASKO0001E 252. Off Highway Truk Caterpillar 773 BK369 ASKO0001E 923. Off Highway Truk Caterpillar 773 BK374 ASKO0001E 40A. Off Highway Truk Caterpillar 773 BK377 ASKO0001E 525. Off Highway Truk Caterpillar 773 BK378 ASKO0001E 536. Off Highway Truk Caterpillar 773 BK381 ASKO0002E 147. Off Highway Truk Caterpillar 773 BK382 ASKO0002E 458. Off Highway Truk Caterpillar 773 BK386 ASKO0002E 489. Off Highway Truk Caterpillar 773 BK387 ASKO0002E 5310.

FFOOT7 FFO OfFFFFOOT7 FfO OffFFO OT 7 FfOOFTFFOOf 7 ffO OFfFFOOT7 FFOOFTFFOOT7 FFOOFTFFOOT7 FfO OffFFOOT7ffOOTFFTOOF7 FFOOTTTTO OF 7 FfO OffFFOOT7 FfO Off FFOOT7 FO Off FFOOTFTFO SffffO0e7e710c6c610949c187b84105a6321424a182929181821180810181010180810181010101018182129183139184a52106b6b18848c10a5ad08d6de08t7f7 OOFffOOTFTFO Off FO OT7 FFOOfTFFOOT7 FfO SffFFOOT7 FFOOfFFFFOOT7f700ffffO OF7 FfO OT 7 FfO OF 7 FFOOTFTFO OF 7 FFOOTFTFO OF7 FFOOTFFFOOF7 FFOOTFTOOF7 FOOTFTOOF7 FOOffffO OF 7 FFOOTFTFO OF 7

FFOOTFTFO OF7TFOOFFFFOOTFTFO Off FFOOT7 FFO OFF FFO8T7 ff42a529429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c004294004a940031bd6b18f7ff10efff21efe399c18429400429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c004294004a94084294004294084294004294084294004294084294004294084294004294084294004a9408429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c003994004a940039a53121efffl 0efff21efff31ad39429400399ADO

FFOOTFTFO OF7TFOOFFFFOOTFTFO Off FFOOT7 FFO OFF FFO8T7 ff42a529429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c004294004a940031bd6b18f7ff10efff21efe399c18429400429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c004294004a94084294004294084294004294084294004294084294004294084294004294084294004a9408429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c00429400429c003994004a940039a53121efffl Oefff21efff31ad39429400399ADO

FFOOT7 FFO OfFfFFOOT 7 fFfO OffFFO OT 7 FfOOFTFFOOf 7 ffO Off FFOOT7 FFOOFTFFOOT7 FFOOFTFFOOT7 FfO OffFFOOT7ffOOTFFTOOF7 FFOOfTTTO OF 7 FfO OffFFOOT7 FfO Off FFOOT7 FFO Off FTO OTFTFO SffffO0e7e710c6c610949c187b84105a6321424a182929181821180810181010180810181010101018182129183139184a52106b6b18848c10a5ad08d6de08t7f7 OOFffOOTFTFO Off FO OT7 FFOOfTFFOOT7 ffO SfTFFOOT7 FFOOFFFFOOT7F700ffffO OF7 FfOOT7 FfO OF 7 FFOOTFTFO OF 7 FFOOTFTFO OF 7 FFOOTFTFO OF7 FFOOTFITOOF7 FOOTFTOOF7 FOOffffO OF 7 FFOOTFTFO

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE

FTE ET TOO FFT fFfOO fFFff tO O FT FFT TO O FFT ETO O Fr ft tro Off fttfoOrtttttoOffffffOOFfffffroorrrrrfroo retfFOOFTETFOOFTFEFFOOFETTEFOO fFFFTFO O FTF ET TOO FFT TFfOO FETE TOO FTF tT OFfTE FOO FFF fro Off ftTfOOrttt ToOffffffOOftftfrfroorffrrroo retfFOOFFEFFOOFTFEFFOOFETTEFOO FFFTTFO O fff tT fOO FFT fFfOO FFFfffOO FTF tT fo OFtTt FTO O Fr ft tro O ffftfroOrttttfoOffffffOOftfffrfroorrfrrroo retfFOOLFEFTFOOFTFETFOOFETTEFOO fFFFTFO O FTF ET fOO FFT fEfOO FEET TOO FTFtT TO OFtT TOO Fr ft tro Off

