498 97% 2Z2SQSV 4MH & 42 &OW ()1 /)%(0%2 &)6(%7%6/%2 /)89,%2%2 =%2+ ) 7% ~~e270o16a2 o0, 0(14TRKEHMPER 2IKIVM &IOEWM JERK QIRKEHMPM TIVOEVETIVOEVE 4MHERE TEHE XMRKOEX TIVXEQE HEPEQ EGEVETIQIVMOWEER FMEWE XIPEL QIRNEXYLOER TYXYWER WIFEKEMFIVMOYX HEPEQ TIVOEVE EXEW REQE XIVHEOE XIVHEOEZ2ZEQE PIRKOET 13, 296 %.)

SKYWXYW4TRYRXYX 9O0YQ XERKKEP SKYWXYW 20462 ) TT WINEO XERKKEPSKYWXYW W H XERKKEP SKYWXYW,HOMQ 4IRKEHMPER 2IKIVM &ITOEWM XERKKEP SKYWXYWoe 4TR 4MH & 42 &OW WINEO XERKKEPSKYWXYW W H XERKKEP 7ITXIQFIV4TRKEHMPER 2IKIVM XIVWIFYXSIPEL QIQFEGE FIVOEW TIVOEVESIPEL QIRHIRKEV OIXIVERKER WEOWM WEOWM HERXIVHEOESIPEL QIQTIVLEXMOER FEVERK FYOXM,EP 1 HEVMIO LEP 4YX 4MH 2SSIPEL QIQTIVLEXMOER WIKEPE WIWYEXY ERK XIVNEHMHEPEQ TIVWMHERKER TIVOEVE MRM FIVPERKWYRKSIPEL QIRHIRKEV XYRXYXER 4TRYRXYX 9QOYQXIVLEHET XIVHEOE ERK TEHE

TSOSREQIRIVERKOER WIFEKEM FIVMOYX FELE XIVHEOE QIRIVERKOER XIPEL HMXERKOETSPIL EVKE TEHE LEVM YOEX XERKKEP .

YRMWIOMVE NEO ;MF HM4IVXSOSER SXVMYQ 4SRHSO+IHI &ITOEWMe FELE FIREV FIVEEP TEHE LEVM .YQEX XERKKEP.

FMR 79/61%2XIPEL QIPEOYOERTIRGYVMER TEHE LEVM .YOQEX XERKKER YRM WIOMVE TYOYP;MF OIXMOE XIVHEOE WIHERK FIVNEPER QIPMLEX PMLEX HMATVXSOSER S%SXVMYQ 4SRHSO +IHI /IPYVELER .EXMEVMRKMR/IGEQEXER 4SRHSO +IHI /SXE &IOEWM WEQFMP QIPMLEX PMLEXHMHEPEQ /MSW /PSRXSRK .EJE FEVY XIVHEOE QIPMIEKYYRMX ,4 QIVO &PEGOFIVV +IQMRM EVRE TYXML ERK WIHERKHMGEW HMEXEW WIFYEL TENERKEROIQYHMER XIVHEOEQIRKEQFMP ,4 XIVWIFYX HIRKER QIRKKYREOER XERKEROEBERERRE HER PERKWYRK TIVKM PEPY XIVHEOE HMXIVMEOMQEPMRK QEPMRK SPIL WEOWM .

.&+()1 /)%(0%2 &)6(%7%6/%2 /)89,%S2%52 =%2+ 1%,% )7%4TRKEHMPER 2IKIVM .SQFERK JERK QIQIVMOWE HER QIRKEHMPMTIVOEVE TMHERE FMEWE TEHE XMRKOEX TIVXMORNEXYLOER TYXYWERWIFEKEM FIVMOYX HEPEQ TIVORWWHEOE2EQE 791% 62 ~8IQTEX PELMV SOFERK9O0YV 8KP OELMV XELYR 30XSFIV.

HMVM XIVHEOE XMHEO HMNYQTEM LEP LEP HETEX HMNEHMOER EPEWER YRXYO OIQFIFEWOERQIPITEWOER EXEYQIRKIGYEPMOER HMVMRE HEVM ERGEQER TMHERE FEMO EPEWER TIQFIREVQEYTYR EPEWER TIQEEJ QEOE TEHE HMVM XIVHEOE LEVYW HMNEXYLM TMHERE1IRMOQFERK FELE WIFIPYQ QIRNEXYLOER TMHERE TEHE HMVMXIVHEOE 1ENIPMW ,EOMQ EOER QIQTIVXMQFERKOER LEP LEP ERKQIQFIVEXOER HER LEP LEP JERK QIVMRKEROER JERK EHE TEHE HMVMXIVHEOE1IRMOFERK FELE HIRKER XIPEL XIVFYOXMRE WIPYVYL YRWYV HEVMHEOEER XIVWIFYXHER TEHE HMVM XIVHEOE XMHEO HMNYQTEM LEP

ERK EOER HMNEXYLOER XIVWIFYX1IRMQOFERK FELE XIVLEHET FEVERK FYOXM HMTIVWMHERKERWIPERNYXRE EOER HMXIRXYGHR'ML PERNWXEXYWREHEPEQ EQEV TYXYWERMRM1IRMOFERK FELE WIFIPYQ QOIRNEXYLOER TMHERE TEHE HMVMXIVHEOE 1ENIPMW ,EOMQ EOER QIQTIVXMQFERKOER LEP LEP ERKQIQFIVEXOER HER ERK QIVMRKEROER ERK EHE TEHE HMVM XIVHEOE,&P LEP JERK QIQFIVEXOERe 8IVHEOE XMHEO QIRHYOYRK TVSKVEQ TIQIVMRXEL HEPEQTIOQFIVERXEWER NYHMLEP LEP JERK QIVMRKEROERe 8IVHEOE FIVXIVYW XIVERK WIPEQE HEPEQ TIVWMHERKERe 8IVHEOE FIPYQ TIVREL HMLYOYQe

8IVHEOE FIVNERNM XMHEO EOER QIRKYPERKM TIVFYEXERRE1IRMOFERK FELE QIRKMRKEX ERGEQER TMHERE HEVM XMRHEO TMHEREJERK XIPEL HMPEOYOER SPIL XIVHE@MEYFYRKOER HIRKER LEP LEP ERKQIQFIVEXOER HER QIVMRKEROER XIVWIFYXQEOE QOIRYVYX QENIPMW EOMQTMHERE ERK EOER HMNEXYLOER XIVWIHMXKERHERK XIPEL TERXEW HER EHMP1IRMOFERK FELE HIRKER EOER HMNEXYLOERRE TMHERE TEHE HMVMXIVHEOE QEOE TEHE HMVM XIVHEOE HMFIFERM TYPE OIENMFER YRXYOQIQFEJEV FMEE TIVOEVE1IRKMRKEX HER QIQTIVLEXMOER 4EWEP E EX OI /9,4WIVXE /IXIRXYER OIXIRXYER

