Salinan PUTUSAN "# S S&S# S$ 8 SH SF "" S()S S# "# S$ S&%xm (S$ SN M$ + KS 8S SH (GS FN SS SES KD, YES RP SB"#,S +. (S# *+ +)S# 2" S$ SS " S(t S&S *" ($ S$ /" $38 +5 S#t S$ ++ LT $.t#$ S$ S$ JES N(" SSH FSC M(" S" *S St S& S +*S "Ft ) S#$$%2"# + $23oleMelawan + +4 4 $.+#S S$ $ )&ES ="(" ,SS# +65 S# +#S#" *S S#t S& S$ S +*S "# )" S#SS2" + $23we S SESH S S Ww y"B+Wes, Ww *WES,S & Ww (S) RN (S$ sWes, we wH S (" Ww S# cH + $3"ES.

(*S+SS "# + $3"ON S)(S# SS'S "S# S$ +& $(% S$ * (S$ S$ S#SSt $*S SES # S SES# N XNH SS . ESCH +)SH# "SH)"S S&5S SB#'S$.65 *S$ $ .$ & *" )% S# SH "S# "GS. 6 " S*(SH# +# +( %"# + $ S S# "# .$ $* )"# 33 %S ++(S *" )%)S#SS#LS#n+ $ 5 S( S$ SH "# 6S S* % +(5 *" )Sat SHOSEL *+&S"Het +, S# &Sot +# +( S$ S# "# .9 S* )" S SS SES (S&#" S("3 $( S S# S##E'S S&S + & S( " +( % " $)s$ S&S)S# "St6 NES (SH MHP Ft LHC" OSH (SH MH + "$$ S/S $ *S# S&S#0("*S S##ETS "ES. S*S# S& )"/S S$ *S + +# +( S$ S# "?

(S# $.6S *" (SOt#.S# %)'S SCS (S# & S&S )&$"OK+HESS +,+8H# )+/S SH RSE "SHS *" (SOCHSHE )IWSES+# +( )"&S S#'SS +(S#'S *SH# + *" /" SES# .S +) 385.5 & )" S$ S%St + S$ + SS# &". S&SE&+S S*S SES ("+ +.S# + S$. S# GS NHS"#S )+ S$. & S( +# (S# SF" S.S#(BE".ES(S "#S 3 G%)" S# )+t$ 6 S St )" S# S) " % "SH "t + S$ *" /" SSS# %S "# S S&SH# .S +) " *+#'SS SES)SH .FHt " (SS "+t S# + $ $#"# + 5 S&S *" (S$ S$ S#S S*S(S. " *+#"SS S&S)S# .+(+ $ S$t(S.6 S$( $,"&%) S(S# " *" & S# (S# &3 S.

",*W "&S)3.S# S# *W we ($ S# Ww +) We w +) "S# %)" S (S# Ww +SH "# +S )"6SE+ )"GS)%.S8S,B(S " "HS +S)" SF"+(4e "# +S (8 $ *" )"ES)S.SH SH *" "HE (S SH oo ym +"$ +S S# + SES." *8)S. " *S SS $E% )(S SH)"ES $ +GSH# *B.S( ("EHS SF )+ SL" 4)S.5 " + (+8484"# S$ SS(S# " "(S" S*% % $( B.S) %E"#5 S# $.605 &".

.+# 941 $)Se 4S'S = > *S&S)5 +(+ )ESH(S ("*S S$ S#E " S # S SES#$$ S# SX" St S.(SH# +# +( "# 5 5 )S&S#ESH *+ +)SH# SHS YM Ww *W &", (" (+S S# ~+(+ "S# Ww S* ("*S S

9.oeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoeoe#uW aoocoogoogoogooococooco0cocoocgooocoagcogcogoocogceoaoocoocoocoooodgooooooooo oO6 L BESSSSSSSSSSSSS SES SES SES SES SES SES SEES SEESSEESSEESSEESESES! Ww Ww & Ww # ! Ww wow A #MENGADILI 2 #" " " SSSBISSSESEEEESEESESEEEESEEESS2 "I 9 4" A ( Me. (:" 96 (3: 0 ~ 49 NN BL#M " s SASSSS) 2 # # " "oof # wom) #. 4 " # HOME EMO SES SS ESS ESS ES SEES EEE ESSS= won "I/ 5" 2 # G5" 4)

33H1&8 % 2% S/" % )" &% SH 3HBHE 44 5 /"65 S$ St "HS % S%/% "SEE "SEX HS& "4*7 88 79x" 5 &# & *1% SD S4*#/S% B 1S /")" , SSH GA * B+$SHSSS/" % )" G% SH B3ELSH 44 5 /"6S 3 St "HS % S% /%S N# SE "SHE #(S& "4* 7 8 8 79S SH " S,% & AN )SZO SB6"TS+ Nt MESS )" " SHSSH " StH 5) &2 5) & & *)S9 & SHSDUDUK PERKARA"HE 4S#S/43+2% " + # "HSSH * S$ " + HSHE(S "BESETan (SHS "TR " 3. 3 & "SE " S3# "N#SS ETS%% MHS" *)3)SH# $3243" "4BSRt&) *S425 /% S'St SHS) )SH# *#S SF & " )E2ZEHFSHE VESSHEY (SHES" )S2EHSHH(S &'%S) SES

)SHS SESSS St &6% % & SH* S# $S % "6S % S# "# 5 5 4" %$ & )S# * & SH ) GS &)StoleQRole+Aole " *Sg "#SSH# * 1G) * & SH)2. $4+2% %$ 6 " + # 4" S&S) * "#,%5 &)S# SHS) AY #B4ESSESHS) SH#S)S SB " + # SH BS) * MM Mak Mee gM kK RETSHS = *S SH HS SHS) M4k OG) ESH ,*SB ME YMRS SBBe S425 +*4*#SSH#E 5 SF + # N#FSSH# #55 *S )S# *#S SHS) " % S'S4= >94. %+2% " + HO" + 4 " *#(SE "HSES GSH OM BS& %) )* SES & & +A WHR (S5.

Termohon................ pergi meninggalkan Pemohon" 3 % )S# BS SH BET: Welt HES Bt /H SSS *B"ESS GSH SBS "HSS "MS" SF "" G) F SHE MHSS ETE "YS %"TSH #(S MH, S +) SH MH" SSH (SHS SS H(S A" ARH (ES425 S$ % +3 & " & SESH (SES "St G& B HRE/M D4+3 & "# OMA GSH "FS SGM AM G)SH MHS SH SHE ESMU4*4*HSSH OMHSSH + HEHE (SM MBRK/ S)% &4S6%) SH SF"+ HSH" + ELSES & GH(S "3 & " SHSH) SH TM OM + #St+25 SHES *S ) SH X#S SHS) 4" #B'S+ +5 & & *)S & S#S8 StS *S ) SH KES S+ " A" &)SH )" " SESSH & *)5 & SHS (SES "6&

") S#SSS' BR) & B;9* % " " SESSH#E 3 % )N)S(SS# SH NHS+S &'SH (SES E)N'*S )%"S'S " S$ Q@Q@P6S & SH SHSSS AQ @@ A*) & BYGC * % " " S#S3# R@) & BOS+25 & & &#S * % * OS wom wae # "HSS,*)S# &) &:%) & "4SS%& 4" &*&+%S 6 SH & SES %) & NM N4* "4" &)S# )" " S#SSH &4525+ *(S#S % % ) )#(% 45SS& 4" &)*x * @ SH*ESS S "S IN)" ,SSH# SH#E/S )" &S SH & 35'S# S745 / "6S % St # S % 6% fs "# % %99&+%S 6 S# & SES %) & NM N4* "4" &)S# )" " S#HSSH# G&4S525+ *(S#S % % ) )#(% 4S5SS& 4" &)*x * @ SH*ESS S "S (")" ,SSH# SHE

