STEPHANE BAUDOIN VS PT ORIGIN RESORT LOMBOK

ORIGIN RESORT LOMBOK

(ROO) Form E atau Surat Keterangan Asal Barang Form E, yangdiatur secara rinci dalam Revised Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) For(a)(b)(c)(d)(e)The Rules Of Origin Of The AseanChina Free Trade Area.bahwa berdasarkan Appendix 1: Revised Operational Certification Procedures (OCP)For The Rules Of Origin Of The AseanChina Free Trade Area pada Rule 7dinyatakan The Issuing Authorities shall, to the best of their competence and ability,carry out proper examination of each application for the

Certificate of Origin (Form E)to ensure that:The application and the Certificate of Origin (Form E) are duly completed in accordance with therequirements as defined in the overleaf notes of the Certificate of Origin (Form E), and signed by theauthorised signatory,The origin of the product is in conformity with the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA,The other statements of the Certificate of Origin (Form E) correspond to supporting documentaryevidence submitted,Description, quantity and weight of products

, marks and number of packages, number and kinds ofpackages, as specified, conform to the products to be exported,Multiple items declared on the same Certificate of Origin (Form E) shall be allowed subject to thedomestic laws, regulations and administrative rules of the importing Party provided each item mustqualify separately in its own right.bahwa berdasarkan angka 4 overleaf notes Attachment C Annex 3 Rules of Origin forThe ASEANChina Free Trade Area dinyatakan Each Article Must Qualify: It shouldbe

Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E131300018710187 tanggal 03 Juli 2013,T.3.

Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E131300018710018 tanggal 11 Januari2013,P.23.

(ROO) Form E atau Surat Keterangan Asal Barang Form E, yangdiatur secara rinci dalam Revised Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) ForThe Rules Of Origin Of The ASEANChina Free Trade Area.bahwa berdasarkan Appendix 1: Revised Operational Certification Procedures (Ocp)For The Rules Of Origin Of The ASEANChina Free Trade Area pada Rule 7dinyatakan The Issuing Authorities shall, to the best of their competence and ability,carry out proper examination of each application for the Certificate of

Origin (Form E)to ensure that:The application and the Certificate of Origin (Form E) are duly completed in accordance with therequirements as defined in the overleaf notes of the Certificate of Origin (Form E), and signed by theauthorised signatory,The origin of the product is in conformity with the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA,The other statements of the Certificate of Origin (Form E) correspond to supporting documentaryevidence submitted,Description, quantity and weight of products, marks and

number of packages, number and kinds ofpackages, as specified, conform to the products to be exported,Multiple items declared on the same Certificate of Origin (Form E) shall be allowed subject to thedomestic laws, regulations and administrative rules of the importing Party provided each item mustqualify separately in its own right.bahwa berdasarkan Annex 3: Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) For TheRules Of Origin Of The ASEANChina Free Trade Area pada Rule 3 dinyatakanWithin the meaning

ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E133707004540300 tanggal 13 Juni 2013;Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E123707004540098 tanggal 25 Mei 2012;Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E133707004540054 tanggal 15 Maret 2013;Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E123707004540357 tanggal 24 November 2012;Peraturan Menteri Keuangan Nomor: 117/PMK.011/2012 tanggal 10 Juli 2012 tentang PenetapanTarif Bea Masuk Dalam Rangka ASEANChina Free Trade Area (ACFTA);Surat Edaran Direktur Jenderal Bea dan

Certificate of Origin ATIGA (Form D) Nomor: 0001/HMC/02/2010 tanggal 14 Februari 2010;24. NPWP: 01.305.691.6091.000 tanggal 14 November 1982;25. Angka Pengenal Importir Umum (APIU) Nomor: 090304862P tanggal 16 Januari 2013;26. Nomor Identitas Kepabeanan (NIK): 05.000043 tanggal 26 September 2013;27. Letter of Confirmation tanggal 09 Juni 2014;28. Product Composition Itemized Statement tanggal 29 Maret 2013;29.

1 dijelaskan:Rule 1 DefinitionsFor the purposes of this Annex:Back to back certificate of origin means a certificate of origin issued by anintermediate exporting member state based on the certificate of origin issued by thefirst exporting member state;bahwa dalam Annex 8 Operational Certification Procedure for The Rules of OriginUnder Chapter 3, rule 11 disebutkan bahwa:Rule 11 Back to back certificate of originThe Issuing authority of the intermediate member state may issue a Back to backcertificate

of origin in an application is made by the exporter, provided that:a valid origin (form D) is presented.

In the case where no original certificate of origin(Form D) is presented, its certified true copy shall be presented;the back to back certificate of origin issued should contain some of the sameinformation as the original certificate of origin (form D). In particular, every comumnin the back to back certificate of origin should be completed.

FOB price of theintermediate member state in box 9 should also be reflected in the Back to backcertificate of origin;For partial export shipments, the partial export value shall be shown instead of the fullvalue of the original certificate of origin (form D).