FrffrfOOFFFfFfO Off FfffOOFffFFfOO ff ff fro Off frrrfroortftfTrToOffffffOOffffffOOffffrroorttTfFOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFTFFFOOTFFFFFOOFTFFTFOO FrffrfO OFFFfffO O ffFfffO OFfTFFOO FfffffO Off ffffoOrtffrTrToOffffffOOFfffffOOffffrfroOfttTfFOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFTFFFOOTFFFFFOOFTFFTFOO FrffrfO OFFFfffO O ffFfffO OFfTFFOO FfffffO Off ffffoOrtffrTrToOffffffOOFfffffOOffffffOoOftfTfFOOFFFFFFOOFTFFFFOOFFTFFFOOLFFFFFOOFTFFTFOO FfTfFfOOFFffffO OffFFffOOFfTFFfOO frfff ro Off frffoortfrffrToOffffffOOffffffOOffffrroorttTfFOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFTFFFOOTFFFFFOOFTFFTFOO

fTFTTfOOFfTtTfOO FFT TEtOO FF Ftf tO Off TFT OFtTt tf Off ttfto Off fitfo0 80808OOOFFFFFOOFETTFOO LFF ffOOffttffOOFFEFFOOFTFEFOO FETT FOO fff fie OO FTF FOO FF FTO O ff ftt fo OFtft ff OO fff rro 0 frttfrO OFtttffoo frftttoOffffffOOftffffroorrrrrfroo retfeOOfffffeOOffiffroOrrrrrroOrtrrrTroo reff froO frftfrO Off tffOO FrfffeTOO ff fff tO O fff ttfOO frffrfoO ff ft ttoOffffffOOftfffrfroorrrrrroo rteffOOFFFFOOFTFFTFOOLfFfffOO fff fff0080808000000000000000000000000000000000004040400O80808000FFTFEFOOFFEFFFOO

ft tro Off fttroOrttt ToOffffffOOftffffroorrrrrfroo retfFOOLFEFTFOOFTFETFOOFETTEFOO fFFFTFO O FTF ET fOO FFT fEfOO FEET TOO FTFtT TO OFtT TOO Fr ft tro Off fttroOrttt ToOffffffOOftfffrfroorrrrrroo rtefFOO8O8N80DD0000000000000000000000000cOcOcOOOFFFTFFOOFETFAOOFTTFTFOOTTEFFOO FFT fTff OO ftfHFOOFFFTFFOOLFEATFOOFTTFFTOO fF TEOO fftTffOOFFEFFOOFTFETOOFETTEFOO ffFfTrOO fff ffeOOrtttrrro Off ftfTro OFfTt ff OO FFfTfrOO ffttffO Off ttfo0 frftttoOffffffOOftfffrfroorrfrrroo rteffOOfffffeOOfffffeOOffffffroOftfrffoo

rr rfrroo rrrrrToo retfFOOFFFFFOOFTFFTFOOLFFT TOO rtf fro rtttT Tro Off ttffO0cOcOcO0080808000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000404040008080SOOOFFFFFFOOFETFEFOO LFEFFFOO FFT ET TOO FFT TEfOO Ff fff rO Off ftt fo Off ft ff Frfffto O fftt tro OFtf ttf OO fFfTttOOffffff004040400000000000c0c0cOOOFFTFFFOOFTFFFFOO LTE TFOO rtf fr OOrtrtt ro Off ttt ro 0 frfttt 00 frtttf0 0c OcOc000000000008080800OffffffOOftfffroorrfrrrooO rrfrtfroortttff00c0c0c000404.04.000000000000000000000000000000000008

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE

Bahwa, Penggugat adalah Pemilik Pertama dan pemilik sah dari Merekmerek VANS, Merekmerek OFF THE WALL dan Merekmerek lainnya yangHal. 1 dari 136 hal Put.