STE 6S N + # (S#S &remy SHS *S ) SH XBES & TN )*S "#SS# 4*) &:4*) & " % %) &(S#S &%,*)S# "AHS " + # " M4* &S B&, Y & "TSt MEN *) SH3) 6 %'% " & SHSSH# SHE (SES & % ) )#(% 4SSS& 4" &)*% S425 /% S'St SHS) )SH# *#S 5 & " )S2EHSHE"EBSE &4 %+2% SHS *S )S# XESS * FS) SH )UTXS SS (SES )* SES SF * SH(% SHS *%S ) SH SHS) )N4" % SH SH &t'S SHS)H(S &,5 &$)% "+ $6 NO+ #6 S425 SS " + # MM Sk) yas SE (SHS SF * SH AM ywrgy xsS425 SS " + # SHU Me) BSE B (SHS SS (SE * SSF SO 1S"HE ASH#S/ 4%+2% "HESS# ) Good SHS *

,AN SSS& SES " ( SE K& & B*S)& "SS, " (45 5 "# &S SE)S# " , S&) *"9S & 'SHES*(HS & +" *E SHSSH S(+(H 7SMG SeE *MK (SE &, (# "ESSH# " &% *?

# S#S2(# S#S #5 %, (# 7 7 "# S#S " & &'SH# $S SF SHES NS,&( %, "HSSH # SHSZ(# SES # 3, (F# < %S#% # S#S2(# SHS #7S, (# 73*"9% & "H 446896 $6) S &tSH# SHES +" 7 ( " " S# S,)S# +53"HSS &'S $3 % (6 6 6 (# ()"#S& & )SH# *S'SHSH +H" StSH# &)ole)"+% % "SS1%S& "#95 % &) %, SH (*S# $3 % "9S % S#"1E'3 $,& Ww +3 &HESSS!

Ww 1 # SH Ww 1 # *W z WwW +3 +" ) %&'SES* (HS) SH (# () BIS %"HE S#S3 %,18 '", )& "HS + )3 S GHE " B*() BS &+" )S1L&HSHIE"* (SK )" "HH (SH +5FB" S # SHS2(# SES #5 %, (# 7 7SHS "SS, &( S, HSSH FF SHESZ(H# SHS, HF < S# (# SHS2(# SS #j S, (# 7 "# S#S " & &'SH# SSS$S *" (6 &5 & SHS & (7olea %+" )% % SHE & " SH)SH ) MHS BOM +"HESGHSS BNSS'S )" "# (SH 4" S ( SH +" # GHS2(H SHSSH BES OMeH ()( *Sole#5 " )S& SH# N#SS# O" )S FS &HEMENGADILIWES (")%# 4N , HOH " , Ott" " & g=Gt ) "4S 3 Bai C (# () "#% (,)3#

(FS *MEMES 3 BS & (F "4B (7 (, *B ( & ((+&G" &)&SH# ( (*3# &HE &% (,) SHE % SESS UE MMS*",G " "4S SH NHSSH SHBSY") SE %, 7 & & E/N, )% &S"E* S)& SES " FE BSE 120 3 AWTS) ("(SSA E*B 6 3 3 $3 33H DA3 S*GHS2 S*GHS *" SS%K %)& #SSMHSBE & ZH (OO'",!

D3 A" S535 SHE " & "ESSRE GOBHSHS +3 3 ,% & & ( (S & S9B)SH BS FE SES (SE (HC) (&,S& & "(SS " , SH gt "ESSS# &3 &S 5 N+S#& " SSA + 3 # () *S'S&#SH# SES *5 FS (# ISH S&)"' (S )S# +3 % SHEBDSETIII&% % Ne / + i 3Q woof63% S#SSa7SH / ; 3 ste NS" 2) xg / i 3: &6 6 & " SE& / < 36( 73 3 = & & & S#E 3oy 11

Kemudian pada pukul 19.00 WIB KapalINKA MINA 08 sampai di sekitar area pengeboran minyak CNOOC SES LtdLokasi Widuri, selanjutnya Kapal INKA MINA 08 bersandar di samping kapalHT INA PERMATA 2.

Sillo Maritime Perdana dan ke kantor pusat CNOOC Ses LTD; Bahwa pengambilan bahan bakar untuk kapal tersebut tergantung daripihak CNOOC Ses LTD yang menentukan, karena setahu saksi ada 2 (dua)tempat pengambilan bahan bakar yaitu di Pabelokan dan juga di Widuri; Terhadap keterangan saksi, Terdakwa memberikan pendapat bahwabenar keterangan saksi dan Terdakwa tidak keberatan terhadap keterangansaksi ;4.

oleh CNOOC Ses Ltd yang merupakan kapal milik PT.

Kemudian pada pukul 19.00 WIB Kapal INKAMINA 08 sampai di sekitar area pengeboran minyak CNOOC SES Ltd LokasiWiduri, selanjutnya Kapal INKA MINA 08 bersandar di samping kapal HT INAPERMATA 2.

#SSH# OS4+S/ &B 4S) & ( MBH S= 7"&%S) S# 8&+2s/15 "+ %) B( =" + 8% "HO S6 = &SH.& % 9 " #S wos &%KK KK KKK wt S#S ZS/1oleole+3 (U4E SHeSSEN SS z Woleheole" "ES (SHES SH + S( " AN" B4RH0> ( LUKMAN yang keterangannya dibacakan dipersidangan : &/1% &( "ME HS + S( ("HSE N#SSH SB MB+ &( & & / #83# ("& & SS & ) 2 )"(" 0884 $/18 &( " & BB "HESVESSS "4+ $B) 6+ oN ( & % &+ & "SHS "NH" (SH 9 6 #& & 9 SH #& & "SS ( (SH )"#'SES/ S #SSH 2 O"# &% 8/15 &( " & % "He" (SH 9 6 #oeWOoleseseQRole&"&S( (SH )U#'SES/S

MESS Sf (NB SHO,SH OMM+ .B # "& "SHES +" HT StS %/ & ( SHWEES / & 2U Ha fF =% %/ &S& % ( % ( "&S( (SH# )N#SH#ES(%S)SH# + /% %) ) "SWHESUWHE Swe (S# 7 B Z/ Oo" SU" W &S TEES + om) Qo"oole & an Ww + "oH" &% NBHESIS +) & /8H& +9 "/ #SSE + +36&& "SHES +" (S# S&S 4 &F UK#Y BW /& +" % )"H#SS( SH 9 &S +N NH + "+ % & "HSS , 3 % SES +BHS ( & S/ +" %) St) )% St "SRHS "SES +" / HS "HSSH# OM SUH RES %S&% & "/ #S$% SS4+ )"+ $% "HS (SH(" 36% +348 ( & ~& #+ ( SHt SH )" 4% %"SHS 7 )S+ ) BY +" SE SEF SHE (M (&#H

HERMIATY EPPANG : S/1% ("+" SHSSHE &( )"B ( "#S/1% /& 'S#S " +) HS + $B "383 "(") Hew s#% #" SSH MBS HM 36 2 OF 4 i+/gofee & 1% "SES yu WONHLS / W 4Q'# 4+% S&%/ %/S# ERHS " 3 SE SH B+ &%/ % #!

%6/15 SS% 6 S&S/ ("SS StS )") "HOS Sifott ( )) #1 S ( Sh (5 & F&S/SEH'S +" % ( %S%1% "&%& ) )S ("S$ SSH %/% "HOSHS ( +%"Hl )SHSH# St = BS% 1 &%'%/ ( %) S+&S( SES(SH# &"/ & SH S/S N+NES/ NH S)St A F&S% " & & (S# )" OS#0 S# ("03 3 3 "BSS 8& ( S&S S S&St 78 # SES* # SHES+%/ # SUE+SHES #3 (SH 1S 5."