The intermediate member state willensure thet the total quantity reexported under the partial shipment does not exceedthe total quantity of the certificate of origin (form D) from the first member state whenapproving the back to back certificate of origin to the exporters;In the event thet the information is not complete and/or circumvention is suspected,the final importing member state (s) could request that the original certificate of origin(form D) be submitted to their respective customs authority

terhadap penetapanTarif Bea Masuk atas jenis barang berupa PP Cosmoplene AX668, Negara asalSingapore, yang diberitahukan oleh Pemohon Banding dengan PemberitahuanImpor Barang (PIB) Nomor: 203216 tanggal 23 Mei 2013 dengan Tarif Bea Masuksebesar 0% (ATIGA), dan yang ditetapbkan Terbanding menjadi Tarif Bea Masuksebesar 10% (MFN);Menurut Terbanding : bahwa atas jenis barang PP Cosmoplene AX668 diklasifikasikan pada pos tarif3902.30.9010 yang tercantum pada Form D nomor 20136050687 tanggal 13 Mei2013, Origin

criteria CTC, sesuai pertimbangan dari Article 28 ATIGA, Annex 3Product Specific Rules For The Rules of Origin Under Chapter 3, tidak memenuhikriteria CTC (a change in tariff classification), sehingga Form D nomor 20136050687tanggal 13 Mei 2013 dinyatakan tidak berlaku.

Dan origin kriteriaseperti yang dicantumkan pada kolom 8 adalah CTH;bahwa ada box 8 Form D mencantumkan CTH seperti unumnya shipment PemohonBanding dari Singapore dengan HS kode 3902.30 adalah berdasarkan kriteria dariArticle 28 ATIGA, Annex 3 Product Specific Rules for the Rules of Origin UnderChapter 3 dan sudah memenuhi criteria CTC (a change in tariff Classification);Adanya konfirmasi dari DirectorGeneral of customs Singapore bahwa HS kode390230 menenuhi kriteria untuk di expor dengan menggunakan

fasilitas ATIGA.Menurut Majelis : bahwa menurut Terbanding, atas jenis barang PP Cosmoplene AX668diklasifikasikan pada pos tarif 3902.30.9010 yang tercantum pada Form D nomor20136050687 tanggal 13 Mei 2013, Origin criteria CTC, sesuai pertimbangan dariArticle 28 ATIGA, Annex 3 Product Specific Rules For The Rules of Origin UnderChapter 3, tidak memenuhi kriteria CTC (a change in tariff classification), sehinggaForm D nomor 20136050687 tanggal 13 Mei 2013 dinyatakan tidak berlaku.

dengan PIB nomor 203216 tanggal 23 Mei 2013 tidak dapatdiberikan preferensi tarif BM dalam kerangka ATIGA sesuai Peraturan MenteriKeuangan RI nomor Nomor 208/PMK.01 1/2012 tanggal 17 Desember 2012;bahwa Pemohon Banding tidak setuju dengan penetapan Terbanding karena menurut Pemohon Banding,pada box 8 Form D mencantumkan CTH seperti umumnya shipment Pemohon Banding dari Singaporedengan HS kode 3902.30 adalah berdasarkan kriteria dari Article 28 ATIGA, Annex 3 Product Specific Rulesfor the Rules of Origin

Nomor PutusanPengadilan PajakJenis PajakTahun PajakPokok SengketaMenurutTerbandingMenurut Pemohon :BandingMenurut MajelisPut56846/PP/M.X VIIB/19/2014Bea Masuk2013bahwa yang menjadi pokok sengketa adalah pengajuan banding terhadap pembebanan bemasuk karena Form D dalam skema Asean Trade In Goods Agreement (ATIGA), hanyadituliskan uraian barang secara global dengan origin criteria nya RVC97,07%, sehinggatidak memenuhi ketentuan dan preferential dibatalkan serta tarif bea masuk dikembalikartarif bea

Barang: 3 jenis barang sesuai lembarlanjutan PIB, Jumlah Barang: 21,062 Kgm, Negara Asal: Malaysia, diberitahukan dalamPIB Nomor 282861 tanggal 12 Juli 2013, yang ditetapkan dalam Keputusan TerbandingNomor KEP5714/KPU.01/2013 tanggal 20 September 2013;bahwa PIB Nomor 282861 tanggal 12 Juli 2013 menggunakan fasilitas Form D NomorPP13857V121258 tanggal 2 Juli 2013 dalam skema ASEAN Trade In Goods Agreem(ATIGA), namun Form D tersebut hanya dituliskan uraian barang secara global (PolyesteFilm) dengan origin

Origin Criteriongoods (including quantity where appropriate (see overleaf Notes)and HS number of the importing country)41 pallet (General) RVC,97.07%Polyester FilmHS Code: 3920.69.00.00 bahwa berdasarkan Point 4 Overleaf Notes Form D ATIGA menyatakan:"Each article must qualify: it should be noted that all the products in a consignment nqualify separately in their own right. This is of particular relevance when similiar artiof different size or spare parts are sent."

