uens yejepe jeinbie) uep jefnbbueg emuzg 1 JNYL3qreGeqes eyjey ueyeynuebuew yelo 9.0z lew 60 JeBBue AMS Vd/91L0ZD'Wd/PreO wOWON uefuap ndeyeg eweby uejpedsuoy UBelauBdayIp yeyerp Sued eXuueyeinb jens ueBuep jeinb6ueg emyegVavwead wnanaueBuepisied ip yeBnBBueg ueBueisjex JeBuapusu yRejajesueHuepisied ip ueynfeip Bue nyngiping esyeu:ew yealeslu!

ueesyuawued eAuuejef reusbuew emyegUESMING UoYoW WeyYeeAUsW eyes ueyledwesip ueye Bued ping undnewuebuelsjey IBe epe yeon ueyeyeAuoW yebnbbueq eAujniueas eMUEgBAUUBYJEUSGLLAW UBYB22AWOLUjeBn6Buag yngasia syes ered uebuessjoy enwies depeuie emues. liseyseg 4201 1deoyeuld yejeq enpey ueyrewepuaw eyesnieq yecns ebieney emyea9S Iluens jebeqes ueylinpiadwew Guljes ibe; yepy 126nbue uep jebnbbueq ny yelas uep eAueny Buelo yewn oy yebnbBbueeJejuebuew yebnOie ulpuas jeu, isyes JeinBia; yor eAuen:Suelo yew ey Sued

BueIas BemyegYeund Ip epe Sued BuesegHuelegq u@yJnoueybuewuep Yeiew Buues eyes jehnSbueg depeusa) LYM ueynxejsw GBuuesUEP ule! eyueM UehuEp ueynyBuyjesied uexynyejew Buues yeBnbia oyeAuyeueyeue Uep ye6nbBuay depeyseyyexyeu ueqieney onuauliee yep jebnbie; eAuueiBiedey yeles zpeAUeJepnes yeuins Jp jebBuy eI ewesied UBWeIDSyYew Leyebbuluewu Bred yea yeOnGial Soz seqowa az yeles "Lp.

Jel8Qeq YUN iNeYy uedejajayiog yejay eyoious eyif ued, : eAUILAYAO SCoPE AD ny mr optAunqiag Gued /zz yeAe yeiebegly 121ns ueinby wefep Bunpueyie Sued LUIS: WinnyBUWOU UNUSUEW 4215 Jnqesie LuNYNY ener emyeq Bueawuiuayy256ue? yeuinwejep (be; unyns dnoy ueye uedeiey epe yepn eBBuiyas uejeyBusuedUep ueyisissied joelie, Buyes jebnbie, uep jebnGduey elewy zyeue Bueso enp lelunseyip yejay uep yes HuzA ueumexiadEyLI3 Yylseuw GBued ues pis!

Bahwa pada saat pernikahan tersebut wali nikahnya adalah saudara kandung Pemohon IIPemohon II yang bernama SUBADAR, dengan saksi nikah masingmasing bernama H.BARDI dan SUED, serta Maskawin berupa uang sebesar Rp. 50.000, (Lima puluh riburupiah) dibayar tunai, yang akad nikahnya dilakukan antara Pemohon I dengan wali nikahtersebut yang pengucapan ijabnya diwakilkan kepada Ustads bernama Ust. ARIFIN;3.

ANAK PENGGUGAT &TERGOGAT ge see ames cece seme sued 6 aus 6 eee see oes see oeee ate2, ANAK PENGGUGAT &TERGUGAT; 12 3, ANAK PENGGUGAT &TERGUGAT ; yang saat ini berada dalam asuhan Tergugat, yang lahir dariperkawinan antara Penggugat dan Tergugat, dimana Tergugatsebagai Purusa maka sepatutnya anak tersebut berada padaasuhan Tergugat, oleh karena itu maka terhadap petitum point5 dari gugatan Penggugat haruslah dinyatakanditolak ; Menimbang, bahwa sementara itu, dilihat dari sisi yanglain, yaitu sisi