) SHHTSS ) #S S/ +" )St + #SSSE +N BCLWole%oleass" SES +" 3(18 " (# ("$3 9 6& % 9 SES "+ 3) (BE MES( (SH )MHSSH+ SH ) THE%/%# %(% #rS( O# 5% "Se MySH MME 3 #S1" MESHSH & SES/ NHN BH)Tk z "E3 8)") GY SUe Z/13 (4m SESS# $(1% We?

. $ At S$ (SH " )S% SH "H2SH# +" )S S$ BHR"cS, "# "HS )" " SH SHO" e /F S# +S $ *$)*% % ')S*% SH2"He S# /$,58 " # se " 4 "# SH #F S+", #S##(S " S# $e 6) " / (S# "8S, & STS"4S#3 " SSH "HS SES# $$ SHH Ses "Be" 4m yg"ES, wH W ')S)S# 1, 9&4,5S& xWHS S% wW S)'"$,55 " , # 8S#S SH# 97 &"&S, "#S)S, "+ S# " #8 S+*S, St & B+rFS SH 273/ 6 "*S 1S SESYIS S$ S# "SSHal dari 11 hal Penetapan Pengadilan Agama Tanjung No. 065/Pdt.P/2014/PA.Tjg(S/ S$'+S "# SS& # (S# 6 $) %1$ $ GU M#1S 959% 5) 8,S# *S# $$ "1S $ S# 1S

,)SH# +" #2)S,5" # 8S#% S#t O'S# ", # B+*S, St & BR #S)"4$St$,5S *" "G&S, $)S #5)S, S# SS " BSH SHt PENH SH" # 8S+*S, St & B#e" +" #5, "# StS )S# ' S$S)S,A" S# )S# *SS SS ' S S)S, M NT *SH# S St" &')S'# 7) UN MET, S +" *(S 3S SHS SHES S*S ) S NHS,S SH #S)$,5$ ", # 8S#S S# B' St " , # 8S+*S, S# %S #3 ")" S$ *",S 4,5 & *"S SAS# SHS" +"# ,~S*SES# & S)"HU " ,S#(S "#IT)'+S )",5 "HSH *",S 54,5 5 S# SS) " +7 FHSS(S '# 7) " 4" )S$ S$ & # S SES# " S*S )S# ' S$ "oN' St S +" $ 6 "N+S&S "*S 7 & S$) ' "1S S#98

$%)S# %28 $*"#% S# /$,5S +" )S $ %#% $ SES, " $*r) 4" JSS HM " $*$ )S# 89 S,/# 3*" 3$+ 4" )S 5 4" BgSES)')S# + *U* ON BS*SH# SES +" )S S SHES DS "HS 3S) H# SH 'F*U# YN S (S# *S7S #(S ,S#(S POlupfiR $)S " S$S*S SS) +" &!SES) *SHS) DH"tS S# /$,5S *' S$ ') %& (S# 6S ') SH ", # (SFS)"E&'S )S# &", #* SHE*S (SH "SE"#ESES, S" & MN NU SE KNIT) +E(Sx" S$ "&Spazgelen %& St# 1PM SHS NES, USGS!

S*S&$($ 89, "BO # S# 4 # S# 0 $,# 3:3 # S# "S "SSS*S& ,' "BOI S#BEB *" SS S*SE(S 89 "S$ ' SH " " S# S,oF / S)$ *' $ ")8S9 " *NF SS TX SHE(S S)S# *S, S#W ,o S *W S Ww +# (SS y")'S S# +" ') SS# (S# *W +/ #S S# we(vollidig en bindende bewijskracht)/) S$ #S#(S $+S 6" S$ $ *"S $S25&$ ')"#S S# /$,5$ " $*S )S# ") & " ') & $,55 ", #St " # S S&S, *'S"S SES GS SES S*S )U+NH# "SHO SH"&! "1S 48 $ S# "*S# 2S"tS S# /S,5S8 S&S ,S& SHS " , # "&S, "# ,S % )S#t !

#"#(S S)S# *S, +" )SSt#S# S# S S SS SH #'R NH SH St*S,S #5 (S# SES) *SHS) SH +9 S$ R37 He "*S 1S S&SN"1S S$ S#"SS (8 $'+S "# SS& BRO NN "=S*)S# SS(S +" )S S )"+S S$ " F# S# 2 , #ol?"

3" #S S&S #S 5S MORN ("css, W $25 s w +"ES'S & " 3 S* 4+" s s"eS, " "HS oo" " SHS " HH(HS $ *S *87*S BB SES +" *S STENTANG DUDUK PERKARANYA"S$ S #08,45 " ##(#S SES *( S #(FS S )S " SS ##SE"% )S # & $8 S$ 6 "+S 6 " $$ " #S S&S #S S$ S$ '( #SS FHSS O "S&S, " #8"'( S$ ,$&7,$&*US#SS " fe ($,45 "FH CES " #S "(HS S$ S&S, *(S$ & S* " & *S, /)SSES *S SS +5 SS BREE 6 (SS, St" (BEES " #S 458%6 SAS&S S$ 6 S* S45 " (49 # + 2 (S$ (&(, S( (48S,S& $ S$ (MP(& *( S$, S&S (S388 #H S$ " S$ S/7 ( $, (37 $,(1 (&$3S*S

CHS $ "(HS ( (S$ ( *""S S$, ( +" 6 $,$ (S$, S$ ##S "HE CES $ "(HS"Pe Stl xMge*s, 8 S$ +" " # S$ S$ /)S # S*"S $ " #(#S ( S # " S$ ##(C #7S4S " ,S St "( (,5 " %" Ft (#3 "SSt $&5 "'S & " S( 8$ "(ES *X S "" FSSZSS S $*S, )S i & St (i. " #(HS" S&S 5 (( #3 #5 25 3 S$ 38% "#(#S S$ &S#S " " & S$ $8 $, $,% S(+( $ 6 &"%,Sy ( (&$3$,4$ +( 25 +" *"&S*S,$ S +" " # SS "Ht (ES " #S "+5 S$ S$ ##50S ($ 5S" #5 *"S " # (GSS "S$ ##( # 'S4S"28 $ )S # " $ S "FH (ES SUBS GES +5 6 TESS$ "tH (ES 6 FHSS (% FH(BS*"SHSS S S SES

S nog 6S $*" #(#S S HSE & ( S, @S # (S #ECHES "S#$%3 $$ &$ $SS SS +85 " #S *" S SHS " #t (HS $ " # (#S ($, "4"6S S$ "%, (S$ #, ( (&$3S,45 " ##CHS *( S$, " (*8,5 "5 S$ S (S$ "+S S$ "&($ #8$ " #(#S S#S $+$ "( ( $ " ##(#SS SS ""SH#EHES 2S" ,$B8S&$,4$ $ $* 4" ($ " #(#S " ##H#SO 3 S *S ##(+ &SHS" *($ % $ " #(#S $ " ## (#S ")% +(& $ $,45 % (( "+" $8,858 $ (S$, $ ##5 " #S " #(#S $$ 3&"%, $%" $*S $ S&S*S S&SE&T S&%SHH(SS S*O S#S "(S$ " #S SES#$ S$ S$ '( #S$ $ # .C S'"ES* S$ mi" 3 *S S$ " #$ 3&5 +"MES TC

*S 3S SO S'"&S* S$ % $ S&S +" *%5 S #S "G&S, " (*S,$" #$ "" $$ $ $,$ $ $*3,$ "+5 So" #H(HS S#S ("#(#S *U*(SS NON B SSeS # A S,( # B " $ #"S$ S&S #9 S )S # "&S, S(S, " #8 S #7 S #"3 S #0$,45 " S*S5 S$ ($% "&SS* " F#GES " S&S $"25 3 "& ( " ( # % ( $ S$ S$ " SS( #0) ( o* & *%0ao" #5 S&S #5 S S$ '( #)9 $ #O2S $ +" " *S "ES 68 +" S$ S$(#S* S$ 44" S # " #S SES #9 S$ S$ '( #S S AS KISS; S*SES #7 S # A S$, ( B " S # " S$ %&S$ #S S$ )S # "&S, %" HS S #7 S # 5 , ( $ S #7 S # 1 $, ("S$ # " ($,8 "($$ $* S #7