QIQTYREM OIOYEXER LYOYQ JERK XIXETOEVIRE XIVHEOFHER 4IRYRXYX 9QYQ TEHE XERKKEP (TWIOF IVQEWMRK QEWMRK QIREXEOER QIRIVMQE FEMO EXEW TYXYWERXIVWIFYX4ERMXIVE 4IRKKERXM

4)2) 864522SQ SV 4HxX 4 42 71K" DEMI KEADILAN BERDASARKAN KETUHANAN YANG MAHAESA"4TRKEHMER 2I1KIW 7EQ TERK JERK Q IQ IWOWE HER Q IRKEHMMTIVWEVE TIVAEXE TIW SLSRER TEHE TIRKEHMER MRKOEX TIVXEQ E JERKHMBOYOER HIRKER , EOM XYRKKEPXIE:L O IO FIWOER TIRIXETER WIFEKEMFIWOYXHERO TIVEVE TIW SLSRERSUAIM AH: 0OFLW (M7EQ TERK FIVXIQ TEX WRKKEP( WE/THYRHDRK 8IRKEL = TYVEFEJE /IP 8HREL/EM /THMRHIRK /IG /IRNVER EKEQ E WHOQTIOIWEER + YVW 8/ 7IFEKEM PEMOHON ; 4TRKEHMER 2 IKIVWXIWIFYXSIEL OQ IQ FEGE WYVEXWYVEXHEHQ

1%, NORMV /TEQ MR TIVIO TYER XIEL BLWHM7EQ TERK TEHEXERKKEP HEW SVERK XYE 41Q SLSR JERK FIVREO E13, 83,6, 1%, s0HER63,1%,1IQ IWRXELOER /ITEHE /ITER /ERXSV /ITIRHYHYOER HERERXEXER 77MM /EFYTEXIR 7EQ TERK WIXIEL HMIVBLEXOER 7ERBRER4IRIXETER DRM YRXYO QIRIVMTOER %OXI /IEHLMER 41Q SLSRXIWIFYXHER WIKIVE HMQ EWYOOER OIHERQ (EQEV%OXI /IHLMERREO ERK WIHERK FIVER HER /YXTERRE HWEQ TEMER OILTEHETIQ SLSR1 IQ FIFEROER FMJE TIW SLSRER DRMOITEHE 41Q SLSRAtau : Mohon putusan yang seadiladilnya ;1 IRM FERK FELE TEHE

LEVMWMHERK ERK XIHL HMXIRXYOER41Q SLSR Q IRKLEHET WIRHMMHDT IWMERKER1IRMFERK FELE WIHRNWXRIJE SHL ,EOM XIHL HM FEGEOERWYVEX TIVO SLSRER 41Q SLSR HER XIVLEHET WYVEX TIW SLSRER XIWIFYXWIXT HEL HM EGEOER 4TQ0 SLSR Q IREXEOER XI XE T TEHE WYVEXTIVW SLSRERRE XIWIFYX1IRMFERK FELE YRXYO Q IRKYEXOER HEBP*SXS GST 7YVEX /IXIVERKER OELW HEW /ITEE 6ETE (EE/EF 7EQ TERK 2S0 SV /2 SR TYEM ELFIWIWYEMR HIRKER EWARE WIERNWXRE HM IWXERHE 4*SXS ' ST /EVXY XERHE 4TRHYHYO SR 79%44HM IVMXERHE 4ole, WIERNWXRIE1 IRM FERK

FELE WIEDR OQ IRKENOER FYOMMWYVEX WIFEKEM EREXIWIFYX HMXEW 4I1Q SLSR WKE OQ IRKENOER HYE SVERK WEOWMERKXTHL HMWYO TEL Q IRYVYX GEVE EKEQ ERJE Q EWRK1IRMFERK FELE WIHBRNWXRJE HMIWMERKER XITHL HMIRKEVTYH OIXIVERKER 410SLSR JERK TEHE TSOSORJE OQ 10 FIWOEROIXIVERKER WIFEKEMF IWOYX&ELE FIREV 410 SLSR HMELMOER TEHE XERKKEP HM7EQ TERK HEW 4EWERKER 7YEQ M WxXIW JERK FIVREQ E 13,83,6 , 1%, S0HER 63,4%,&ELE FIREV OEVIRE OIMHEOXELYER HER OITHEMR SVERK XETIQ SLSR Q EOK OTRMLMER 410 SLSR FIVQ HMGEXEXORR HM/ERXSV

MAHALI2EQEY : ROHIMAHJERK HM) SLSROER HEHQ WYVEXTIW SLSRERRE HETEXHMWEFYRER1 IRM FERK FELE YRXYO Q IQ TIWDRKOEX YVEMR TIRIXETER DRMQ EOE WIKEH WIWYEXY JERK XIVWEHM HMTIWMERKER WIFEKEM ERE ERKXIVHETEXHEHQ & IWKE %GEVE 41 WMHERKER HMERKKET XIEL XIW YEX HERQ IRNMHMFEKMER ERK EO XIVIMNNELOER HEVMMNMTIRIXETER DRMTENTANG HUKUMNYA1IRMFERK FELE QEOWYH HER XYNWER HEW TIW SLSRER4TQ SLSR EHEEL WIFEKEM ERE XIWIFYXHMEXEW1IRMFERK FELE TEHE TSOSORJE 4I1Q SLSR QSLSR EKEV4TRKEHMBER 1 IRIXETOER HER 1 IRKIWELOER FELE

IGEQEXER 1EWFEKMO/EFYTEXIR OSQFSO 8MQYV 2YWE 8IRKKEVE&EVEX FIVHEWEVOER 7YVEX /YEWE /LYWYWXIVXERKKEP %KYWXYW 2s 1>% 7/4(8 : ERK WIPERNYXRE HMWIFYXWIFEKEM4%6% 8) 6+9+%84TRKEHMPER 2IKIVM XIVWIFYXTJIXIPEL QIQFEGE FIVOEW TIVOEVE FIWIVXE WYVEX WYVEX ERKFIVWERKOYXERTJIXIPEL QIRHIRKEV OIHYE FIPEL TMLEO ERK FIVTIVOEVETIXIPEL QIRHIRKEV OIXIVERKER WEOWM WEOWM8) 2832+ (9(9/ 4) 6/%6%1IRMOFERK FELE 4IRKKYKEX HIRKER WYVEX KYKEXBRE XERKKEP YRM JERK HMXIVMQE HER HMHEJXEVOER HM /ITERMXIVEER 4IRKEHMPER2IKIVM 7IPSRK TEHE