ANAK PENGGUGAT &TERGOGAT ge see ames cece seme sued 6 aus 6 eee see oes see oeee ate2, ANAK PENGGUGAT &TERGUGAT; 3, ANAK PENGGUGAT &TERGUGAT ; ini berada dalam asuhan Tergugat dan keluarga sebagai Purusaadalah mutlak perlu diberikan hak kepada Penggugat untuksetiap saat dapat bertemu danbercengkerama dengan anak tersebut tanpa perlu ijindari Tergugat, untukmencurahkan ~ kasih sayang seorang Ibu terhadap anaknya,demikian sebaliknya terhadap anak tersebut, Hal demikiansesuai bukti P.7 telah pula disetujui

ueuoyouied 6gy gpl jesed ueyesepieq eyew yes Sued ueseje niensWw(yeidny nqu sejagas snjeu eb1)) OOO'LLE dy HvIwnr0009 dy lejayew eAelg000'S dy Isyepal eAelgo00';0zz dy ueiBBued eAeig0000S 38 dy MV/S8SOld ehelg'000'0 dy uelseyepued eAeigNOY "eleyed eAelg UeIDued

AYS'Yd/9 LIZA) Wd P77 ON Nd 124 ST ep 6 eH ule Lendwesed ueBuep wag Cues ye6nGse) pues ye6n66ueg eBienjey uebuep stucuuey Bueinyje6nb.91 ebeyeq sejew yebnbie, euarey yejepe yebnbie, ueBuapyeBnBEue4 eseyue UzieyBueped uep ueuisijesiod qeqasued emyegLOZ ludy ueing Jeyies yelas unwind Hep B/N Neje snusuew snio Sued uezeyHusyed uepueulsiesisd pefia Bullos yebnbie; ueBuep ieSnbbueg evewe BMUEE UBING g UNYeR p INWN eweEXIPUY Ul MAReld MeYWJNN eweuleq Uendwesed yeue Bueso (nes) lelunexip yejo yebnbiey uep

(seeyes) uepBBued jens ueyesepisc emyegmonn nonce ro: njaq lebegas eyye)eyye yedepsa yeja) e1esuad seweg uepyeSn66ueq uehuesey uebuap uexBungnuip eAure; yNq 38,2 uep yeBrEbusyyeyld Wep syesisyes Uuebueleoy UeyWesepiag emued Buequiusyy yebnB5uad jeyepia Buewo neje ebyenjey yeyld wep Isyes4syes UeBIE JayJeBuepLow yea .wyey syafew Lege, unye (IH) Wwejs Wnxny Iszyduuo0yaLtyeBnEse uep AS Ved/9 192/90 WAvFTPO ON Md eu ST wep O FHeAulpelis; uep eAuepe Jeusq emueg UeyyNiUNUeLU yea ney Sued pozUdy uelng seyyes

ANS'd/910Z/O Pd 58H) ON Ind WYRE pL Wep W BHeweby uelpebue4 ueeloyuedsy ip ueyepip Buet gaz weniqed 10je66ue) eAuueyeinB jeins ueBuep jebnbbued emyeg BuequiuayVuavyMdad MNnandueHuepisued ip isyes Bled uep yebnbouey uebuelaiey Jebuspusw yea,ul ereyiad ueBuep ueyeyeg Sued yeunsJ2uns Welejedwaw YyejoyyeBnBaay ingesip eAujnfuejes uisendAvegisn, ualednqey nAeyeas ueyewesoyyeog ueyeleiey TO MY 70 LYip jeBSuyn wediuei ndosg ueehayed qWwWSngesia BueBy uENpeBuaedueyipiouad wes: euebe unye) Zp Inuin ueznyH

JOONBIscuopU Yiqraday SunBy yeweyyeyy ueinjelag uenjusjey eueLUeBegesISBIpeyy Ueeuesyejad eyew ueSuepisied ay sIpey Yyewad yeogyeBnbss euaiey yajo uep jiseysaq yep ideja ueye yebnBie, uebuspleJeoiaq yWuUN jiu ueyBuninBusew Jsebe jebnbbusq epedey yeyeszuUBYUSIWSL euesUed yes wuMyeH sijaleyy emyeq Buequuiualy6g'y (1) yeAe Br jese Lenjuajey eUBLUTeBegas(yasuea) reBnBie eAuipey edue ueyjnfuejip tur sueyed ueesyuawednit Buajex usiQ uebuepisied ip wpey ynitn BaAUesen> reBeqasuse Buelo sninBuew ejnd yepy uep yes Sued