*SE # A $,( #B " S$ # " $ %&$S #$ S$ )S # &S, S(S, " #8 S #7 $Sy ( " S$ # " (S,$ S$ #7 $ @ $,( B $ $ #7S$ # 1 $, ( " S$ # " ($,$ " ($ $ $* S$ #7 S$ #A S$, ( BOS ( (#8)S$ *"( 6 SNS #FSBSEO" SS*S5 5 S$ S+$SES *S SS S$ " S " #(#S 6S +" S$, BS % St" *S SS #S"3 S #6S,4S )S$ # " 'S % + S*S&S, S&S +" S$ %*US#SS SS )S # & " (SS &", " FECES +2 SS + *SES S*#E S#(#S $ "Ht (ES "S$ #8S& O85 "S$ 5 ( S'&S* NM +" 5 S # S*US#SS " fe ("% S #0$,4$ " $S*S $ ( %+$ S$ S/$, 5 5= S ##S29(&% t( 6 7 " 28 $ 6 S&S )S S$ Sk

Penggugat:
Yayasan Citra Buana Mandiri
Tergugat:
1.Ses Aesif Lambei
2.Aprisman Masa
Turut Tergugat:
2.Dra. Ariani Yusuf
3.Nurbainah Sastradinitiya Tiban
4.Camat Kecamatan Palu Selatan
5.Baso Mappatoba, SH,. M.Kn
6.Kepala Kantor Pertanahan Kota Palu

Ww #S SES #S "Ss Ww 'S # Ww Ww S()S S Ww #S SES Ww$$ #(S " "BSS " ,S *+XS*)S)"S#SS " SIRS " (S."8 $%oleHXHESS # SS, * (O"+/% * * O1 St+* DFS S$ )ES ON % BSoleS&S) "(" ,$$% $( $90 " $% *)* 2) $0 %($wis S S * %S0 s* S Ww Ww Ww )"Ee ;* S %)"*Ww FESH#ES ( 2" )% Ww HERES " ( 2" )%"653 $ 0oleS&SS) olewa" 7oS Ww S 5" Ww S z ##ESS B ")S S Ox * 1 $+*OS#S S$ )&S0 " % S($% $( $8 $0"iS S S * % s* S WwW Ww Ww )"6e r 'S $)"*Ww #*X#ES ( 2" )% Ww FEES Wy 2" )%"#5 6S #8 S$ oy NaeWest Ww S.S S Ww "S,S$ z wW (S) Ww

#EXES SU EKES "G&S #)* #(S " &(S+t$ $$ $om af 2 ")S %.S0$ $ * O59* SN "uo"" #S 35&% 6 ($+ 6'St (S$ * FEXEI "ES6 S(St(S &"+ 6S )" " S$ 'S # T SSS S)S()B(S &M+*S S# )S()S S(S+t 'S # " SS S$ 8 " #8StS " * S$ S$ BSt$( B$"$ * $%0S+3$ S$ $ 3 ##*HES SU EES 5 S( S$ S +k* HES S$ $+ yM)*)*S) GS MUN RES YS S $ 6 S( $$ &3 S$ #8 * *(" &(S+S ( wk * (" " xs +* (* )&S s* * " S * S* S$ #5 'S # " &S(*S+3S " ##THS ) "ES S " S(S+ HRS & S( BER(B *(K yu s #(S Ww FEXH#ES Wwou* K+ (S * * ( ("E" #(S s s & S) S)% *Ww #S SES

#S S Ww WwSt3S5 ) MES+ OM BNC SHEETS S F*#S +5 * * (* $ 6 HSE 6 * St St" RES $ "(S$ S$ # & ##S& GS *"S#*#SS #$($ "S$ % 6 S( S($ * S83 $ $($+3$ ("S$ $$ * S+ OS" GHIBB* #S SS *#S ) *ES " SES a C4$3( " $ & )",S( $3S& *&S QU SN TEX ES BS t*ES *&SSWw 78 z Ww )"&%) S+5S s Ww Ww #(S S 'S # 3)"S(S /e Ww EES Ww 4 ak 8 *ON EES (SN ORCAS SSS EB HES S $+S$+35 * .S( " )"&%S) StS $ nN PT HD SOS EES ",8 6 S ##S& 3 *S$ 6 " S3S& S"SH#X#S ES # S&S ("SS SS $ $t+4S &S #)* # "MR (*KGEEXES "45 FES " HEXES )* St BS" #

& AX S )* S$ + +9QSBH GI * 18" 3(%$ * *)S %$ S$ %,S *+(S$ S&S " SFVESBS BG" #5 S&S #55" S S$ +$85*0 S ##S& *&S S)"He" "S$"#5 S$ ##989 "S(S 99 %, S'StE&N+ (S$ BS 8 0 )"S#S%"*S $,"&OM0 0 $ 0 OS) % #4$)S # )"S#SRS tt SOS +8 5 & * *, MHS S*.S (S$ S&Sm#($ * *( # * ON HS GS SF, EMF 0 O"S#sS "SS"##S 2 HS 84S SS" Mees ( 2" )S " HES "(2 HRESS2" )% " HERES "(2M )8S(% ## $0 " *S $,"&S)0C 0 $ 80 S$ 6" SB ##S 30Soy 0oe6S58'S " (S$ $/ " $5 $$ 0"($$ 0S ##SES 2 09 " $()% 0mY 83 : QO OD* &S+ 9< O68 $ $ *)" SES =

*B+* B** SS*()$e% $ )")*$B "HS * 7B 1S2&4 S & Ww S Ww #S SES #S S Ww Wwole

/ 0 7 < 1 SUHESEIm#S" S&S $" 39+*S *SES "S'St 1! +" S$ + &5St+*S *S&S5 "S'S+ ! 8B " O+S S)! S S#S" S$" 1 31 $75"TLL Sm#S" (S"# )S S$ ) ' 1"(S 394+*S *SES "S'St 1! +7 BST S$. !*SES "S'S+ 7S I"S TSES "SISt 1 +" 1 S" SH# 35E" 1S BS 1 4oS 126. jJFPRY J + 8 FE IBS 2. "(S , &! 9" (690+S"S')$ S$+8& $ $ &S$'S1ES'S ESS" (S"# $ St 125, QB7S!" 9M BLSS)S" (S"# INHESUHESUT SH 1 +S)S $$ +" & SHS,mS SS# BS+*S +5 3 S$)! & S"#S" :S& "1.8 6 ! +" 31 "S, . . 0 $+." S#$ $ &@ jlfl SSeyegu +33! !

I",$ % *SE% "BIS+ mes" Ses sh Im, SH 18 iS 1S 3 of 4 gg!6. ImHS" oF +" 1S IMs gg .(S . ST) ESR1 She BR BFS11 $+*$ 16% 288" +" 317! ,$ 13888 (S*S" $)% $3 8LMHS" )IN#+S SES" ) l 81 75 as & ~)@S+9 39) 3.65"511 $+*$ 286 " .% ! +" S"# . && (S"# $$ 3! S#S S $GS3" +$6$ 6% $ *S" 511 $+*S6" S$ S$ 1 +" GS" 286" (8 BM(S % S$ $$ +.3.1HSH" S St%$' $$ +.3."#9" 9" Sm 1 4 #8 & $1 $68 Brg gM)! .MSMHS ) 1 SUSMESH Imes )eeSr Sms) 511 S$+*S+.3."#S" S" $ S71 .S"(S . $+ 3! , SES. SNES S"(S "165 $ 6 2.