WEXY OIWEXYER ERK XMHEO XIVTMWELOER HEPEQ TSOSO TIVOEVE MRM&ELE TEVE 8IVKYKEX TEHE TVMRWMTRJE QIRSPEO HEPMP KYKEXER4IRKKYKEX OEVIRE HEPMP KYKEXER 4IRKKYKEX XIVWIFYX XMHEO QIQMPMOIHEWEV HER EPEWER QIRYVYX LYOYQIGYEPM XIVLEHET HEPMP KYKEXER4TRKKYKEX ERK WIGEVE REXE HRRKEW HMEOYM SPIL TEVE 8IVKYKEX&ELE HEPMP KYKEXER 4IRKKYKEX TEHE ERKOE HER XMHEO FIREVHER XMHEO TIVRXEQM XERKKETM XIVPEPY NEYIVIRE MWXIVM %1%5(90%12 FYOER FIVREQE 2%5 (90%12 EOER XIXETM REQEREEHEPEL 2%5 (30%,&ELE XMHEO FIREV HEPMP KYKEXER

4IRKKYKEX TEHE ERKOBRERKTEHE MRXMRE QIREXEOER PYEW SFIO WIRKOIXE EHEPEL ,EHER XIPEHMTIGEL QIRNEHM SPIL WEPYVER MVMKEWM=ERK FIREV WIFEKEMQERE HEPMP IOWITWM TEVE S8IVKYKEX HM EXEWFELE PYEW SFIO WIRKOIXE EHEPEL 1 IQTEX VMFY XYNYLVEXYW IREQ TYPYL QIXIVTIVWIKMHalaman 9 dari 46 Putusan Perdata Gugatan Nomor : 60/Padt.G/2013/PN.SELTIVWIKM ERK QEWML QIVYTEOER WEXY OIWEXYER FIVHEWEVOER7TIVXMTMOEX ,EO 1MP2 EXEW REQE %1%5 .%17%, 8IVKYKEX&ELE XMHEO FIREV HEPMP KYKEXER 4IRKKYKEX TEHE ERKOBRERKTEHE MRXMRE QIR

EXEOER FELE WIXIPEL SQEU (YPEQMRQIRMRKKEP HYRME SFIO WIRKOIXE HMOYEWEM SPILL %1%5ole17%,8IVKYKEX XERTE QIRKLMVEYOER LEO 4ITRKKYKEX WIFEKEMELPMEVMWRE=ERK FIREV EHEPEL SFJIO WIRKOIXE HMOYEWEM SPIL 8IVKYKEXWIXIPEL EPQEVLYQ %QEU (YPEQMR QIQFIVMOER QIQFEKMREXIVOEWYO HIRKER 4IRKKYKEX WIRHMVMEP MRM FIVHEWEVOER 7YEX4TRIVELER 4IRIVMQEER 8BREL 7EEL ERK HMOIPYEVOER SPIL/ERXSV /ITEPE (IWE 4IRKEHERKER VIKMWXIV 2SQSVXIVXERKKEP .YRM&ELE HEPMP KYKEXER 4IRKKYKEX TEHE TSMR HER XMHEOFIVHEWEVOER LYOYQ OEVIRE TEVE 8IVKYKEX

QIVYTEOER TIQMPMO ERKWEL XIVLEHET SFIO WIRKOIXE FIVHEWEVOER 7IVXMTMOEX ,EO2QSMPMOEXEW REQE %1%35 .%17%, 8IVKYKEX SPIL OEVIRE MXY HEPMPKYKEXER 4IRKKYKEX TEHE TSMRHER XIVWIFYX LEVYWPEL HMXSPEO&ELE HEPMP KYKEXER 4IRKKYKEX TEHE TSMRXMHEO TIVPY OEQMXERKKETM OEVIRE WERKEX ENEV ETEFMPE TEVE 8IVKYKEX QIRKYEWEMSFIO WIRKOIXE HMWIFEFOER EXEW HEWEV JERK WEL EMXY FIVHEWEVOERTIVXMTMOEX ,EO 1MPKO EXEW REQE %1%5 .%17%, 8IVKYKEXHER LEVYW HMPMRHYRKM SPIL LYOYQ&ELE HIQMOMER TYPE XYRXYXER 4IRKKYKEX HEPEQ KYKEXERRE

RKEHNMTI VOEVE TI VHEXE EKEQE TEHE XRKOEX TI VYYEQE HEFEQ TI WHERKERQ EN PVM FEL Q! RNEXYLOER TYXYVER TI VOEVE VEM+ YKEXERXEVEPenggugat YQyYv MELYR EKEQE WEQ TIO!IWEER /EVE ER(1ERV TI RHMINDER 708% XQTEX OHNEQER HM / EFYTEXR&ERKOEFER W FEKEMPenggugatQI FE ERTergugat YQyYVv MELYR EKEQE WEQ TIO WEER 7EXTEQTI RHNMINMDER 708% QTEX OHNEQER HM/ EFYTEX R &ERKOEFERW FEKEMTergugat4 RKEHNMER %KEQ E X WI FYX81 FEL Q!

WOYX&EL E TEHE XERKKEP 2STIQFIV 41 RKKYKEX HI RKER81 WKYKEX Q1 FERKWYRKOER TI VRNDELER ERK HNGEXEX SRL 41 KE EM41 RGEXEX 2NMDEL / ERXSV 9OWWER %KEQE /1GEQEXER &ERKOEFER/ EFYTEX R & ERKOEFER HEFEQ / YXWER %OXE 2NMDEL 25Q SV% 49 86%6: TIMQTYER YQYV XELYRPutusan Nomor: 1160/Pdt.G/2014/PA.Bkl, Halaman 1 dari 11&EL E TEHE E ER E WQEL XERKKE 41 RKKYKEX HER 8l KYKEXWOYR HER GYOYT LEVQSRNV REQ YR OYVERK RFM WNEO FYFER2STIQFIV XELYR Ol X RXVEQER WQEL XERKKE 41 RKKYKEXHI RKER 8 KYKEX QYFEM XWEO LEVQSRNV HER

RKEOMEXOER TI VX RKOEVERERXEVE Ol HYER E4YRGEO Ol VW XEOER LYFYRKER ERXEVE 41 RKKYKEX HI RKER 8l KYKEXX WeFYX X WEHMOYVERK R FM TEHE FYFER 71 TX QFIV XELYR ERK EONFEXRE 8l KYKEX TI KM QI RNRKKEROER 41 RKKYKEX HERTYFERK OL WQEL SVERKXYE 8!l KYKEX W RHMM HI RKER EFEQ EXW FEKENQ ERE X W FYXHMEXEWL NRKKE W OEVERK W FEQE FYFER HERW FEQ E MY 41 RKKYKEXHER 8 KYKEXWYHEL MEO EHE FEKMLYFYRKERFEND FELWQ EYTYR FEXR&EL E 4 RKKYKEX WHEL FI WWELE FI WEFEV HER QI!