"Multiple items declared on the same certificate or origin (Form D) shall be alloprovided that each item must qualifies separately in its own right"bahwa berdasarkan penelitian di atas, Form D tersebut hanya dituliskan uraian barsecara global (Polyester Film) dengan origin criterianya RVC97,07% yang mseharusnya dituliskan untuk masingmasing barang sebagaimana invoice dengan orcriteria sesuai dengan masingmasing barang tersebut;bahwa telah dikirim surat pemberitahuan penolakan penggunaan tarif dalam

criterianya RVC97,07% yang mana harusdituliskan untuk masingmasing barang sebagaimana invoice dengan origin criteria semasingmasing barang tersebut;bahwa origin criteria RVC 97,07% pada kolom 8 sudah mewakili kriteria asal Polyester Film" yang terdiri dari 3 ukuran yang barangnya sama yaitu Polyester Filmtidak sedikitpun mengurangi nilai substansi dari kriteria asal yang secara fakta keseluruadalah RVC97,07%;bahwa secara keseluruhan barang impor Pemohon Banding telah memenuhi sypreferential tarif

Pada Form E tertera origin criteria WO untuk produk Modular ChillerModel CLSF 130 CU/S C/W Accessories (pos 8418),d. Atas produk Modular Chiller Model CLSF 130 CU/S C/W Accessories(pos 8418) dimungkinkan terdapat berbagal komponen material non origindari China, sehingga kriteria origin seharusnya bukan WO.bahwa berdasarkan Annex 3 Rules of Origin (ROO) for ACFTA:a. Produk yang digolongkan dalam origin criteria WO adalah produk hasilbumi, binatang hidup atau dihasilkan dan air, tanah, bumi,b.

Pada attachment B Product Spesific Rule, atas deskripsi produk ModularChiller Model CLSF 130 CU/S C/W Accessories HS Code 8418.69, origincriteria adalah bukan WO.Bahwa berdasarkan Annex 3, Rules of Origin of The ACFTA Rule 16:a. The importing party may request a retroactive check at random and/orwhen it has resonable doubt as to the authenticity of the document or as tothe accuracy of the information regarding the true origin of the products inquestion or of certain parts thereof,b.

Criteria) pada Form E, menurut PemhonBanding sesuai dengan buku Pusdiklat Bea dan Cukai 2013 yang disusun olehDedi Abdul Hadi, S.H., M.Si., adalah sebagai berikut:Origin Criteria Wholly Obtained atau Wholly Produced merupakan salahsatu dari origin criteria yang ada, dimana pada intinya adalah bahwa negarayang terlibat dalam pengadaan atau produksi barang tersebut hanya satunegara (seluruh komponen bahan bakunya berasal dari satu negara dandiproduksi sendiri).bahwa barang impor tersebut di atas pada

saat penghitungan penjualan kepadaend user / pembeli, Pemohon Banding sudah tidak menghitung pajak beamasuk impor, karena barang tersebut Pemohon Banding impor ari CHina (adafasilitas Form E/ACFTA).bahwa Pemohon Banding sebagai importir berharap Terbanding dapatmembuktikan secara transparan pembuktiannya dari penerbit Form E tersebutdi atas.bahwa sesuai Appendix I Operational Certification Procedure for the RulesOf Origin, Rule 12 Where the origin of a good is not in doubt, the discoveryof minor

discrepancies, between the statements made in a Certificate ofOrigin and those made in the documents submitted to the customs authority ofthe importing party for the purpose of carrying out the formalities forimporting the good shall not ipso facto invalidate the certificate of origin, if itdoes in fact correspond to the good submitted.bahwa sesuai Appendix I Attachment A Revised Operational CertificationProcedures (OCP) for The Rules of Origin of The Asean China Free TradeArea Rule 17(a) kiranya

.01/2013 tanggal 19 Juni 2013 dan mohon kiranya Permohonan BandingPemohon Banding ini dikabulkan sehingga perhitungan SPTNP menurut PemohonBanding adalah tidak terutang Nihil.bahwa sesuai Keputusan Terbanding Nomor: KEP3621/KPU.01/2013 tanggal 19 Juni2013, berdasarkan penelitian terhadap Form E Nomor: E133105200640222 tanggal 22Februari 2013, terdapat keraguan atas tanda tangan pejabat yang menandatangani Form Edibandingkan dengan Specimen Signatures of Officials Authorized to Issue Certificateof Origin

of The Peoples Republic of China and Specimen Official Seals dariGuangdong EntryExit Inspection And Quarantine Beureau of The Peoples Republic ofChina;bahwa berdasarkan REVISED OPERATIONAL CERTIFICATIONPROCEDURES FOR THE RULES OF ORIGIN OF THE ASEANCHINA FREETRADE AREA, disebutkan:Rule 2The Certificate of Origin Form E) shall be issued by the Issuing Authorities of theexporting Party;Rule 18 (a)The Customs Authority oflthe importing Party may request a retroactive check atrandom and/or when it has

reasonable dbubt as to the authenticity of the document oras to the accuracy of the information regarding the true origin of the products inquestion or of certain parts thereof,(i) The request shall be made in writing, accompanied with a copy of theCertificate of Origin (Form E) and shall Specify the reasons and anyadditional information suggesting that the particulars given on the saidCertificate of Origin (Form E) may be inaccurate, unless the retroactivecheck is requested on a random basis.

Rule 23, Appendix 1, Attachment A, Revised Operational CertificationProcedures (OCP) For The Rules of Origin of The AseanChina FreeTrade Area, menyatakan :The Customs Authority of the importing Party shall accept aCertificate of Origin (Form E) in cases where the sales invoice isissued either by a company located in a third country or by anACFTA exporter for the account of the said company, provided thatthe product meets the requirements of the Rules of Origin for theACFTA.