55 S25 S hl S SES" YL Se Sz S ! )% s+7s" S & pin s)s" ZNsTENTANG PERTIMBANGAN HUKUMes 3B3S"H# 3S4+*S Ss . s" 7 8" )! + wou ! + Ww S$ s$$ 5ole) ' '"(S S$ S&S+t 13S#SS S"S ! 13.Him. dari him. Penetapan No. 039 /Pdt.P/2014/PA.Gs.I"S 35"# 39+*S )! 7S $ B"S S SeSt 1 1 RIRIMSME gmI"#S SES" #$ S$ 1 BT51" 35"# 3S+*S! +." 286 " 18 3 1 + Sh S(St 1 4)! & S"HS" SM test 1 B31 arsm rl 1 gsmesm 12.7 ym (851" 35"H# 354+*S $,163 S'S laSt 1 ! 3" S4rSY '4)B Soleoleole+$Ss" $(S+ LC LF ee 1 $$ $ "S ." 3!

S/S" S"#rsas" Saee & S"S 1 +" 1 +" SHS S(SHN(S 8B% 1 $)'S" 13S#S% *Ses $ +e 'S I"S S(S+ +." I"HHS B STS,SES S&S )! wors+s" s" S S ! + Ww mes 25& Ww .S z ! +3! "Ss S : 2 wasn S&S s" 2S5& Ww : & ! + Ww S s" '&.! )."(S% ! S"# S"S'5I" 35"H# 3S4+*$Sa% "S'8S(S49! +." +8 3 )B & SUESM SM1 31 ars ri 1 gm#sm (S# )S S$ ) 7 WINS 7S" B94*S BS IMHESTI",$ & *Se% "S'S+ SES)! TSHE"S 1 +" IMHSM 25E" LSImHS SeS SEQ" 18 3 1! +" SS Ile, IyesH 1 fm rg ysS$. "(S$ 2S S$" .ISH.

Sm YL .M SUM#LL SUHS 7S IMS(S S&S SS" SES NSISt 1 tae +5 . S"(S S$7S" & S$! 31 S$ S$ +."%. L+S"H##S 3! S )S"#I"S 39"# 39+*S S&S +5& )! + "SU" S#S *S&S "S'S+ 1! +"S"(S STS" S$ +$& $,1&% $'% mS 8S SM 'YS.S" S S&)s&S Sw". &S $,8& S(S 8 9 $" S(S 8 9 !$. $5"#5 S$ !).3&5" " "! SS $+." 0 ! $S$% $6%S?

(RSH S(SS SH N#SS3SS"H,S (*S# &7%+olellRQHenyiniwoWO" 2 3+ "HESS (SY B"HU SESH ES) $M *Bo0&( S45.8'S "HSS GSH SSS LM 4M# S4R Set # 4( ( BH YSS4%5 4% $ % & & SES )SHS "S & MHSS(KSRL %oHeUr"#SS St "# & & & +" & SESSH " SHES*SH# " S($S & S* % S#S"#) ( ( SHES "S&H N.SSS& *(S S#)S +5 SS" &S5 "MT S &+SH#SSE" & SH +5 ( BES*SH# *" & S*S & SHH) S STS 56'S SB) SES SS4% "SH, ( #)S +" " &* SSH GSH, ( SH BTS +" & SHS" ( (F (# (* ( ( "HOSH# &S43"E +" .3/)S#S & &H)S " St &+" SSEXSH# "NDB "HSS (SSS43 (# (* MHS (

(*nr S &S, (*S# SH & o* "HSS, (XS# 7% (* & )S#S "SE+S&XSH XN & +(' SHE ) SES +5 56 + * *#)S " St 45 SB(SS SHE) S645 # SHS ,S'SHH)S +" & SHESSH " (S#)S ""S &/%3 %ole% %/% % +" & SHESSH +" *RBHSHRICH (F "+" GHSHS (SESH5+( ( S# &#EFS & (#, (*'S 1" & BS B/S SKM MHEG ( (45*S# FS (x" S&S (S# #SSH#E +( ( SH &HE!"HE .S#S1.345 S* ( St (, (SESS SH N#SS (SSB S'S".SSS& SES ""S &( S&*SH & FS"HE .S#5S1.%34%5 " S(S% "TS &+%#SSE" "#SS# " & S# +%(# (* "HSS St & +" & SESS# ".SSS& S#S *" "HH (SH# +3 &!"

HESSH# S'S S# ".SSS& S#5 *" "HE (S# 234' (5D " % ( S#WOM GH SB 2 S(# 2 :1)S& ( S# S$ % (S & St & " & "oo"eM ( " ,6 & +" "EG &% St +" #S*S SH St & SF $$ % % StS& (+ (*(# 'SSE& S'S ( S63 S#SSS%"#& .S#S1 .34% " E+ (# " $(S8% & S* % & EIS+" & S#SSHB (# *S "#S 4" *S FS GHEE H#)SES*( +" HEH ( N/SED) SE ( +" *S FS +" /" SESFL"H#SS GSH " St LW SHE "SH+ 0 (*% &SH# *N4+S SF N#HSS(GH U* & ( N#HSS (SS "rS NESS, (KSSH SIS(* & ( % S(+(# S* & ".SSS& SES "'S E&BSE*X*S# & & SF"HE .S#S1 1345 S'S ~(* & )S#S &S, (*%

"#SS (S% S+%&+" & .SES*SH#H NL.

SSSR SES MOM, ( &0.S45 &#E"HE .S#5S1.%4% % '& ( % .(* &H " (+5*S# S* %"# &*4.(% "VW & S( &% StS# +",3.% ( ( )S#S ." 4N#SHES (# (*W (%" & BSL(* 8( (& CH S SESTHEWe (Zrw +", 35.% W a 1&HS WoW) Wot SH wre +('Sa wre Ww WH (& )% z 5"HE .S#S1.545 " &*ESH# +('S ( 3 .

Menyatakan Hukum bahwa perkawinan antara Penggugat dengan Tergugat yang dilaksanakan di Makale, Kabupaten Tana Toraja pada tanggal 07 Mei 2006 ses uai kutipan Akta Perkawinan No. 398/MKL-CSTR/V/2006 tanggal 08 Mei 2006, adalah sah dan putus karena perceraian dengan segala akibat hukumnya;4.

Men kan Hukum hw rkawinan antara Pen nganTergugat yang dilaksanakan di Makale, Kabupaten Tana Toraja padatanggal 07 Mei 2006 ses uai kutipan Akita Perkawinan No. 398/MKLCSTR/V/2006tanggal 08 Mei 2006, adalah sah dan putus karenaperceraian dengan segala akibat hukumnya;4.

AN SSXH/ (SH /" ( ( ( ( &HSSS BSS SHIZ SE"HEESSS'XSH# "#SS (SS St, 6 & &H#H NSS (SS SH SEY SSSES+SH ) ole 2( (ole& ( " S(8% & Sk ," #5. , ('S#S SH & B* ," HEL *& & *%&*" S.(& 7S SHS SES "S+ SH ,S+ & & 5E'SAS. ", (/'E* F"3S 3 & ( " S(SS & B* M /" & #SO*S. 5S &/ *", SS MESS (& &* "H#GHSSS'*SH# 13% /"H S SES 3,3 ES(HS*SH# +"/BSSE #RE+" S$ " S$($% " /&F& Met " " (GEMEBS (SSS.5% "#SS(SS OS. /" (43.5 "HOBBES % TRA", S FS SES" S(SS #3 (# " "*S &S "#)S S*SH G& SX MHS" SL (G 4AN/" & SSH6.5% 6 St +&*S, SH

*S# , ( (494 "S&H ) SES 4E"S &'S &'H)S# S#SSS ," +& SESSE ") SHS*SH GSS (SS& +"# & & HSE BSEOKSHE " S(SS & S* .% & # & SK MH) (%.5oleole3 3 376 6 60 &ole"S&# (# (* 1.3 & +"/SSSE& KHBESHEES2 "#( ( /" & % ,SORSSE' SHT"'SSt & & "HSS &'SH SSS ( & SHS BHISYF 9 SH D"om oyn )S#S &/%S0%*%1," +& SHESS#2 " S(S%S "'S. &, S#ESSE4" ZESSHHE, F&(SZ " #)S GF /S.5!