FSO:ynyuaq 1eBeqaes iAunqiegBueA siefeyy jedepued ieheqes ye queip Sued ope ueweyey znyeuuns ubi4 geyy wejep yedepis Bued wes wnyny seyeg yedepued uebueplenses Yele jnqesiea ueseje ny Buidwesip emyeq BbuequiusyueleJeqied yejepe yeqie uejeleyew ehn66ued ibeq ewejnis yeyid yejeq enpey ibeq ueeyweapued ueqegueynquiuew yepy sebe eqs uejef eAueuaey Yao Ibe; Ueypninwip yedepwep Z yeAe winwy yeing uesny'y ebnf uep wejs wnyny iseydwoy jesedof p61 unye sowWON Buepufbuepun 1 jesed pnsyew euewrebeges yewyesuep

jnqosia ueepeay uep 16e ueyUNyruip yedep yep) yepnsuemlwep Gued eb6uey yewns emyeq syaley, ibeq ynfunjed ipefuew e66bulyas( oBewwey usyo1g ) yeja1 Yepns UeDWep BueA eB6ue, yewni uep Wynquey yejeSejeIp ynqesie) euewiebeqes uejng ~ unye) yYiqe; BueJny ewejss reB6unyyedwa yesidieq yes eyes yeBneGie; uebuap yeBnbbue,g esejue ueseyBuapadUep UeuUIsesiod eAuepe Guejus yebnbGueg yajo ueyjepip Buek edeemueq ueyinduiAuew yedep sijafey eyxew yehnbse, uebuap leJaoseq yNJUN HeyuedejajaxJ9q peys ueyxnlunuew Sued

emyeg ebnpic yedep iyed eyewISeuJeq Yepl) Inqesiai enlusas idejo UeBuepisisd weep 1p weyeAed ip yepnsuejeyaseued eAedn uep yebnbie, uebuep ebbue, yewns euiquew i6e) newyep, Sued yeSnB6ueg deyis eyes wajsi tuens eAuyeAe) euswieBeqas euuesieguewelpey yeuwni njes weep jeb6un ibe; yepn yebnbis) uep iefnGbuegeieiue eALyeound uep ueuisijesiod eAUepe ueBusp emyec Buequwius,y4Nyn deja ny UeUIMeyedueyuBuibuew yeyld nyes yejes undiysew uexynyesiedip ynqun 1Be, unSBunwyep, eyeu yeoec Yyepns Lipuss ny ueulmeylied

ueyyejuewsaw eAuls BueA Jewe yequreuaw ned ueipeBued 600zunye OSG JoWON Buepunbuepun ueBuep enpey ueYyeqnied Uep goNz UNYeL Jowoy BuepunSuepuq, uebuep yeqnip yee, eueuwefeges ges, unYyeLZ Jowop, BuepunBueeun pg esed uenjuajey senses emyes HuequiuayyUeYNGeXIP yNJUNeAujyedss yepns wd5rhbueg ueyeinb eyew weyjs; wnynp tsejiduoy (J) JninyOL ISSBq UEP G/B, NYE G JOWON YeIUTEWSEY UBINJelag Yi ynuny 61 yesed olp/BL unye: Joon) BuepunBuepun GQ) jniny z yeAe gE esey ueseeluac yaoIyepusyoxp BueWIeBeqss dnyno Sued

eleoes I66uedip yeja undrysetu eAueseny jem ueyWUIGuew ejnd yep) ueBuepisiedIp depeybuew Bbueyep yewed yep ye6nB6ueq emuec Buequiuayyseje Ip lenaeuewlebeqas jehnhhueq uejyefn6 uenn uep pnsyew emyeg EuequiuayyWAYNH NVONVEWILYAdul Uesnnd Wep ueyyesidia ye ueibeq Ueyedniaw Sued eseoe ejWeq epedayynfunup iu; uesnjnd wejed yenwa winjaq Bue jeyjey emyeq Buequiuayyes Bued ueBuejey njens uexqeqasip ny eAubuejepHepl emyeq eyeAuse yep ueyBuepes Buepis weyjep Ip ueyeoegip eAuuei66uedseejel Hued jnjed uep iwsei