The third party invoice number should be indicated in Box 10of the Certificate of Origin (Form E), the exporter and consignee mustbe located in the Parties and the copy of the third party invoice shallbe attached to the Certificate of Origin (Form E) when presenting tothe Customs Authority of the importing Party.bahwa berdasarkan pemeriksaan Majelis atas buktibukti yangdisampaikan di dalam persidangan, kedapatan sebagai berikut :bahwa berdasarkan pemeriksaan Majelis atas PIB Nomor 013723 tanggal12

E114700BH5610014 26122011Certificate of Origin E114700BH5610015 26122011Certificate of Origin E114700BH5610016 26122011Certificate of Origin E114700BH5610017 26122011Certificate of Origin E11470ZC40230651 29122011 bahwa berdasarkan pemeriksaan Majelis atas Invoice Nomor150446702, 150446684, 150446692, 150446693, 150446694,150446695, 150446696, 150446698, 150446699, 150446683, dan150446700 tanggal 26 Desember 2011 yang diterbitkan oleh BrooksSport, Inc. yang beralamat di 19910 North Creek Parkway

meets therequirements of the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA.

The third partyinvoice number should be indicated in Box 10 of the Certificate of Origin(Form E), the exporter and consignee must be located in the Partiesand the copy of the third party invoice shall be attached to theCertificate of Origin (Form E) when presenting to the CustomsAuthority of the importing Party. tidak terpenuhi sehingga dengan demikian tidak dapat diberikanpreferensi tarif berdasarkan ACFTA.

barang sesuaidengan PIB), negara asal China, yang diberitahukan oleh Pemohon Banding dengan PemberitahuanImpor Barang (PIB) Nomor: 124554 tanggal 02 April 2013 Pos Tarif 3921.90.9000 ditetapkan menjadiPembebanan Tarif Bea Masuk (MEN) sebesar 10%;bahwa menurut Terbanding, berdasarkan penelitian terhadap Form E Nomor: E133307319220018tanggal 18 Maret 2013 terdapat keraguan atas tanda tangan yang tertera pada form E dibandingkandengan "Specimen Signatures of Officials Authorized to issue Certificate of Origin

Certificate Of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E133307319220018 tanggal18 Maret 2013;3. Surat Head of Customs Office of Tanjung Priok Nomor: S1520/KPU.01/2013tanggal 17 April 2013 perihal Confirmation on Certificate of Origin;4. Surat Zhejiang EntryExit Inspection and Quarantine of The People's Republic ofChina Nomor: 33000013142 tanggal 17 Januari 2013 perihal Verification ofForm E Nomor: E133307319220018;bahwa bukti/dokumen pendukung Pemohon Banding adalah sebagai berikut:1.

(ROO) Form E atau Surat Keterangan Asal Barang Form E, yang diatursecara rinci dalam Revised Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) For The Rules Of Origin OfThe AseanChina Free Trade Area;bahwa berdasarkan Appendix I: Revised Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) For The RulesOf Origin Of The AseanChina Free Trade Area pada Rule 7 dinyatakan The Issuing AuthoritiesShall, to the best of their competence and ability, carry out proper examination of each application forthe Certificate of

Origin (Form E) to ensure that:a) The application and the Certificate of Origin (Form E) are duly completed in accordance withthe requirements as defined in the overleaf notes of the Certificate of Origin (Form E), andsigned by the authorised signatory;b) The origin of the product is in conformity with the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA;c) The other statements of the Certificate of Origin (Form E) correspond to supportingdocumentary evidence submitted;d) Description, quantity and weight of products

, marks and number of packages, number andkinds of packages, as specified, conform to the products to be exported;e) Multiple items declared on the same Certificate of Origin (Form E) shall be allowed subject tothe domestic laws, regulations and administrative rules of the importing Party provided eachitem must qualify separately in its own right;bahwa berdasarkan Annex 3: Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) For The Rules Of Origin OfThe AseanChina Free Trade Area pada Rule 3 dinyatakan Within

Bureau Of The People's Republic Of China dengan Nomor: Ref.33000013117 tanggal 14 Juni 2013 yang merupakan jawaban konfirmasiSurat Nomor: S3558/WBC.10/KPP.MP.01/2013 tanggal 24 April 2013.bahwa Terbanding menyatakan alasan penolakan keberatan PemohonBanding karena berdasarkan penelitian terhadap Form E Nomor:E133306049670002 tanggal 07 April 2013, kedapatan halhal sebagai berikut:bahwa dasar permasalahan adalah pengguguran Form E (fasilitas ACFTA)karena diragukannya Kriteria Ketentuan Asal Barang (Origin

Criterion) padakolom 8 karena tidak sesuai dengan Annex 3, Rules of Origin for the AseanChina Free Trade Area, Rule 3: Wholly Obtained Products sehingga terhadapimportasi barang pemohon diberlakukan tarif bea masuk yang berlaku umum(MEN).bahwa Pemohon Banding tidak setuju atas pembebanan yang dilakukanTerbanding bahwa pembebanan BM 0% (ACFTA) yang tercantum didalamPIB Nomor: 035457 tanggal 22 April 2013 menurut hemat Pemohon Bandingsudah benar karena telah memenuhi syarat yang ditetapkan PMK RI