& S* %S SES#E)S & ( &EN/S/*SH# TML 4"4(S5 ( SY SHSSH" )SHHSS SHS .2"*S 5 &HE &' SH ( *SH# NHSSH SH,T 45 & #)S " S(SS, S.5% ," " ER+SSH# ," XSF EHE & (TSE "NHSSH " /SOR*SH +("ESS (SS )S#S &+EH)S " 3S, &," S.S#*CE TNL "HESS (SS5% (# (* "EUS (.*S# S'&' SE!

S.(# 8 S# ,S4S'1. ( (A;ral St& (*( +'E"2Q2 *S "HSH)S S*S (SS SH N#SS(SS 5 (&*S/ (' MoH"He /S#SZ%.5% (# (* " 08, SH)S " &/ % GHEt Bt +"/BS2KB SEE TM (BM (BB BLS BL SHS OM, (C/E HO HM HES= : SH &* NT S+ERSHE NESS FOSBS # SHESS.(# 9 +"/SSSE& SES "SL &(/S. N#SSH # SES HF THESH 1St "(/%S.S# "(i SHS # SHS 8 %. (# S*S 6 NT E+" S# S#S ," '( (# (*% " " &H#H S.*SH# SHEE " S (# (* HSE &+3!)

. (# 23*S /&S)5 ," *5 & &/"/S#E*S#*",% % "HSS ($%"HES&H#SS +" (6% ," & ( SH ," (# SHES(# SHESSHE ) SES /" "S*( %+)% B&)S. )S#ES /" *S& SHE NHSSH ," *Z SD EHE"#)S S*S# /%.5% " S(SS )S#S wrs, &, S#SSE! "HESSH# ,S ( (#& ," +& SHESBHAX .A &"ESS/('*XSH# S(SS S# N#SS (SS "HEESH @U + NKoo< # S (.*S# S'S* +5 ( /S=&# +(57 " S($% ,"HESS (S37 74" " GH SSH SHE " S (# (* NHFSE & +5" SHSHE , ( (+0 ) SESmW (ae.

KemaritimanBakorkamla Angkatan I tahun 2010 di Kolat Armatim Surabayatanggal 27 September s.d 7 Oktober 2011, dan dinyatakan lulusbersertifikat dengan hasil BAIK (copy sertifikat terlampir), sehinggaapabila PENGGUGAT dinyatakan tidak melaksanakan tugaskedinasan merupakan tidak tepat;Surat Perintah Nomor : Sprin184/Ses/Bakorkamla/IV/2011 tanggal 18Februari 2011 tidak pernah diterima PENGGUGAT;Surat Perintah Nomor: Sprint184/Ses/Bakorkamla/IV/2011 tanggal 13April 2011, dimana disebutkan mengenai Surat

18Februari 201 ;Surat Perintah Nomor: Sprint184/Ses/Bakorkamla/IV/2011 tanggal 13 April2.

Sekretaris Lakhar Bakorkamla Nomor: Sprin088/Ses/Bakokamla/II/2011 tanggal 18 Februari 201 1;6.

Surat Perintah Sekretaris Lakhar Bakorkamla Nomor: Sprin007/Ses/Bakokamla/1/2011 tanggal 6 Januari 2011 tentang mengikuti kegiatan Pendidikan DasarKemaritiman bertempat di Surabaya mulai tanggal 24 Januari 2011 s/d 2 FebruariHal. 25 dari 43 hal. Put. No.22/G/2013/PT.TUN.JKTPAGEb. Surat Perintah Sekretaris Lakhar Bakorkamla Nomor: Sprin088/Ses/Bakokamla/II/2011 tanggal 18 Februari 2011 tentang mengikuti kegiatan Pendidikan DasarKemaritiman mulai tanggal 28 #Februari 2011 s/d 10 = # Maretc.

Surat Perintah Sekretaris Lakhar Bakorkamla Nomor Sprint 007/Ses/Bakorkamla/1/2011 tanggal 6 Januari 201 1;(2). Surat Perintah Nomor : Sprint184/Ses/Bakorkamla/IV/2011 tanggal 18 Pebruarikarena itu.

"# S S&S# SS Ht SH SH " "3 (S$ S# # S$ S&% )")S S$ S# S$ ) SS NESt NH,S *+ SH )* *(SH# SES )" SG S"# * S*.* / St+*#R SS (&9"H# FS SES +5 YU" SPE SOS* St $ % * S" St S$ S$ * TEU ).S St BAX) S "F28, . "&S#,* #7S Q(MHL* * $"&SOS#mn o* S** St*EL SS (&9"# 6 6 SES +5 2)" " ,SSES SS.1" " YS St SE*)S "Ho SUESH,* #75 S(T1* " * $we S SESH S S Ww ("1*"gst "193 1" $()" $ "ESt "Ht "OS nN) OH SH S S# (S$ (S4(S (%!"

*S 1" 3 S$ $38 S$ )" (% S# S# S&SSHS +5 *( SSH# S$) N&St " S(* S# " *)S S# 1$ SS# 'S# %)* *(S# S#S"#3 1S# 1$+0S$ $ (* SH *,*S# )*ES SH ("1S $% S#S "SH"* $$ S$ * $"#% 1$# 18+0S ("1"E* ")" % 1St St )SHEH Se Sy "ES (+$ % " &M1S+ S$t+*E* M )" S&S IS#t S#" )SES SES# S(S S# NE)S# S&S# S#. $& mcmoqe .'S#S&S (S#S S# &N+ @* *(5 S "H# S# S& NH S SUBH*SS B (ABS (H1*Hal. 8dari 10 Put.

. $ (S&7 Jo $($& "$$ * S# " S# St S+*# 98JoS($& / )SES(5 * * (SE"+ S "#S SK S#'S S S# 18+0S$ " *"GS+ S)S# SE& ("3S S$ "( & S# )S *"#S 1S# 1S+0S )S S$ S(S)#HS * S$ "# S&S& S# SH S# 1" "# S#U * S S ("HS S$ 6 FOSS S#) St * $ 6S +9 ("184(.oe("&S&* Ww no )" ("G&S (S+S# S WES Ww * S ("&SE&* WEerxs S&:"S SS# $1l* (" "&S+ SH* St* Sit " SES "Hot S& S# )"# ?

SESE )"# * S " ("1* S)$ S'S S# & S$ '"#5 1S# 1$+0S $ %& S#SES(S SASS 14* 55 (* S$ S*) *# S&S"ESEXS N(S (SS#SES(S GS 5 " * S# 5S S@5S $StOS 1"#S"# * S$ St * S$ S$ S&St (*$ 6 3( %& (StSt+tOS 1"#S )"# * S$ S# " * S )" #St * KF ("1S $%(KS 3 3 8S+OS 1"#S * St SHU#S * S$ 6S +S #5( S"HES %)" ("ES (B4S4$+O0S %& S1"#S "(NS SH "&*S S&S SH ) *&S# "S&S "S SS# $1* S "HS SH#* SH S# " S (e =6$t+0S 1"#S " o* S$ "Hot S& S# )"# * S (",S $0S&+oH# SS ("S$ S# @S#*B(S St 1" ,S&SH*ES# SH (TES S$ee; Cf * "= (Pl1e ) UP *

S(" S$ " SOS "#38 S$ % St & " )OH)"* SORHSM * S SttgrSeSt (*# SH.* "HSS S S# )* *(S# )" 3" SBSH Ses ("1*S+3(" 3S SH *# * & *"HS 1S# 1$+0$ )" S# St ","GS( +8 8 " (M1* SH 1M s)" S# $+ ")S S$ )S#E" S tH * MHS & (MHMESS (SEBHSH )* *(S"#35 $ 6 St ("S&o *( S S# S3SH * S# SESS SS Et ) USE SHHal. dari 10 Put.