X W FYX 41 RKKYKEX QI QSLSROl TEHE 41 RKEHNER %KEQE &ERKOEFER EKEV QI!

I RKKYKEX Ol KYREERR E HER W NEO O NEHNERX We FYXWQEL XERKKE 41 RKKYKEXHER 81 KYKEXWYHEL XWEO LEW SRNWVW VARK X VNEHMTI W AWMLER HER TI VX RKOEVER ( ER Ol Q YHNER ERXEVE41 RKKYKEXHER 8l KYKEXX WEHMTI VI MNELER WEQ TEMW OEVERK W FEQ EOYVERK RFR FM FYFER WFRQE TMEL 8i KYKEX XHEO Q1Q FI WREJOELOl TEHE 41 RKKYKEX O! PEWE X FEL FI WWELE QI! RHEQ ENDER REQ YRMHEO Fl VLEW?

.&+()1/ ) %( O%2 &)6( %7%6/ %2 /)89, %2%2 =%2+ 1%, %)T%4TRKEHMPER 2IKIVM .SQFERK JERK QIQIVMOWE HER QIRKEHMPTIVOEVE TMHERE FMEWE TEHE XMRKOEX TIVXMORNEXYLOER TYXYWERWIFEKEM FIVMOYX HEPEQ TIVOEVE 8IVHEQLE2EQE 1 $/97; 363 %AEW; 363 &M; %6%78IQTEX PELMV SOFERK 9Q0YV XERKKEP PELMV XELYR 30XSFIV.

xXYRXYXER JERK XIPEL HMWEQTEMOERWIFIPYQRE1IRMOQFERK FELE HEPEQ TIVOEVE MRBIVHEOE HMHEOE SPIL4TRYRXYX 9OQYQ HIRKER WYVEX HEOEERJE XIVXERKKEP 2STIOQFIV2SQSV 61K 4IVO 4(1 ~31&% EHEPEL WIFEKEM FIVMOYX&ELE XIVHEOE/97;363 &MR ;%6%7 TEHE LEVM /EQMWXERKKEP TITXIQFIV WIOMVE NEQ ;MF EXEY WIXMHEO XMHEORETEHE WYEXY EOXY XIVXIRXY HEPEQ FYPER 7JITXIQFIV XELYRFIVXIQTEX HM (YWYR OYQOTERK &SPSRK (IWE .SQFERK /IG /EF .SQFERKEXEY WIXMHEO XMHEORE TEHE WYEXY XIQTEX XIVXIRXY JERK QEWML XIVQEWHEPEQ (BEIVEL ,YOYQ 4IRKEHMPER

XIRXERK /IWILEXER1IRMOFERK FELE EXEW HEOEER XIVWIFYSIVHEOE QIREXEOERXMHEO QIRKENYOER OIFIVEXERIOWITWM1IRMOFERK FELE YRXYO QIQFYOXMOER OIFIREVER HEOEERREXIVWIFYX4TRYRXYX 9OQYQ HM TIVWMHERKER XIPEL QIRKENYOER WEOWM WEOWM EMXY7EOW = &9 71&ELE TEHE LEVM /EQMW XERKKEP 7ITXIQFIV WIOMVENEQ ;MF XIVHEOE /97;363 FIVWEQE .).)

TSOSORE WIFEKEM FIVMOYXe S&ELE XIVHEOE XIPEL QIQFIREVOER WIQYE OIXIVERKERREHEPEQ &IVOEW 4IVOEVE WIVXE OIXIVERKER TEVE WEOWM JERKLEHMV HM TIVWMHERKERe &ELE TEHE LEVM /EQMW XERKKEP 7ITXIOQFIV WIOMVENEQ ;MF XIVHEOE /97;363 HER .).)

HMNEXYLOER OITEHE 8IVHEOENILMRKKE TIRNEXYLER TMHERE IJIOXMJ YRXYOQIRGETEM XYNYER TIQMHEREER ERK HEPEQ LYOYQ TMHERE QSHIVRQIRKEVELOER TIQMHEREER TEHE TIQFMREER TIPEOY HER FYOER WIFEKEMFEPEW HIRHEQ EXEY YRXYO QIRHIVMXEOER HER QIVIRHELOER QEVXEFEXSIVHEOE OEVIRE XMRHEOER JERK FIVYTE TIQMHEREER IJIOXMJ JERKQIRKEVELOER TEHE TIQFMREER TIPEOY NYKE FIVJYRKWM WIFEKEM XMRHEOERTHYOEXMJ HER IJIO NIVE EKEV 8IVHEOE XMHEO QIRKYPERKM TIVFYEXERR1011WIVXE QIVYTEOER XMRHEOER TVIZIRXMJ FEKM QEWEVEOEX HER KIRIVEWQYHE

YRM 2SQSV4HX + 4% 'QM4IQSLSR QIRKENYOER KYKEXER GIVEM XIVLEHET8IVQOSLSR HIRKER HEPMP HEPMP WIFEKEM FIVMOYX&ELE 4IQSLSR HIRKER 8IVQSLSR EHEPEL WYEQM MWXIVM ERK QIRMOELWIGEVE EKEQE WPEQ TEHE XERKKEP %TVMP HMLEHETER 4IKEEM4IRGEXEX 2MOEL /ERXSV 9VYWER %KEQE /EFYTEXIR &ERHYRKER XIPELHMGEXEX HEPEQ VIKMWXIV %OXE 2MOEL 2SQSV 3 XERKKEPSTVMP&ELE TEHE EEPRE VYQEL XERKKE 4IQSLSR HIRKER 8IVQSLSR VYOYRWIVXE XIPEL FIVLYFYRKER WIFEKEMQERE PEEORE WYEQM MWXIVM HERHMOEVYRMEM SVERK EREO FIVREQE %2%/&ELE OIQYHMER VYQEL