CoOperations between The Association Of South Asian Nations and ThePeoples Republic Of China (persetujuan kerangka kerja mengenai kerjasamaekonomi menyeluruh antara negaranegara anggota Asosiasi BangsaBangsaAsia Tenggara dan Republik Rakyat China) (lembaran negara RepublikIndonesia Tahun 2004 Nomor 50) dalam melaksanakan kerjasama ACFTAdimaksud disepakati untuk menggunakan Rule Of Origin (ROO) Form E atauSurat Keterangan Asal Barang Form E, yang diatur secara rinci dalamOperational Certification

Procedures (OCP) for the Rules of Origin of theAseanChina Free Trade Area.bahwa PMK Nomor: 117/PMK.011/2012 tanggal 10 Juli 2012 tentangPenetapan Tarif Bea Masuk dalam Rangka ACFTA yang mulai berlaku padatanggal 10 Juli 2012, merupakan pelaksanaan dari Pasal 13 ayat (1) UndangUndang Nomor 10 Tahun 1995 tentang Kepabeanan sebagaimana telahdiubah dengan UndangUndang Nomor 17 Tahun 2006 menyebutkan beamasuk dapat dikenakan berdasarkan tarif yang besarnya berbeda dengan yangdimaksud dalam Pasal 12 ayat

For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall bedeemed to be originating and eligible for preferential concessions if theyconform to the origin requirements under any one of the following:Products which are wholly obtained or produced as set out and defined inRule 3; orProducts not wholly produced or obtained provided that the said products areeligible under Rule 4, Rule 5 or Rule 6.bahwa pada Rule

Bahwa berdasarkan "Attachment A: Operational Certification Procedures ForThe Rules Of origin Of The AseanChina Free Trade Area" pada Rule 6disebutkan sebagai berikut:"Rule 6The Government authorities designated to issue the Certificate of Origin shall,to the best of their competence and ability, carry out proper examinationupon each application for the Certificate of Origin to ensure that:e) The application and the Certificate of Origin are duly completed and signed bythe authorised signatory;f)

The origin of the product is in conformity with the ASEANChina Rules of Origin;g) The other statements of the Certificate of Origin correspond to supportingdocumentary evidence submitted;h) Description, quantity and weight of goods, marks and number of packages,number and kinds of packages, as specified, conform to the products to beexported."

tanda tangan pada Form E tidak sesuai denganspecimen tanda tangan pejabat yang berwenang dari Sichuan EntryExit InspectionAnd Quarantine Bereau Of The People's Republic Of China dan Terbanding telahmelakukan konfirmasi atas keabsahan Form E tersebut sesuai Surat Kepala KantorPelayanan Utama Bea dan Cukai Tipe A Tanjung Priok kepada Sichuan EntryExitInspection and Quarantine Bureau of The Peoples Republic of China Nomor: S937/KPU.01/2012 tanggal 22 Juni 2012 perihal Confirmation on Certificate of Origin

ini;bahwa Pemohon Banding menyerahkan Certification dari Sichuan EntryExitInspection and Quarantine Bureau tertanggal 02 Juli 2012 yang menyatakan bahwaForm E Nomor: E125103000155248 tanggal 13 Mei 2012 dengan Invoice Nomor:00002995 tanggal 07 Mei 2012 adalah benar diterbitkan oleh Sichuan EntryExitInspection and Quarantine Bureau;bahwaberdasarkan pemeriksaan Majelis terhadap Form EE Nomor:E125103000155248 tanggal 13 Mei 2012 dan Specimen Signatures of OfficialAuthorized to Issue Certificate of Origin

Second Protocol to Amend the Agreement on Trade in Goods of theFramework Agreement on Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Between TheAssociation of Southeast Asian Nations and The Peoples Republic of China yangditandatangani oleh Menteri Perdagangan Mari Elka Pangestu pada tanggal 29Oktober 2010 di Hanoi, Vietnam, dimana pada article 3 menyatakan bahwa Thisprotocol shall enter into force on 1 January 2011, pada Attachement A Rule 11Revised Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) For The Rules of Origin

of TheASEANChina Free Trade Area menyatakan In principle, a Certificate of Origin(Form E) shall be issued prior to or at the time of shipment;: bahwa sesuai keputusan keberatan Nomor: KEP3601/KPU.01/2011 tanggal 19 Juli2011, berdasarkan penelitian, barang diekspor sesuai tanggal pengapalan pada Billof Lading No.

of The ASEANChina Free Trade Area menyatakan /n principle, aCertificate of Origin (Form E) shall be issued prior to or at the time of shipment;Menimbangbahwa dalam Peraturan Menteri Keuangan No. 235/PMK.011/2008 tanggal 23Desember 2008 tentang Penetapan Tarif Bea Masuk Dalam Rangka ASEANChinaFree Trade Area (ACFTA) disebutkan: Pasal 1 Ayat (1)Menetapkan Tarif Bea Masuk atas impor barang dari negara Republik RakyatCina dan negaranegara ASEAN dalam rangka ASEANChina Free Trade Area(ACFTA) untuk tahun