1 S()S SM IMH#S SES *! (Porm 6 eS GS SMH(S FL 8S 8 LeSt IM, S TH+(SU KT YS" YL S#SS !*! ($ $! So'#S S$" SS.LUE #S /!$og5"Lo # #S/I"#S S&S" #5 S$ 1! )A ''eSt+ 1! *18S,5 6 ! (S$) ! (S$ $fest Im IMHS (1 1 SHSM I UHEHS $s" )$()81)$()%*1 ye suegn$+0$ LH HS MHS" TS THES SU" GS SNH S25 (S"IXSUS 1 SSN LMHS SES" #5 5 "SSS LMHS" LHS)SBHHSE 4 1% 1eS+ 1 "HS," ($" +$61+$& )! S#SS 1 S("S+OS !"##' HES SU" Lo #S LES+ !

S$tS SES S$" S LMHS" ,1&S) $S( & S&S&'S O%8ES St "N NJISSSHES S" SS LUE! #S o" Lo # HS L&SFQ)Sr *8 SUHHSE& )IES S (% SMHS" StStOS UHH HS YT St of TYStS 7M 7 ( ":S$ S ! ##S $($"$ $( ! +$)%&$+0$ $$) $)S$ $&$)$" $&$)sn oo! jl LUE ES +" (1*S S$*INMES SES" SES S ' SSS TU 7 L (i's 1 S"##SE SU" ftLUE! #S S" lo dep 7heg, = & 15,8 "+096 7 FYS )L Ss IN#S TR (SN RFS SU INET ESoe(1m,S 7+($" SES( )S So") ETE ES FrGG > 1 +S S*UHH ES Fea G >/< ! ! $"($" $$ $ *!

1 (S$ S$ "BS SES()$S"S(S!$"*S +8 " S$ 1 HHS$+0$ $,!&%) $(% l&St 1 7)St+S I"S) S45 & LURE HS SHSlos! $% pepo" 1 #7 8483 1 $*% % $( 1 HS )'S &"6 S$:S($" )" S$ #5 $" LUE #S Suit 1" S$ S$ %)%8" $S*! S+S"(S" &L+ LNA ESStO0S 7" 7 ( 1 eT S ($" S&S& FTES SUM EES ES L&S+1"#S,7 ($" S&S " ( ) $ **3 5ole? 2; * "Sesh ( S$ &(S+ 78 7 9 SUHESES ONSSU# S(L&"S (S GLH (E*SES ")S" #8 $ 1:8 $$$ $" S$ S'" 680S$ % ' S"# 1&S+ S: 2: ((8" LMHS" S)&S" S! $ 1! $% 37 ('%3! & S"=B>/? : a Ss!

##S 1) qgeru lest Beg"Jli2S$ S$ *S$ 7S38( S$ SU# LM#+S*SES FSC ! " S$ S$ $t0S (! 3 Sioo+$ 6 SU" S % 6)! S$ (S" &!I!t )TS 7" +SES"#S" SUH )St !+47 (' 3 &I+ (S$ I"S 6% S(S ! #7#S +5 7) 3" S$ S(A" & S( +83 $+0S ! $)$ ($" '( BS(S +$ 7) SB" S S(S" 1EStLP F( &@ purr +e ie +05 LUE! #S 1 es" 1 #'#S S$ )'S 6%) 1 6 S"# 1 B(S S&S *! (SOSMS" SU"# )St+3. S+0S #7#S SU LNHET ES 6 S)S ($" *S S$ $&S& SES)S"# *S 3 * ( ("S$ S$ $&$St+ $t0S )!1,S( )! S# rl(: (38 $ 36 !

oleole)&S S&S (% &1 "0S 6'B SEESSS".dil abil jl aut ol syle gl ise j5i olsSN" SS SES SOL FFD IMEEST TN TC 458 5 SST ot YL 7" & 8S 8!6 S( S(! St'% , mS (! 6S SMS $3! (S$ S$" $ <SET FT) (S INES" & S)S (S" *S SS TRISIS UN SSY3. $+0$ 1 6S$)S ($" *1 & Sues" oe $sHRS SN LURE ES '&S+ 1 *7" SS 3h (7* S&S)S" SS" 1ES+ !yt S$ Lo LM +S *Sk8S S => "SUFI SUF S47" 456 S)S$& 4+" "22> ! S$ 7 S$" 1 1! S"4S586+'"" 4586 S$) $&ole+! ' 22 *SES)S 1 (' )AIB !

*S SS " SS 2*(* )" S "ES S22 ((S# S# ""# S# $)aS#"S+ )"GSH,* HS EM " *S $,"&S) S." & SHES 9 1:3)6 * S$ "" SH SH TSH %" 1% (S# E" SH *)S# $$S$ S# "#S# $.* SH SH fot : 1 A"St $6 6 "nM + "ES SHSQ" "EB LALAB"ESH#,* #7S 6M " *S S,"G%) 3." & SES OD 33"ES .S# + .$58 % )$ SH .*( 8 )*S+ SSE " ~ # MES"# S,*(S# )$()S4)$()% )".S SB." B(* /00, % .$5$8 )* S#'S "HX * $ $25 $8 $58. )"ES "LN S(S# (")S() SSH "SH $$ ( (#7S )".S $% 1."

0 09S'S (St *F " = # 7+ = S# S&S "ES ()S#SS# S(S #7S)"# 6 % 'S# "# S(S (S# 3S5S 'S# "#,5 S )S$()% (" S($ " # "+ SH ""GSH )*# (SH " #E(SSH S$ SES )S'S SH# )"S 8 SHS SH SH SH&SSHHE $3$5$ $&$ " (SSs#S# " YU" * S$) (SSc##7S 6" * S )UL")S9)" $ *) S.* * 26945 *#S 33S5S$ $ 6 " (SSs#S# " )N.* ""(S E&S S(S *#SSS SH00, % .S$5S )* S#7S "HX * $ $285 $558 )"ES "LN S(S# (")S() SSH "S# $$ ( (#7S ).S $5 1."

*(S#ES " * S)S#7S " (SSt#HSHt (8 "#S )")*SS (" "# *SH# S$) SE "S$ 9: #ea 6 myn + " (SSs#SH# S$ SES )S+ $ $.58&S SES (*8 S)c# 4 $)c# S$ S$ S#'S S# (" " 28S'SS#ETS & *3"HE .SH# + .$5S$ *(* GS " S)*( )SES JS * *(K SH"()%) "#)% S# ("."

.$5S $)$& 6 'S 91: * *7 " S&S) *(*"" ges) ("S"#S# S# "HS SES# $$ SES "($$ "HE )S$"S(#S "GS * % " (S5RESH "SH SES(A(SH GM (SS SH & $6SaS# S# " (SStHS# "He * # S# 4H SH S*# 6 3"HS .SH# + .$5$ "6" S$) $B (" "H *SHA(" "H *S# 7 Be)""* $% % S$ S)+ SES "(HS %)S SH SS (" "HSH SH *(* "= $+ ,* S$" )"ES ("HSH SH *(H & SHS( SH" &S%")*$ 34%) SS# $$ #3"#5 .S# + .$5S %6 " S# )oleCPssteCPsi # "&S "# S,* ($4* S$ .*( 6 H S# ( " 4+ )S 8% 4 y" S$ 9 *S: SH )S("* $% % *($34"#5 .S# + .$5S .*( 56 4+ 4 S# 41 $5 " # " .*855

$5 " # ." $ S$ S5%&S'S '* S$) S()S NH S SE&S# $$)"S# S &N (S$ #S#'S FS SES# S$ S$ $ S#t ."

wes SES" #S S , Iwi (S"# ! ! S)*S s" wes EES ! S$! $$ S$ S$ S"#)S ! $$ L&S+ IN,S TH)SN 7 TSUN *ISH#SSS&S 1! )$ $ /! $% #7#5 S$" $ $0PENGGUGAT ASLI. 1 S+/".S#5 S$ *&S .!)! ,SS'SWASTA.! %"+##SKABUPATEN SUMENEP. ~!s#s3%UHH! #S2&$3$"TERGUGAT ASLI. 11 S+"S#S S$ *&S .!)! ,SSSWASTA. ! $SU HES & KABUPATEN SUMENEP. *!S#S%1 # #LI"#S S&S" #5 S$ ! *A"lS+ ! S/S $" ! !ge$,$ % ! )$*2! )8 8'&St+ IM IM#S Yt 1 SHS" LUHEET HES S BS *S)*%I" S"/#.S43S I"HETHS LMHS * SHES SU(S 1 SUHESSHe (S"# lest 1!