4IQSLSR HER8IVOSLSR HMPERKWYRKOER&ELE 4IQSLSR WERKKYT QIQFEEV FMEJE TIVOEVE MRM&IVHEWEVOER HEPMP HEPMP XIVWIFYX 4IQSLSR QSLSR /IXYE 4IRKEHMPERSKEQE MOQELM GU I1ENIPMW ,EOMQ JERK HMXYRNYO FIVOIRER QIQIVMOWETIVOEVE MRM HER WIPERNYXRE QIRNEXYLOER TYXYWER HIRKER EQEV WIFEKEMFIVMOYXLIRKEFYPOER TIVOSLSRER 4IQSLSRLIQFIVMOER M*MR OITEHE 4IQSLSR 4) 13, 32 YRXYO QIRKMOVEVOERXEPEO XILEHET 8IVQSLSR8) 613,32LIQFIFEROER FMEE TIVOEVE QIRYVYX LYOYQSXEY NMOE 1ENIPMW ,EOMQ FIVTIRHETEX TREXYWWER ERK WIEHMP EHMPRE&ELE TEHE

JERK HMXIXETGHIKOSLSR XIPEL HEXERKQIRKLEHET WIRHMVM OI TIVWMHERKERWIHERK 8IVQSLSR XMHEO HEXERKQIRKLEHET XERTE EPEWER ERK NIPEW HER XMHEO QIRYVYL SVERK YRXYO LEHMVWIFEKEM EOMPRE ERK WEL QIWOMTYR QIRYVYX 6IPEEW TERKKMPER 2SQSV4HX + 43 ' OMXERKKEP YRM HER XERKKEP YPMXIPEL HMTERKKMP WIGEVE VIWOM HER TEXYX&ELE 1ENIPMW ,EOMQ QIRKEEPM TIVWMHERKER HIRKER FIVYWELEQIREWILEXM 4IQSLSR QIRKYVYRKOER RMEXRJE FIVGIVEM HER WYTEE VYOYROIQFEPM HIRKER 8IVQSLSR XIXETM XMHEO FIVLEWMP WILMRKKE TIVWMHERKERHMPERNYXOER TEHE

HIRKER 4IQSLSR HERE 8IVQSLSR HER OIWEOWMERHMWEQTEMOER HMFEEL WYQTEL HM QYOE TIVWMHERKEWIGEVE WYFWXERWMEPOIWEOWMER OIHYE WEOWM XIVWIFYX WEPMRK QIRHYOYRK WIVXE FIVWIWYEMER WEXYWEQE PEMR (IRKER HIQMOMER OIWEOWMER XIVWIFYX XIPEL QIQIRYLM WEVEXTVSWIHYVEPWEVEX JSVQEP HER WYFWXERWMEP WIWYEM OIXIRXYER 4EWER44 2SQSV XELYR NS 4EWEP HER 4EWEP ,6 WILMRKKE SPILOEVIRE MXY HETEX HMXIVMOQE HER HMNEHMOER HEWEV QITOYXYW TIVOEVE MRMLIRMOFERK , FIVHEWEVOER OIWEOWMER WEOWM OIPYEVKE HMEXEW HMTIVSPILJEOXE HMTIVWMHERKER TEHE

XMHEO WENE FIVEOMFEX 4IQSLSR HIRKER 8IVQSLSRTMWEL XIQTEX XMRKKEP XIXETM NYKE ERXEVE 4IQSLSR HIRKER 8IVQSLSR XMHEOPEKM FIVLYFYRKER HER QIPEOWEREOER OIENMFER QEWMRK QEWMRK WITIVXMPEEORE WYEQM MWXIVMRMOFERK TYPE FELE QIWOMTYR OIPYEVKE XIPELFIVYTEE WIHIQMOMER VYTE QIVYOYROER 4IQSLSR HIRKER 8IVQSLSR EOERXIXETM 4IQSLSR XIXET FIVWMOYOYL YRXYO QIRGIVEMOER 8IVQSI(SRKERHIQMOMER TIVWIPMWMLER 4IQSLSR HIRKER 8IVQSLSR XIPEL QIQTIRKEVYLMOIYXYLER VYQEL XERKKE 4IQSLSR HIRKER 8IVQSLSR WIHIQMOMER VYTE HERXIPEL WEQTEM TEHE

7IRHERK FMVY 686; OIGEQEXER 7YQFIVQERNMRK ;IXEROEFYTEXIR LEPERK6 KEQEWPEQ nate ceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees4TOIVNEER2IPEJER 0 eee teteeeeeeeeeeee4ITIRHMHMOER 7 ( OIPEW8IVHEOE HMXELER WINEO XERKKEP .ERYEVM WEQTEM HIRKERWIOEVERKS8IVHEOE HEPEQ TIVOEVE MRM XMHEO HMHEQTMRKM 4I1REWMLED, YOYQ4IRKEHMPER 2IKIVMXIVWIFYX aaa aaceceeecceeeeceesceceeecceeeeceencceeeeseeseeseensseeeseeoees7VIXIPELQTOFPEGH acca ate eeeeeeeneeeeueeneseeeens1. 7YVEX TIPMQTELER TIVOEVE EGEVE TIQIVMOWEER FMEWE HEVM4TRYRXYX 9O0YO TEHE

TIVOEVEMRM i dssasssewsexesseneeneseesensseunsnsas ss uemunreen maser esereenaeees3. 4IRIXETER /IXYE 1ENIPMW ,EOMQ 2S 4IR 4MH 7YW 4R/TN XIVXERKKEP 1EVIX XIRXERK TIRIXETER LEVMWMHERK. jj. swavsuwsesenererwenens8IPEL OQIRHIRKEV TIQFEGEER WYVEX HEO EER HEVM 4IRYRXYXQOYQO a eeeeeeeeeeeeeee8IPEL QIRHIRKEV OIXIVERKER WEOWM WEOWM HER QIRHIRKEV TYPEOIXIVERKER XIVHEOEHMTIVWMHERKER8IPEL QIQTIVLEXMOER FEVERK FYOXM ERK HMENYOERHMTIVWMHERKER8IPEL QIRHIRKEV XYRXYXER TMHERE .EOWE 4IRYRXYX Y9OXOVXERKKEPSTVMP JERK TEHE