Sejarah Merekmerek VANS, Merekmerek OFF THE WALL dan Merekmerek lainnya milik Penggugat;1.

Tentang Merekmerek VANS, Merekmerek OFF THE WALLdan Merekmerek lainnya milik PenggugatB.1. Merekmerek VANS, Merekmerek OFF THE WALL dan Merekmereklainnya milik Penggugat telah digunakan dan terdaftar sejak lama dibanyak negara di dunia;7.

VANS, Merekmerek OFF THE WALL dan Merekmerek lainnya milik Penggugat telah terdaftar dan digunakan di Indonesia;C.

Tentang Merekmerek VANS, Merekmerek OFF THE WALLdan Merekmerek lainnya milik Penggugat adalah merekterkenalC.1 Merekmerek VANS, Merekmerek OFF THE WALL dan Merekmereklainnya milik Penggugat telah memenuhi kriteria menurut UndangUndangMerek sebagai merek terkenal;Hal. 9 dari 136 hal Put.

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE

Tidak menerima gaji dipotong mulai hari ini lay off ( dirumahkan ) ;Dan Tergugat memaksa Penggugat untuk memilih satu opsi tersebut, dengan tidakmemberikan kesempatan Penggugat untuk mengajukan penawaran lain sebagai solusipermasalahan, karena Penggugat merasa keberatan terhadap kedua opsi tersebut,akhirnya Tergugat memberikan keputusan sepihak untuk merumahkan (Lay off)Penggugat, akan tetapi Tergugat tidak memberikan surat Lay Off hanya menyampaikansecara lisan;7.

Bahwa memang benar pada tanggal 17 Pebruari 2011 pekerja atas nama I KetutSutama diberikan 2(dua) pilihan oleh perusahaan yaitu : dirumahkan (lay off)tanpa dibayar atau tetap bekerja tapi gaji dipotong ;2. Bahwa benar pekerja atas nama I Ketut Sutama meminta surat Lay Off kepadaperusahaan tapi tidak diberikan dengan alasan bahwa pekerja dianggap keluargasehingga tidak diperlukan dengan surat menyurat ;3.

sedangkan Tergugat tidak memberikansurat lay off kepada Penggugat karena Penggugat sudah dianggap keluarganamun pada prinsipnya Penggugat telah menerima lay off tersebut dan hal itumerupakan kesepakatan telah dicapai yaitu.

No.SE 05/M/BW/1998 yang didalam Surat Edaran tersebut telah diaturtentang tindakan lay off yang dilakukan perusahaan terhadap pekerjanya baik tentangwaktu dilakukannya lay off dan sampai kapan lay off tersebut berlangsung disamping itujuga ketentuan tentang upah yang harus diberikan kepada pekerja yang dirumahkan ; Menimbang, bahwa tentang upah yang harus dibayarkan adalah upah pokok dantunjangan yang biasa pekerja terima selama pekerja tersebut dirumahkan kecuali telahdiatur didalam perjanjian kerja

off maka terhadap Tergugat tidak diwajibkan untuk membayargaji Penggugat selama lay off yaitu dari bulan Pebruari 2011, sampai dengan bulanPebruari........... 29Pebruari 2012 ; 20992 220922 202 2225+ Menimbang, bahwa sesuai dengan ketentuan yang berlaku bahwa apabila dilakukanlay off maka harus ada atau ditentukan batas waktunya, tetapi didalam perkara aquoTergugat didalam melakukan lay off terhadap Penggugat tidak ditentukan batas waktunyasecara jelas, dengan demikian atas lay off yang dilakukan