)$ $ B"%ole% S$) 2 +$*S&1 S*S )$" SES*S" $6365 Sasd"#S5HS*. +" )!1 $$ FS)rS MHS BES" FS S 7 IME =$,1e8* $)% oF 1 B)*S gMI"#S SES )S FIBER, "(S +" IMS HSH 71 THEM HIGHER 1 8)0IN#S'&)S" HHS S" INHHDESI"(S $)$" ,$ + S&S) *$ ' S:9" *H+ & 1 HHS R4+s s1 !$")$" 88($ 1 )$ $ FIRTSS )L Em gM ary (QM 1 BS)!0Shot MF FSM (SUH *IS SERS BEN(S"Ss S"#.

'4 4 SES*S TY)! EEB LS INS FS 7 KES SU LURE ES$$ 6) $" &S""5 SU"#.S+3$ ! S$*S )Sh JL Im 7S" S*SESU# 5 " SUH< 8" CC 1" SMF 1 $ S&S" #5 S$ *!IS#SS $"S 1&S+ =" LU#SN OM SUES OM SME tL fre 7 9" L Bs a B+ Meee" OSU"#S " SUF str" C, S* Sk ! $ 7 sg" 1 1 3" btG $47" c< *1 FS 1 'S 4 S$ & SES# St+)3 St #7 NF0 5 E SUH#S& B) ! )! S$ S$ S"e !$wes SES" #S S y tw z ! au $+) $s" mw a) iE 2 z )s" KSESNSM ,1 )$ $ 3"% (S"# 1ES+ !

)I)'S S" 47)" 1 $ JIS S$ 1#83S%&)S+ $" reg" $5 $ *1S#S3 SS 1 *I1 SES) BO SMI"S S"#.S$43$ &!+ )$ I"S 1! )$ $ BS" 1 ST) SES %1 )$3B"S".5)$ ! $*$ )S" S*ES(S 78." S"#5 " SH 0SES ! S , s" ! mw SuU#5ru S "#s" (S"# ! &S)ry: xES (S"# !

)S$3R"S" S 1 $ SNHHESE"HH HS S 1 HOES" 1) B/S $ SES $4 S$ (S"# BI BS)SN ITM% 121 1$")$" )1 $$ IMHHTES 1 S($ 88($ 1! )$ $ *1,7 &S+457 $ $'* &S 'h'+ #8 BT 1 BS41 3) 36" Fo Pager 6" 8,9 ' +)" SES *S S# "(SBS StS$)% S$ +$ 6 L&S*S SUHHSE! ! Seles l 169 S$" 1 "ape"SU"##S& G&)$S St 1 &, S(S$tE!+ )S * B*I1S#SS = $)% 1 'S$ $,!&s* *! # .$" B@ . #. *1S#8%S $)% 5 $)% "He S$ *!1 S$ %'/S )S" &"TRS S&S *S SUH OL HTS TM Fy oreole1 'S $,!&* S$ $ +8 %&!l+ S$ S$ S$)% "HE $.

SES 1M, THEM 1 FHS HISHSS 1 8)!0mesreys 1 + msm $a! $%=8" )1 $$ 1 +7" 1) IMHr/s yg" s) S SES) 1 48 +" % 1 S$" *8 ShH ImHS Sesh HS S17 1M!1$")$" 3$($ 1 )$ S *LAPSS )L IM rgM grye (SH 1 gg)?0S + Ww , rmxgm (S"# KIS SEAS SE"(SINS S"#.S$425 $$ +8 8 ! *% SMHS" (S"# 1GS+1 + 4 'eS+ +5 % *I" $ & S&S RIS SOMES +" %$ S$) +5 %oleCPsSeS 1 BE SMHS SST SS) OIM(K TH SMH BSBM TM 1) 48 8%1 *% S"H#S" *1SHS% 25)%G )SEI"ESS %S) SS * S )I!

SeS S" Ses Rms 1 +481"S S"H#, S42S )! 7 3S" $,1as* 8) 8 lest 1 ' $(SI" $ $%)S" 34S) (S"# ! 1 )S S ImHS 11 % "SeI4S YI! Sg1 +" S#S o')P )1 See oIMHSH 1 MG mM 8 S$) 1 4S*88,)1 1 SS" Bes",/ )sy ImHsM 1 S/sysy FS oF 4S" 1 4" (EBxole"($ 1 $ 8! SHoMysm gitad! 401"S S"#. S+25 7" 7) IMHTS )S" Sesed Sess 1 + MSTborn bo o+ Im#s,)$" ") B4") & 1 1 &BR 1 7 > / ( ' &" ) $ %)StO 8 9 G"HHSe5 1 !6: ($"# &%)leS )S" 1/$ $ S Sh BMH Sr sum or iM(S"# est / / ) IHS" SkgaM(S S$" !

1 SMHS" BS2S+ * $+ (S"# $$ )*DNTHSS 1 B)4 $+2$.*8)*% )IMSE 1 +" S$" 1 +" YS IMS S)*% $ SES+ Po" 4d4 $428. ! +" "HSM 1 4." SES+ *7S & BF 1S CINHESHH.)S2B"eB 7 YIM & 1 St SMH 1S 1 + ME* KES MSLHalaman 3 dari 8 halaman PutusanNo.0952/Pat.G/2014/PA.Smp4 $+25S * I rss y S+ SUH#H#ES ! + ou wesw ! + ryrm s"+S "Ze 1 S & KI, SY ESURI1G! ! + ou rwes,7)s" I + "sg"1 /! SSS" (S oe + pwn + kL owe ! KIL Gg Sko4 wey S J" ('S"(8$ ! +" 6 ! 7)S *IGSMH#) T+ I"#S" &S)S4&SGSS" *KI+S"H##ES +" $$) S$ JES(S"S 1!

S 1 17425 SSK o" SUHAr Sug$+" 6 , $$& 4773 3 1 $7 SM 11S" St Sem 6, $*S& B84" 13 3 SES*S 1) eH YS I"S BT 1 + mSm1 +" $$ %)$"8yis"I" S"#.S+2$ glt )$ I"S 1! )S S$ BME 1 Sr) GSES %1 )$2"S".S)$ ! $*$ )S" SBSS(S 7: " S"#4 " SMH 0 6$+7" Bo oI" S"# 1 $ BES" #S S *ISHSS SS 168+ BTS+ LN" sveq " gue O05 $+" 8 S$" 1 S)+elmesn o" SmEa SmtO Str" eI 1S 89($ 1 )$ $ BI$")$")! $5 2 +8I"HS"HES F1H#SES 1 $7 SM 1 7" guegrm guagm (gn# 1 gS)!

FAA 7M ry om S r4eysm SES)*S' $,cS !4+8 $ 17 4A : % 1 S$" *Z SUE INES SESH#5 S$ 7 Uwl dbel=