XIVLEHET XIVHEOE 79/%6 &2 1762HIRKER TMHERE TIRNEVE WIPEQE FYPER HMOYVERKM WIPEQEXIVHEOE FIVEHE HEPEQ XELERER WIQIRXEVHER HIRHE 6TWEXY NYXE VYTMEWYFWMHEMV IQTEX FYPEROYVYRKER3. 1IREXEOER FEVERK FYOXM FIVYTEWIFYEL KIVKENM XERKERFYEL TIGSO HMVEQTEW YRXYO HMQYWRELOER FEXERK OEYYOYVER GQ < GQ TERNERK OQOIXIV KPSRHSRK OEY YOYVERQIXIV HMOIQFEPMOER OITMLEO TIVLYXERM4. 1IRIXETOER FMEE TIVOEVE WIFIWEV 6T HYKE VMFYVT ME coccevseueseseceeerer ees8IPEL QIQTIVLEXMOER TIQFIPEER TIVQSLSRER XIVHEOE WIGEVEPMWER ERK TEHE

TSOSORE QSLSR OIVMRKERER LYOYQER OEVIREXIVHEOE QIRIWEP HER FIVNERNM XMHEO EOER QIRKYPERKM PEKTIVFYEXERRE WIVXE XIVHEOE EHEPEL XYPERK TYRKKYRKOIPYEVKR jY = jj sgssscssnsnsenensesnsnsesssewes esas es vesssnwes esses ce eesreewen ers1IRMQFERK FELE XIVHEOE SPIL4TRYRXYX 90Q0YQ HMLEHETEROITIVWMHERKER OEVIRE XIPEL HMHEOE QIPEOYOER XMRHEO TMHEREWIFEKEM FIVMOY Xi... eeccccceseeeeeeeeeeees&ELE XIVHEOE 79/%6 &2 1762 HER XIVHEOB=%283WIGEVE FIVWEQE WEQE QOEFYTYR FIVXMRHEO WIRHMVM WIRHMVM TEHE LEV6EFY XERKKEP

ERYEVM WIOMXEV NEQ ;MF EXEY TEHE EOXYEOXY PEMR HEPEQ FYPER .ERYEVM XELYR EXEY TEHE WYEXY EOXYXIVXIRXY HEPEQ XELYR FIVXIQTEX HMOEEWER LYXER PMRHYRKTIXEO JERK FIVPSOEWM HM (YWYR 6SSXIVEXI (IWE 7MXMEVNS OIGEQEXETYQFIVOERNMRK ;IXER EXEY WIXMHEO XMHEORERE HMXIQTEX XIQTEXPEMR ERK XIVQEWYO HEPEQ HEIVEL LYOYQ 4IRKEHMPER 2IKIVM /ITERNIRQIRIFERK EXEY QIQERIR EXEY QIQYRKYX LEWMP LYXER EORM FIVYTETSLSR OEY NIRMW WIRKSR PEYXOIRIFERK TSLSR HIRKERQIRKKYREOER TIGSO HER KIVKENM XERKEKERTE QIQMPMOM LEO EXEY M*MRHEVM

4989 7oleDO2SQSV 4HX + 4% 4AOP&7100%,66%,1%266%,1()1 /)%(0%2 &)6(%7%6/%2 /)89,%252 =S2+ 1%,% )7%4TRKEHMPER SKEQE 4IOEPSRKER JERK QIQIVMOWE HER QIRKEHMPM TIVOEVEXIVXIRXY TEHE XMRKOEX TIVXEQE XIPEL QIRNEXYLOER TYXYWER WIFEKEMOERE FIVMOYXMRM HEPEQ TIVOEVE /IVEM +YKEX ERK HMENYOER SPIL4) 2++9+%8 YOYV XELYR EKEQE WPEQ TIRHMHMOER Y% TIOIVNEER XMHEOEHE MFY VYQEL XERKKE FIVXIQTEX XMRKKEP HM /IPYVEVBRKS/IGEQEXER 4TOEPSRKER 8MQYV /SXE 4TOEPSRKER WIFEKEM4TRKKYKEXIPE ER Q8) 6+9+%8 YOYV XELYR EKEQE WPEQ TIRHMHMOER

FIVLYFYRKER HIRKER TIVOEVE MRM8IPEL QIRHIRKEV OIXIVERKER 4IRKKYKEX HER WEOWM WEOWM 4IRKKYKIHITER TIVWMHERKER8) 2832+ (9(9/ 4)6/%6%2=%1IRMOFERK FELE 4IRKKYKEX HEPEQ WYVEX KYKEXERRE XERKKEP(IWIQFIV XIPEL XIVHEJXEV HM OITERMXIVEER 4IRKEHMPER %KEQE 4IOEPSRKERHIRKER VIKMWXIV 2SQSV 4HX + 4% 40P XERKKEP (IWIQFIVQIRKIQYOEOER EPEWER EPEWER KYKEXERREWIFEKEM FIVMOYX&ELE TEHE XERKKEP SKYWXYW 4TRKKYKEX HER XIPEL QIPERKWYRKOERTIVRMORLER JERK HMGEXEX SPIL 4IKEEM 4IRGEXEX 2MOEL /ERXSV 9VYWER %KEQE/IGEQEXER 4IOEPSRKER

OYVERK PIFML QMRKKY /IQYHMER 4IRKKYKEX HER8IVKYKEX XMRKKEP HM VYQEL SVERK XYE 8IVKYKEX HM /IPYVELER/ BGHOPXERTIQEQTMV /SXE 7YVEFEE WIPEQE OYVERK PIFMIXELYR 8IVEOLMV4IRKKYKEXHER 8IVKYKEX QIRIQTEXM VYQEL QMPMO SVERK XYE 8IVKYKEX ERK FIVEHE HM /SXE7YVEFEE WIPEQE OYVERK PIFMLXELYR FYPER LEVM, EPEQER HEVM LEPEQERYXYWER 2S 4HX + % 40P&ELE WIPEQE TIVRMOELER XIVWIFYAIRKKYKEX HER 8IVKYKEX XIPEL QIPEOYOERLYFYRKER WIFEKEMQERE PEJEORJE WYEQM MWXWWEOHE HYOLYP HER XIPELHMOEVYRMEM WISVERK EREO FIVREGE%/ PELMV TEHE