e6Gue uewund euIquiewW Weep sluoWwWeY Uep uNyM dnpiy yryLnyeGnbis; uehuep yeSnGbueg ueylewepuaw uep yeyeseuew yrjuneyesniag Buies yepns yebnoie, uep jebnbbueg ebvenisy emueg indwieyip srueu Sued yreque ueyel yejepe uewoosed uep yeBnBieueBuep eB6ue: yeuins eulquiew ynjun be dnbbues yes ye6nObuagBueseyas ueD yeg ipeluew yeuled yep jnqasis uUeBORey UNLeUuegnioq ueye ueepeey jees nyens uederey uebusep Ww ueepesyueBuer Jeqesiac ynjun eyesnieg yes yeBnbSued Iu!

166uedip yee yeGnGve; emyeg buequiuayy. seye tp (eine) euewiebeqesyeSnifuee ueyesn6B uenini uep pnsyew emyeq buequiueyWNXNH NVONVSAILYAdJul uesnjnd wep ueyyesidia ye ueibeq 1ebeqesNgssiay Bueoxy elWeg yNlunuewW WIyeH syeleyy iu; Uesnind sexSuuawyrjun ebBuiyss Buepig eieoy eyeg luwejep jeyeap eAudeyduajesjul Buexyied ueesyouad eAuueyel jeusbuew emyeq BuequiuayyueSNing UOYyowW UeyejeAuaw uep yeBbnBHieep yesid.eg ulSul nyeA eAuueye6nb eped dejo ueyeyeAuaw yebrdbuegKAD IAG Pa61EO Wid UIA FT 14P 6 MHYISew Sued

JEyejU0yeuns, p jebburt ye6nGse) uep yebnbbued UzPNUSy unLe gz Buenulge BLuBas yefual ever p WIpues yIU Yew Ip jeBGun yeduepec26 uk, UeSUsS yeEnGbueg jngesie ueyexled Yejajes eMyeE a ye yeybis UeydeonbuewUP YHL reve yejajes uep ZL0Z sequeseq C jeBGue:ZL /INIL G/LO MALL 'S0' Ly Jowou YyexyIN epiy uedgny lexidnq' uebuep, yebue emer suldoig uawingey uajedngey Buln UBBWEIOHeweby Jesnin Jouey eped yeleols Bued gg6 Wenuer 9 jeBBuR eped id iLi Mig d)9 S272 IPd/09ZO OWEN UesMjnd UeWeTeY S$ Hep UEWeleH ues Sued

TeBnbbued Jeunse wejep eAuenpay yeLe Suelo (erp) Zz reiunsexipLeal eas 5 Wysiwens eAuyekey eueWeBeges UeBungny UljeluaLu Yye/a Uepinst iwens LeEuesed yejepe jebnOje, uep yebnBGBued emyeg ves Bue, urine yunuawl jes uesee uedJeseplaq ejnd yer eAUUeJIPeyHepeY YesGuek ehuesery nejye yea wi6uels eind yep wey yep) UeGues sued Ipcepeysuoul!

SO'Ge AS Wa'd 02/9 Pd /Z820 9 OL0eNYWEq 1ebeqes ePALYAYOdBued jyepyep nej2 sesejeueseje ueyeynwabuew Yee gLOZ ud8. eBBueLe AYSYe/SL0Z/D Wd/Z8Z0 JOWON eieyWeq sJejsibey weepndeyas ewedy ueipebued ueesayuedsy Ip seyepie, yeis, Sued 91 ozjudy 9g, je6Bueve, efuueuoyouued eins weep uoyowsg emuegVANYdVa dad ANdNG ONVLNALBuepis eynu Ip W4Nq WeleJeje esy JeWwWeW YejoeJeyiadieg Bued yeuld seBuepuew yejae.eyed seyieg wefejadwew uep esequuaw Yyelondqessea Puueby uelipeBueyusuOUUa IeBeqas jnqasipeAuniuziag ulsentueq