FrffrfO OFFFfFfO OffFfFffOOFffFFfOO ffrfffro Off frfrffoOrtfrffrToeOffffffOOFfffffOOffffrroOfttTfFOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFTFFFOOLFFFFFOOFfFFTFOO FrffrfOOFFFfFfO Off FfffOOFffFFfOO ff ff fro Off frrrfroortftfTrToOffffffOOffffffOOffffrroorttTfFOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFTFFFOOTFFFFFOOFTFFTFOO FrffrfO OFFFfffO O ffFfffO OFfTFFOO FfffffO Off ffffoOrtffrTrToOffffffOOFfffffOOffffrfroOfttTfFOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFTFFFOOTFFFFFOOFTFFTFOO FrffrfO OFFFfffO O ffFfffO OFfTFFOO FfffffO Off ffffoOrtffrTrToOffffffOOFfffffOOffffffOoOftfTfFOOFFFFFFOOFTFFFFOOFFTFFFOOLFFFFFOOFTFFTFOO

FrffrfO OFFFfFfO OffFfFffOOFffFFfOO ffrfffro Off frfrffoOrtfrffrToeOffffffOOffffffOOffffrroorttTfFOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFTFFFOOLFFFFFOOFfFFTFOO FrffrfOOFFFfFfO Off FfffOOFffFFfOO ff ff fro Off frrrfroortftfTrToOffffffOOffffffOOffffrroorttTfFOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFTFFFOOTFFFFFOOFTFFTFOO FrffrfO OFFFfffO O ffFfffO OFfTFFOO FfffffO Off ffffoOrtffrTrToOffffffOO0cOc0c000404040000000OODODDDDODOODONc Oc OcOOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFFOOFFFTFFOOfFFFTfOOFfFFFfOO ffff fro OfffrffrroOffffrrfoortfFffOOFFFFFFOOFFFFFOOTfFffOOffftffOOfffffeOOFfffFFOOTFFFFOOFTFFFFOO

OO fffffeOOFTTFffOO ftfTfrOO frftfrOOrttt fro FrffetOO ff Fft tO Off fttfOO FrTfefOO ff ft ttOffffffOOftfffrfroorrfrrroo rteffOOFFTFFOOFTFFTFOOffFfffO0808080008080800080808000000000000000000000000000FFTFTTOOffffffOOFtffrfOOrrtrrroO rr rfrroo rrrrrToo retfFOOFFFFFFOOFTFFTFOOLFFT FOO FFT frfOOrtttT fo Off tt ff00cOcOcO0080808000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000404040008080SOOOFFFEFFOOFETTEFOO LFEFFFOO FTF ET TOO FFT TEOO Fr FTffOO ff ftf fo Off ft ff OO Frftfto O fff tffO Off t ff OO

OO FTfFTfOO fff FOO Fr fTffO Off fttfo OFfTt ff OO FrfTfrO 0 ffttfrO OFtttfTOO frffttoOffffffoorttrfrTroortttfeoortttfeOOFffHfOOFfTTFOO FFETTFOO FFT FTTOO FTF FOO FF ETT tO Off ftf fo OFtTt ff OO FFfT fro 0 frttffO Off tffOO frftttoOffffffOOftffffroorrfrrroo fretffOOFFFFFFOOOOODDDDD000000000000000000000000000000000404.04.000ffFTFFOOFFTFOO FT ETOOffffffOOFfffffOOrrtrrroO rrr rffroO rrr rrfroo retfFOOFFEFFFOOFFFEFFOOFETTEFOO fFFfTfOO fff tTfOO FFTTETOO fff tt tO Off ftffo OftfttfOOfftfff0080808000808O8000000000000000000000000000000000000000000040404000FFFFFFOOFFETFOO

refffroO frftfrO Off tffOO FFT TetOO fr Eff rO Off ftffOO FrffrfOO ff fftTtoOffffffOOftfffrfroorrfrrroo retfFOOLFEFTFOOFTFETFOOFETTEFOO fFFFTFO O FTF ET fOO FFT fEfOO FEET TOO FTFtT TO OFtT TOO Fr ft tro Off fttroOrttt ToOffffffOOftffffroorrrrrfroo retfFOOLFEFTFOOFTFETFOOFETTEFOO fFFFTFO O FTF ET fOO FFT fEfOO FEET TOO FTFtT TO OFtT TOO Fr ft tro Off fttroOrttt ToOffffffOOftfffrfroorrrrrroo rteffOOffETFOOFTFEFFOOcOcOc0008080800040404 00080808 000FFTFEFOOLFETFOOFTTETTOO fff OO frftttOOFfTFFOOLfETOO