WEEX 8IVKNYKEX WIHERK LEQMP X#BFRKKYKEX HMERXEV SPIL8IVKYKEX OI 4IOEPSRKER TEHE TIVXIRKELER .ERYEVM HER 8IVKYKEXLERE FIFIVETE LEVM HM 4IOEPSRKBRPY 8IVKYKEX OI 7YVEFEEe FELE WIXIPEL 4IRKKYKEX QIPELMVOER TEHE EOLMV .ERYEVM WIXMETWIXIRKEL FYPER 8IVKYKEX FIVOYRNYRK OI 4IOEPSRRERRXYO QIRNIRKYO4IRKKYKEX HER EREO OIQYHMER TEHE FYPER T7JITXIQFI 8IVKYKEXFIVWEQE SVERK XYERE QIRKENEO 4IRKKYKEX FIWIVXE EREO YRXYO XMRKKEPFIVWEQE HM 7YVEFEJEe FELE WIXIPEL 4IRKKYKEX HER 8IVKYKEXXMRKKEP FIVWEQE HM 7YVEFEE8IVKYKEX

WIVMRK QIRKYGETOER OEXE OEXE GIVEM OITEHE 4IRKKYKEX EXEYQIPEPYM 717 8IVKYKEX ERK HMOMVMQ OITEHE WEOWM HER WYEQM WEOWM TEHEXERKKEP 7ITXIQFIV TEHE TYOYP HER MWM 717 =MxXyYQIR EXEOER EEJOER 8IVKYKEX FELE 4IRKKYKEX HEPEQ OIEHEER FEMOFEMO WENE 4IRKKYKEX HER 8IVKYKEX XIPEL GIVEM QYXHEXEOER EXEWOINEHMER MXWIQSKE NEHM FEMORE WENEIQYHMER TEHE OIIWSOER LEVMREWEOWM OQIRNIQTYX 4IRKKYKEX HM T7YVEFEJE YRXYO HMENEO TYPERK OI4TOEPSRKERe FELE WINEO MXY 4IRKKYKEX XIPEL TMWEL VYQEL LMRKKE WIOHYBRWINEOMXY TYPE WEOWM

49897 % 22SOSV 4HX + 4% 4+VX( BX BMX ~()1 /)%(0%2 &)6(%7%6/%2 /)89,%2%2 =%2+ 1%,% )7ole4TRKEHMPER %SKEQE +EVYX JERK QIOQIVMOWE HER QIRKEHMPMTIVOEVE XIVXIRXY TEHE XMRKOEX TIVXEOEFPEL QIRNEXYLOERTYXYWER WIFEKEM FIVMOYX HEPEQ TIVOEVE4)13,32 YOQYV XELYR EKEQE WPEO TIOIVNEER;MVEWEWXE FIVXIQTEX XMRKKEP HM &YVYNYP686; (IWE 'MVETYLER /IGEQEXER 7IPEEM/EFYTEXIR +EVYX JERK HEPEQ LEP MRM QTQFIVMOEROYEWE OITEHE =%( 7 7%4986% $7, EHEPEL %HZSOEXHER /SRWYPXER ,YOYQ TEHE /%2836 ,9/91 =%( 7715498 6% $773'%8)7 FIVOERXSV

HMWIFYXWIFEKEM 8IVQSLSR4TRKEHMPER SKEQE XIVWIFYXSIPEL QIOQTIPENEVM FIVOEW TIVOEVESIPEL QIRHIRKEV OIXIVERKER 4IQSLSR HER WIQYE WEOWM HMHITER WMHERK8) 28%2+ (9(9/ 4)6/%6%&ELE TIQSLSR HIRKER WYVEX 4IVOSLSRERRE XERKKEPSKYWXYW JERK HMHEJXEVOER HEPEQ VIKMWXIV TIVOEVE HMOITERMXIVEER 4IRKEHMPER %KEQE +EVYX HIRKER 2SQSV4HX + 4% +VXXERKKEP SKYWXYW JERK TEHETSOSORJE XIPEL QIRKENYOER HEPMP HIRKER XEQFELER HERTIVYFELER WIFEKEM FIVMOYX &ELE 41QSLSR HER 8IVOQSLSR EHEPEL WYEQM MWXVM JERKQIPERKWYRKOER TIVRMOELER TEHE

7IPEEM /EFYTEXIR +EVYX4VSZMRWM .EE&EVEX WIFEKEMQERE HEPEQ /YXMTER %OXE 2MOERL 2SQSVXERKKEP 11M1&ELE WIXIPEL TIVRMOEFLER XIVWIFYX 4IQSLSR HIRKERSIVQSLSR FIVXIQTEX XMRKKEP FIVWEQE HM /EQTYRK MOEPETE68 6; (IWE 'MVETYLER /IGEQEXER 7IPEEM/EFYTEXIR +EVYX 4VSZMRWM E(E & EVEX HER WIPEQETIVRMOELER XIVWIFYX 4IQSLSR HIRKER 8IVQSLSR XIPELVYOYR FEMO WIFEKEMOQERE PEEORJE WYEQM MWXVM HER XIPELHMOEVYRMEM IOQTEX SVERK EREO JERK FIVREQE 6MTEPHM YOYVXELYR 2E*EV XELYR ,IRHVE YOYV XELYR HER :MXEYOQYV XELYR FYPER&ELE TEHE

FIPEL TMLEO LEVYW LEHMV HM TIVWMHERKER1IRMOFERK FELE WIWYEM HIRKER QEOWYH HER OIXIRXYERTEWEP Q9RHERK QYRHERK 2SQSV SELYR 1ENIPMW ,EOMOQXIPEL FIVYWELE QEOWMQEP QITREWILEXM 4IQSLSR QIPEPYM OYEWEREEKEV HETEX VYOYR OIQFEPM QIQFMRE VYOEL XERKKE HIRKERSIVOSLSR BOER XIXETM YWELE XIVWIFYX XMHEO FIVLEWMPLIRMOFERK FELE FIVHEWEVOER EPEX FYOXM LEVYWHMREXEOER XIVFYOXM FELE ERXEVE 4IQSLSR HER 8IVOQSLSR XIPELXIVMOEX HEPEQ TIVOEMRER ERK WEL WIFEKEMQERE HMEXYV HEPEOTEWEP 9RHERK Q9RHERK 2SQOSV SELYRLIRMOFERK FELE TEHE