In exceptional cases where the Certificate of Origin (Form E) has not beenissued by the time of shipment or no later than three (3) days from the date ofshipment, at the request of the exporter, the Certificate of Origin (Form E) shall beissued retroactively in accordance with the domestic laws, regulations andadministrative rules of the exporting Party within twelve (12) months from the date ofshipment, in which case it is necessary fo indicate ISSUED RETROACTIVELY?

inBox 13.bahwa bahwa menurut pendapat Majelis, berdasarkan revisi terhadap OperationalCertification Procedures for The Rules of Origin of The ASEANChina Free TradeArea tersebut, menjadi jelas bahwa Form E diterbitkan sebelum tanggal pengapalanatau pada saat pengapalan;bahwa Revised Operational Certification Procedures for The Rules of Origin of TheASEANChina Free Trade Area tersebut telah diratifikasi oleh Pemerintah RepublikIndonesia dengan Peraturan Presiden Nomor: 37 Tahun 2011 dan telahdiundangkan

SengketaMenurutTerbandingMenurut Pemohon :BandingMenurut MajelisPut50619/PP/M.XVIIB/19/2014Bea Masuk2013bahwa yang menjadi pokok sengketa adalah pengajuan banding terhadap pembebanan beamasuk oleh Terbanding terhadap klasifikasi 8481.80.91.00 berdasarkan penelitian terhadapForm E Nomor: E134407H40660010 tanggal 26 Maret 2013, terdapat keraguan atas OriginCriteria yang tertera pada Form E karena barang dalam sub heading 8481.80 tidak termasukdalam kategori Wholly Obtain berdasarkan Rule 3 Rule of Origin

ACFTA, barang yangdiimpor adalah Water Tap A801T 2 ...dst, (18 jenis barang sesuai dengan PIB), jumlahbarang: 1136 CT, negara asal: China diberitahukan dalam PIB Nomor: 133828 tanggal 9April 2013, dengan uraian sebagai berikut:Menurut Pemohon Banding: klasifikasi 8481.80.91.00 BM 0%;Menurut Terbanding : klasifikasi 8481.80.91.00 BM 5%;bahwa berdasarkan ketentuan di atas serta berkaitan dengan keraguan atas Origin Criteriayang tertera pada form E, maka telah dilakukan konfirmasi (retroactive check

telah ditandatangani oleh pejabat yang berwenang di Chinadan seharusnya Pemohon Banding tidak dikenakan BM sebesar 5% untuk HS Code8481.80.91.00;bahwa semua material, pekerja dan lainlain adalah benar berasal dari China dan bukan darinegara lain karena Form E telah ditandatangani oleh pejabat yang berwenang di China;bahwa Terbanding menyatakan alasan penolakan keberatan Pemohon Banding karenaberdasarkan penelitian terhadap Form E Nomor: E134407H40660010 tanggal 26 Maret2013, terdapat keraguan atas origin

Criteria yang tertera padaForm E karena dalam sub heading 8481.80 tidak termasuk dalam kategori WholeObtained berdasarkan rule of origin ACFTA;e Huruf i:bahwa berdasarkan uraian di atas, dikarenakan terdapat keraguan atas Form E yangdilampirkan serta belum terdapat jawaban resmi atas konfirmasi, maka atasimportasi yang dilakukan tidak dapat diberikan preferensi tarif BM dalam rangkaskema ACFTA, sehingga diberlakukan tarif yang berlaku umum;. bahwa menurut Pasal 16 huruf d, pejabat instansi penerbit

China (all materials used were wholly obtained inChina, the products qualify as Chinese origin);Menimbang kesimpulan pemeriksaan tersebut, Majelis berpendapat bahwa SKA (Form E)Nomor: E134407H40660010 tanggal 26 Maret 2013, dikeluarkan oleh negara pengeksporChina yaitu Guangdong EntryExit Inspection and Quarantine Bureau dan produkproduktersebut dikualifikasikan sebagai origin China sehingga Form E tersebut dapat diterimaatau sah sesuai dengan yang dipersyaratkan dalam rangka penerbitan SKA (Form

Pada tanggal 13 September 2013 telah diterima jawaban atas permintaan retroactive check S5672/KPU.01/2013 yang berisi: In the manufacture of the goods, all the materials used were wholly obtained in China; The goods were intended to be transported to your country when they left China, so meet therequirement of Rules of Origin ACFTA;5.

Invoice: NXH132572, tgl. 2208201310Tidak dicontreng issued retroactively13 Tidak dicontreng Third Party Invoicingbahwa berdasarkan Rule 7 Attachment A Revised Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) For TheRules Of Origin Of The AseanChina Free Trade Area diketahui bahwa:The Issuing Authorities shall, to the best of their competence and ability, carry out proper examination ofeach application for the Certificate of Origin (Form E) to ensure that:(a) The application and the Certificate of Origin

(Form E) are duly completed in accordance with therequirements as defined in the overleaf notes of the Certificate of Origin (Form E), and signed by theauthorised signatory;(b) The origin of the product is in conformity with the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA;(c) The other statements of the Certificate of Origin (Form E) correspond to supporting documentaryevidence submitted;(d) Description, quantity and weight of products, marks and number of packages, number and kinds ofpackages, as specified,

SKA atau Certificate of Origin, dalam hal ini, Form E yang diterbitkan oleh otoritas Kepabeanan diChina membuktikan bahwa barang tersebut memenuhi ketentuan asal Barang China. Form E sudahdilampirkan dalam PIB;b. Bill of Lading membuktikan bahwa barang tersebut dikirimkan/dikapalkan dari China;c.