eueWwieBeges jnfueyylga UeXINGWUEW Aad Be; yepa UOYOWed uep weusq dedhueiw snieyUOUCWS UPUOYOULed Leseje nejz jijep ejeBas eyew nqesia uoyoWadueuoyoued depeyio, undede ynweq weep ueqemel njens uexnleBuawYEP UeP JIpey ePH UCYOUWe, BUuaIey Yajo emyeq Buequiuay16e; ueyunyN p yyns Sued snuesuewsnie Gues ueseyBuayieduep ueyisyesiac ipefiay Buues uoyouwds) uep UolWueg eeuugseje UueBusp uoycluue) sele yee, ueyynjefuew yniur eAulbeq ulmWaquew jeBbe nfexes eweby ue lpebueg epeday ucyowsw UdYOWsYeAuyoyoc eped

BINS UBWeEsEpleginjed uep jwise) Beoes uEsrBa uaqip eind yela uoyowsey Uuep sigqey Yeduoyouwag Wep eleyied eAeiq joysieA eUdJey Yeo emYeg Buequiuay,UOYSL.3q epedsy ueyuegaqip ueuImMeyied Buepic weepBleyied eAelq enuas eweby uelipeisy Buequel ggg) uUNye / .OLON BuepunBuepun (1) WAY 68 esed uenUaey UeWesepleg emyeg Buequiuslefueseyied ynpnp weep ueylesnip yejo eueLUEBegesYejepe uovowed UeUoYyOUed uenny uep pnsyewW emyeq SuequiuayWTNH NVONVEINILYAdqui uesnind sepueyyesidis yep ued ueibeq ueyednisw Sued

uEWeEZeyBWeGy UBS JojUey YEN TeyeoUad lemehog yao jeeop Bued UBYey WiadLeyGuns6uejau uoyouwa) UEGuap UOYyoWs, 'ZgGL snisnBy co je6bue, epeg +1lIiSOd AY TvdEUSOq4 WE/EC: MEd (eBQes EC WeEp LeynieBuawShOZ smusnGy ge, jebSuey way g/910Z/O IPY/0OL sawON Uebuap Bwig EWedyuepebue, VEEaPUeday Ip Jeyepip Yea BueA UeWOYOUad = uexnfefvaLW Yep) PLOZvenver og eEBGue, eAUBUOYyoWSd jeuns WRIEP Joyous, Bye BuequiuayyVevHe3ad wndndBuepis eyNU IP UOYOUUay UEP LoYyoWe, UPBLEIaay JeBuapuau yes IW) Bieyed Ubvap veyexyeq Sued

ep Hep uexeynwabuew eXAuxoyod eped Guedk sioz Jaquaseg ro jebBueQNS Wd/GLOZ/D Wc/0060 : JOWON JasiBoy uebusp emequing ewebyueypebueq uUeeJayuedey Ip UeyeYyepip Bued SLOZ laquasaq 70jeSBuews eAuueyeGng jyeuns wejep yebnSBused emyeq BuequiuayyVANVYVA ead YNGNG ONVLNAL: UeHuepisiad Ip eAueyap Bueio/ eBlenjay Isyes isyes uep yebnBbueg uefuelajoy seBuepuaw uP,: UejnyBuesieq Sued Jeuns WING yng esyeWeLW yea BAuBleyled seyiag ueleedwauw Uep BORqWISLU YyBay: Nqes/a elUehYy Ue!

wens eAUyeAe) eueWwIeBegas unynJ dnpiuyeje je6nbie, ueBuep jebnbbueg jngasie) ueyeyiuted euugjas emuegpues yebn6Susy yewniIp je66uy yebnbsel uebuep yebnbbueq erejue yeyiu yejales emyeg 666 Jaquiajdagez jeB6ueLe 6661 /XI/SZ/PBlL JowoU emequing uajedngey seyy/ueInuejewesey euweby uesnin sojuey YexIN jeyeoUsqd lemebeq yYajoueyenjayip Sued yeyIN epy uedyny nyng wep eyeAua euewiebeqasemequing uajednqey aauysueIn Ip ueyeyiwied ueyBunsbuejawye6nGie, uebuep yebnS6ueg s66l Jequaldas ez jebbue) eped emueg"ANS