TTTFFFFPP PTTTETPT EFT FTT TTT TFT TTF FFO O00 OO OOD DDD OOO OO OFF FFF FFF EET TFT FTF TTT TTT TTT TTffffffffffTfTTT Tt TOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTTFFFFF TFT TTTFFTFFFO OOO OO OOOO OOFFFFFFFFTFT TTT TTT TTT TTT TTOO00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDOODOO OOOO OFFFFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOO OFFFFFTFTFTFTTTTTTTTTREP ER EAT TEE FT FE TE EE EE ET TT PPT TTPO 0 0 0 OOO OO OOO FFF FEET TT FTFTFT FT FTE TF TFT

0 0 0.0 OFF FTFE FE FEF FEE EEE FEFT FT FTE FETE FFFffODDDDDDODDDDDODDOOOOOO OOO EFFFFFFFFFFFFFT TTF FTFT FFF FTE TTT TT TTT TTTTTTTTTTFO 000000000000000000000OODDDDDODD OOOO OOOOO OFFFFFFFFFFFT FFF FFF TTT TT TTT TFTTTTTTT TTT TT OO 0000000000ffffTfTTTTTTOOODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDODOOOOOO OOFFFTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTOOO0000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOO OFFFFITTTFTFTFTFTFTFIFFFO O00 OO00D000000000 000 OO OFFFFFFFFFFTFTFTTTTTTTTTTIFOO00000000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD DOOD OO OOOO FEF

TTTTTTTTTTTTITIOO 0 OOOOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTTTO000000000ODDDDDDDDDDDDODDOOOOOFFFFFFOO O00 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTFFFFTFTTTTTT TTT TFTTTTFTTTTFIFO 00 0 0 Off ffTTffffffOO000000OOO OFF FEET TE EEE EERE EE EE EE EE EE EEffffffO 000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000OOOOOOOOOOOOOO FEF FTFTTFTTTTTTTTTTTETPTEFFTFTT TTT TTTTFO O00 OO00D0D0D0000000000 OOO FTFTFTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOO0000000FfTETFTTTFTFTTTTFTOOOOOOTFFFTFTFFFTTTFFFFO 0 000 OFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFTTFO 0 00 OO FEF FFE FT FFF FEFE EF FE TTT FT FFFT

EE EE EE EEE FEE FE EEE EE EE EEPRL EEE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRR EEE EE EE EE EEE EE EE EE EE EEPRL EEE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRL RE EEE EE EEE EE EE EE EEEPRL RE EEE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEETETFTFFFFFTTTO 0 OOD DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OOOO OOO O OFF FETT FFT FTTTFTTTTTTT TT TTT TTTFEPP PP PT PP PP PTFEFFFFFFFFO 0.00 O OFF FREER FREER EE FREE FREE FEE REE FE FE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EEE EEEPRR ER EET EEE FEE FEE EE EEE EP PEATE O 0 000 0000000000000000000000OOO OOO OO FREER EEE EEE EEE EEE EEE EE EE EE EE

FETE EF TFTT TT FT TT FT TTF 00 0 O OF FFFFF FFT TTT FTFTEEPE PTET TTT TFT TTF TT TFFFO O00 OOO OOOO OFF TFTTTTTTITTIIFFOOOO0000000000000000000OOOOOOOFTTFTTTTTTTPEPE E TEEPE TTT FT FT TTF FF PPPFO 0 0 0.0 OFF FT TTFTFFFEFTTFTFFT TT TTT TTF OO 0 0 0.0 FFFFFF FFF FFE TET TFT ET PTPREP EE EET EEE E EEE EE EE EET TEP PPP PPT FO O 0 0 0 OO OOOO OFF FFFFFFFTFTFFFF FFT TTT TTTFEFFFFO ODD OOOO OO O OFF EFT TTFE FEET TEE FTF FEEEEEEEET TEEFEFT FEFTEE EETEE TTT TTFTPRT RE EE EE EE EE EE EE EE EEPRT EE EE