Judging from the abovefacts, we are of the opinion that the goods covered by the certificate are of Chinese origin and meet therequirement of Rules of Origin of the ASEANChina Free Trade Area;bahwa berdasarkan pemeriksaan Majelis atas buktibukti yang disampaikan Majelis berkesimpulan FormE Nomor E13800501390317 tanggal 29 Agustus 2013 adalah memenuhi ketentuan dan dapat diterima;bahwa oleh karenanya Majelis berpendapat, penetapan tarif bea masuk untuk 100T Hydraulic Jack,..., ASt, negara asal: China

Tanggal 18 Juni 2013,Print out Sistem Informasi dan Administrasi Pelayanan untuk Spesimen wilayah Hengshui,China,Surat EntryExit Inspection and Quarantine of The Peoples Republic of China Nomor:120035T tanggal 30 Agustus 2012 perihal Verification of Certificate of Origin Nomor:E1239B35N4540007,Surat Head of Customs Office of Tanjung Priok Nomor: 996/KPU.01/2012 tanggal 28 Juni2012 perihal Confirmation on Certificate of Origin.bahwa memenuhi permintaan Majelis, Terbanding menyerahkan fotokopibukti

Surat EntryExit Inspection and Quarantine of The Peoples Republic of ChinaNomor: 120035T tanggal 30 Agustus 2012 perihal Verification of Certificateof Origin Nomor: E1239B35N4540007,3.

(ROO) Form E atau Surat Keterangan AsalBarang Form E, yang diatur secara rinci dalam Revised OperationalCertification Procedures For The Rules Of Origin Of The AseanChina FreeTrade Area.bahwa berdasarkan Appendix 1: Revised Operational CertificationProcedures (Ocp) For The Rules Of Origin Of The AseanChina Free TradeArea pada Rule 7 dinyatakan The Issuing Authorities shall, to the best oftheir competence and ability, carry out proper examination of eachapplication for the Certificate of Origin (

Form E) to ensure that:The application and the Certificate of Origin (Form E) are duly completed in accordancewith the requirements as defined in the overleaf notes of the Certificate of Origin (Form E),and signed by the authorised signatory,The origin of the product is in conformity with the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA,The other statements of the Certificate of Origin (Form E) correspond to supportingdocumentary evidence submitted,Description, quantity and weight of products, marks and number

of packages, number andkinds of packages, as specified, conform to the products to be exported,Multiple items declared on the same Certificate of Origin (Form E) shall be allowed subjectto the domestic laws, regulations and administrative rules of the importing Party providedeach item must qualify separately in its own right.bahwa berdasarkan Pasal 1 Peraturan Menteri Keuangan Nomor: 235/PMK.011/2008 tanggal 23 Desember 2008 dinyatakan Menetapkan TarifBea Masuk atas impor barang dari negara Republik

sebesar 0%, menggunakan Form E Nomor:E133708004520015 tanggal 27 Maret 2013;bahwa sesuai Keputusan Terbanding Nomor: KEP3675/KPU.01/2013 tanggal 20 Juni 2013, berdasarkanpenelitian, importasi SX5251GJBM364 Concrete Transit Mixer, Negara asal China, yang diimpor denganPIB Nomor: 139419 tanggal 11 April 2013, sesuai Form E Nomor E133708004520015 tanggal 27 Maret2013, terdapat keraguan atas stempel pada Form E dibandingkan dengan "Specimen Signatures of OfficialsAuthorized to issue Certificate of Origin

(Form E) to ensure that:a) The application and the Certificate of Origin (Form E) are duly completed in accordance with therequirements as defined in the overleaf notes of the Certificate of Origin (Form E), and signed bythe authorised signatory;b) The origin of the product is in conformity with the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA;c) The other statements of the Certificate of Origin (Form E) correspond to supporting documentaryevidence submitted;d) Description, quantity and weight of products, marks

Kedutaan Besar Republik Indonesia Beijing Nomor: 0287/UM/K/02/13/09 tanggal 08 Februari 2013 perihal Verifikasi Form E No E123708004520057;SPPB Nomor: 455457/KPU.01/2011 tanggal 02 Desember 2011;Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E123708004520002 tanggal 10 Januari 2012;SPPB Nomor: 027287/KPU.01/2012 tanggal 30 Januari 2012;Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E123708004520035 tanggal 04 Juni 2012;SPPB Nomor: 260168/KPU.01/2012 tanggal 26 Juni 2012;Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form

E) Nomor: E123708004520063 tanggal 27 September 2012;SPPB Nomor: 424102/KPU.01/2012 tanggal 18 Oktober 2012;Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E113708004520057 tanggal 12 November 2011;Brosur;Keterangan Perusahaan;Surat Keberatan Nomor: 009/IMPEA/IV/13/0 tanggal 23 April 2013;SSPCP tanggal 09 April 2013 sebesar Rp 1.190.689.000,00 (PIB);SSPCP tanggal 28 Juni 2013 sebesar Rp 535.802.000,00 (Keputusan Terbanding);NPWP: 02.704.662.2439.000;Akta Notaris Nomor: 03 tanggal 02 Juli 2007;20.

Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E133708004520015 tanggal 27 Maret 2013;38. Permohonan Pengiriman Uang Bank BCA tanggal 20 Maret 2013 sebesarUSD184,000.00;39. Purchase Contract Nomor: AH2011Z1016 tanggal 05 Juli 2011;40. Surat Kedutaan Besar Republik Indonesia di Beijing Nomor: 1676/UM/K/08/13/09 tanggal 13Agustus 2013 perihal Verifikasi Form E No.

Putusan Pengadilan Pajak Nomor: Put56093/PP/M.XVIIB/19/2014Jenis PajakTahun PajakPokok SengketaMenurut Terbanding:: Bea Masuk: 2013: bahwa yang menjadi pokok sengketa adalah pengajuan banding terhadap koreksiadanya pembebanan bea masuk karena keraguan atas pemenuhan ketentuanmengenai Origin Criteria, sehingga tidak sesuai dengan ketentuan Overleaf NoteRules Of Origin for The AseanChina Free Trade Area (ACFTA) atas importasiJenis Barang: Knitted Fabric, Jumlah Barang: 1,042 Roll, Negara Asal:China

tanggal 31Juli 2013, dan belum diterima jawaban dari pihak issuing authority;Menurut Pemohon : bahwa Pemohon Banding telah mengimpor barang dengan PIB Nomor:Menurut Majelis172655 tanggal 3 Mei 2013 preferensi tarif ACFTA, yang kemudian berdasarkanSPTNP Nomor: SP TNP008251/NOTUL/KP UTP/BD.02/2013 tanggal 25 Mei 2013,Pemohon Banding harus membayar tagihan Bea Masuk dan PDRI sejumlahRp36.709.000,00 karena preferensi tarif ACFTA dibatalkan dengan alasan terdapatkeraguan atas pemenuhan ketentuan mengenai Origin

Specific Rules (PSR) pada alternative rulesdisebutkan:"The following criteria shall be applied as alternative rule to the general ruleprescribed in Rule 4 of the ASEANChina PTA Rules of Origin.

Whenapplying for a Certificate of Origin From E, the exporter can use either thegeneral rule prescribed in rule 4 of the ASEANChina FTA Rules of Origin orthe Rules set out in this Attachment."1. Change in Tariff Classification2. Process Criterion for Textile and Textile Products Working or ProcessingCarried Out on Non Originating Materials that Confers Originating Statusa. Fibres and Yarns,b.

Origin Criteria: For exports to the above mentioned countries to be eligible forpreferentia) treatment, the requirement is that either:(iv) Products which satisfy the product specific rules provided for in attachment Bof the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA shall be considered as products to whichsufficient transformation has been carried out in a Party.If the products qualify under the above criteria, the exporter must indicate inBox 8 of this form the origin criteria on the basis of which the claims

PIB) Nomor: 263248 tanggal 01 Juli 2013 yaitu TarifBea Masuk (ACFTA) sebesar BM 5% BBS: 100%, dan yang ditetapkan Terbandingmenjadi Tarif Bea Masuk (Umum/MEN) sebesar 5%;: bahwa dikarenakan belum adanya konfirmasi resmi dari pihak penerbit yang sesuaidengan ketentuan OCR ACFTA maka atas importasi yang dilakukan tidak dapatdiberikan preferensi tarif BM dalam rangka Skema ACFTA, sehingga diberlakukantarif yang berlaku umum sebesar BM 5%;Menurut Pemohon : bahwa sudah benar bila pada kolom 8 Form E (Origin

(ROO) Form E atau Surat Keterangan Asal Barang Form E, yangdiatur secara rinci dalam Revised Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) ForThe Rules Of Origin Of The ASEANChina Free Trade Area.bahwa berdasarkan Appendix 1: Revised Operational Certification Procedures (Ocp)For The Rules Of Origin Of The ASEANChina Free Trade Area pada Rule 7dinyatakan The Issuing Authorities shall, to the best of their competence and ability,carry out proper examination of each application for the Certificate of

Origin (Form E)to ensure that:The application and the Certificate of Origin (Form E) are duly completed in accordance with therequirements as defined in the overleaf notes of the Certificate of Origin (Form E), and signed by theauthorised signatory,The origin of the product is in conformity with the Rules of Origin for the ACFTA,The other statements of the Certificate of Origin (Form E) correspond to supporting documentaryevidence submitted,Description, quantity and weight of products, marks and

number of packages, number and kinds ofpackages, as specified, conform to the products to be exported,Multiple items declared on the same Certificate of Origin (Form E) shall be allowed subject to thedomestic laws, regulations and administrative rules of the importing Party provided each item mustqualify separately in its own right.bahwa berdasarkan Annex 3: Operational Certification Procedures (OCP) For TheRules Of Origin Of The ASEANChina Free Trade Area pada Rule 3 dinyatakanWithin the meaning

Certificate of Origin ACFTA (Form E) Nomor: E133707004540300 tanggal 13 Juni 2013;. SPPB Nomor: 259805/KPU.01/2013 tanggal 01 Juli 2013;.