LUaDes Sued Leylsyesied ueepeay EMUEGeuesiad UeWEIpay Ip deze jebnGio eiejuawes 4e6nbbue,y BunpueyyeAe lefeqas isyes UeLInI oy Guejnd yeOnbSued "Be; yeunses jebBuy xepAYEPNS MYYeIO URN weUs WEBS jeGinfue, uep jeGnbbueg yeul Isyes BMYedsngasie yeBnbie, uep jeGnbBbuede6Bue yewinu isioucy BunsBue elevss Wipes inyeyebuew isyes eMUedsnuaolu sme Bued yeBndue, uepyebnGbueg esejue ueuis jeasied eauepe ueHuep unyu yep yejnu jeBnEsel uesyeBnBbus,; ebbue yew weesesy Iuyesay ueinc g Wielep UNLUBU suuouuey UeDunynd

) esejUSeWes eAuenjbuelo Ip yein6Buedye66un yeduwes Hes yepns ye6nbie, uep yebnSbued yeyy Isyes emMYUeq nqesse yebnbie, uep yebnbbueqebbue yewns isipuoy Bunsbue eieoss wipues inyeyjabuew syes emMyeq WYye18 URNG g WEeep SrJeLaLW snaBued yeBnBie, uep jefnBbue ereyue ueuisiesied eAuepe uebuep unxyn Yee LL Hep UGWEEH AYS Ye LOZ/O WPdeB LO WON UeSnndyepy yebn66usy uep seuec defbueip sney ye6n66ueq ueyebn6 ueseje neyesuepwep eyebas eyew uIpey yeph jebndual eucwey emyeq Buequuiusyy168 uUBYyUNYTUIP WIS Sued

MKSDEMI KEADILAN BERDASARKAN KETUHANAN YANG MAHA ESAPengadilan Tinggi Tata Usaha Negara Makassar yang memeriksa dan memutussengketa tata usaha negara dalam tingkat banding, menjatukan putusan sebagai berikutdalam sengketa antara : SANNY MAMONTO, Kewarganegaraan Indonesia, pekerjaan Wiraswata, tempattinggal Jalan Manguni Lingkungan ITV Kecamatan PerkamilKota Manado ; Dalam hal ini diwakili oleh Kuasa Hukumnya : 1 JEM SURIETE, SUED, geecnnnneeceee tees eneenecemeeernte2 EZRI TUMUWO, SH. MH.

eyynfunjip ful vedeyeued Leleun jeyBuissadwew ynjun eAujnfuejas emyegANS W/Z 07/9 Wd/ZZ60 JOWON eAUBIerxJedjnqeousw ueyEjeAuew uebuepisied eyYNUWIP ues eieoes UeuUOYyouUedueynfeBueu. ucyoWeY indesis ueBuepisied eped uelpnusy emMyegyes Sued uebuejey nyens ueyqegasip ny eAUBueep yepy emyed eyeAUJEyep UeyBuepes Sueprs uejep ip ueyeoeqip eAuuelb6ued seejai Bued jnjeduep jluse) eieoas iB6uedip yejay undijsew eAULWuNyNY eseny,)/MeMrebeqesdepeyBuew yritn ule Buejo yninAuew yep uep Buepis eynwaydepeybuaw

edue eWWesiaq ueWeIpey jedweueyjebBbuiuew efebues uefuap uoyouwal ejiqede jenoa* uoyouwe ueWeIpeyyedwe Wndyaw eAuwinyny yejsep BueA eweby uejlpebuesy epedey ueynieipsniey onb e ueuoyouad eyew iwens yeyld yajo ueYNelp Sued je190 UeUOYyoUedyejepe jul eleyied weep yalgo uefunqnyess emuec BuequwiualeAuip je66uy pedaueljeuaqeay ueylpnquew yee eAuepeduep emyeq ueyeyeAulp ejnd smiey uepJul BseyJed Wejep yes Sued 1y4nq JEJE 1leBeqas ewueayip jedep 1.4 Inq JedepusdieqwiyeH siafey) eAueussey yao (epuaepuiq