.YEVMX XERKKEPTITXIQFIV 1EWILM FIVXITEXER HIRKER XERKKEP>YPOEMHEL ,MNVMJELSPIL OFQM (VW %12 WIFEKEM ,EOMQ/IXYE 1ENIPMW WIVXE (VW , %7)4 &%&(69>%$1%52 1, (ER(VW , 6 % 7%8& 7, Il, QEWMRK QEWMRK WIFEKEM , HOMOSRKKSXE TYXYWER QERE TEHE LEVM MXY NYKE HMFEGEOER HEPEQTIVWMHERKER XIVFYOE YRXYO YOYQ SPIL OIXYE QENIPMW XIVWIFYXHIRKER HMLEHMVM TEVE LEOMQ ERKKSXE BHRS2 &%),%5 7,WIFEKEM TERMXIVE TIRKKERXM WIVXE HMLEHMVM SPIL OYEWE 4IQSLSRXERTE LEHMVRJE 8IVQSLSR/IXYE 1LENIPMW(Vw %1 2,BOMQ SRKKSXE ,BOMQ SRKKSXE

Penuntut Umum:
TEHE ARO WARUWU, SH.,MH
Terdakwa:
KHOA TJING HUI alias AWI alias GAPAM

Butar Butar, SH Panitera Pengganti pada Pengadilan Negeri Sibolga, sertadihadiri oleh Tehe Aro Waruwu, SH. MH Penuntut Umum dan Terdakwa;Hakim Anggota, Hakim Ketua,Marolop W. P. Bakara, SH. Alex T. M. H. Pasaribu, SH, MH.Halaman 17 dari 18 Putusan Nomor : 50 / Pid.B / 2019 / PN Sbg.Tetty Siskha, SH, MH.Panitera Pengganti,Antoni G. P. Butar Butar, SH.Halaman 18 dari 18 Putusan Nomor : 50 / Pid.B / 2019 / PN Sbg.

498 97% 22SOSV 4AHX + 4S +VX( HX AX XxX ()1 /)%(0%2 &)6(%7%6/%2 /)89,%2%2 =32+ 1%,% )7%4TRKEHMPER %SKEQE /IPEW% +EVYX JERK QIQIVMOWE HERQIRKEHMPM TIVOEVE TIVHEXE TEHE XMRKOEX TIVXEQE HEPEQTIVWMHERKER J1ENIPMW XIPEL QIRNEXYLOER TYXYWER WIFEKEMFIVMOYX HEPEQ TIVOEVE GIVEM KYKEX ERXEVE4) 2++9+%8 YOYV XELYR EKEQE WPEQ TIOIVNEER;MVEWEWXE XIQTEX XMRKKEP HM .P /IRE@GKE6; /IPYVELER 4EOYSR /IGEQEXER +EVYX/SXE /EFYTEXIR +EVYX WIPERNYXRE HMWIFYXWIFEKEM 4IRKKYKEX0S 7 & 28) 6+94+%8 YOYV XELYR EKEQE WPEQ TIOIVNEER

(IWE /MPEY/IGEQEXER MPEY /EFYTEXIR +EVYX WIPERNYXREHMWIFYX WIFEKEM 8IVKYKEX4IRKEHMPER SKEQE XIVWIFYX8IPEL QIQFEGE WYVEX WYVEX TIVOEVE8IPEL QIRHIRKEV OIXIVERKER 4IRKKYKEX HER WEOWM WEOWM HMTIVWMHERKER8) 2862+ (9(9/ 4) 6/%6%2=%1IRMOFERK FELE 4IRKKYKEX HEPEQ WYVEX KYKEXERREXIVXERKKEP 1LEVIX JERK HMHEJXEVOER HM /ITERMXIVEER4TRKEHMPER SKEQE +EVYX HIRKER 2SQSV 4HX +45 +VX XERKKEP 1LEVIX HIRKER TIVFEMOER HERTIREQFELER WITIVPYRE XIPEL QIRKENYOER KYKEXERFIVHEWEVOER EPEWER WIFEKEM FIVMOYXe &ELE LEVM 6EFY TEHE

XERKKEP l1EVIX 4TRKKYKEXXIPEL QIPERKWYRKOER TIVRMOELER HIRKER 8I VKYKEXHMLEHETER 4IKEEM4IRGEXEX 2MOEL TEHE /ERXSV 9VYWERSKEQE /IGEQEXER +EVYX /SXE /EFYTEXIR +EVYXWIFEKEMQERE XIVGERXYQ FYOY /YXMTER %OXE 2MOEL2S 8IVXERKKEP 1EVIXe &ELE WIXIPEL TIVRMOELER XIVWIFYXRKKYKEX HIRKER8IVKYKEX FIVXIQTEX XMRKKEP HMVYOEL SVERK XYE4ITRKKYKEX WIFEKEMQERE EPEQEX 4IRKKYKEX XIVWIFYXHMEXEW WEQTEM HIRKER WIOEVERKe &ELE WIPEQE TIVRMOELER XIVWIFYX 4IRKKYKEX HIRKER8IVKYKEX HEPEQ QIQFMRE VYQEL XERKKE ,EVQSRMW HERFIVKEYP

WEXY SVERK EREO JEMXY %>)0 4986 %2 (6=%2YOYV XELYR IREQ FYPER WIOEVERK FIVWEQE 4IRKKYKEXe s&ELE WIQYPE VYOEL XERKKE 4TRKKYKEX HIRKER8IVKYKEX VYOYR HER LEVQSRMW REQYR WINEO FYPERTJITXIQFIV XELYR OIXIRXVEQER VYQEL XERKKE4TRKKYKEX HIRKER 8IVKYKEX QYPEM KSEL WIVMRKAVNEHMTIVXIRKOEVER HER TIVGIOGSOER ERK XIVYW QIRIVYW ERKHMWIFEFOER OEVIRE 8) 6+9+%8 GIOQFYVY OITEHE4)2++9+%8 FIVPIFMLER XERTE EPEWER JERK NIPEWe &ELE TYRGEO TIVXIRKOEVER VYQEL XERKKE 4IRKKYKEXHIRKER 8IVYKEX XIVNEHM TEHPER 30XSFIV XELYRJERK TEHE

EOLMVRJE 4IRKKYKEX HIRKER 8IVKYKEX XMRKKEPQEWMRK QEWMRK WEQTEM HIRKER WIOEVERK HER WINEO MXYXMHEO EHE PEKM LYFYRKER FEMO PELMV QEYTYR FEXLMRe &ELE TYRGEO TIVXIRKOEVER VYQEL XERKKE 4IRKKYKEXHIRKER 8IVYKEX XIVNEHM TEHE EOLMV XELYR EOLMVREERXEVE 4IRKKYKEX HIRKER 8IVKYKEX TMWEL VYQEL WEQTEMHIRKER WIOEVERK HER WINEO MXY XMHEO EHE PEKM LYFYRKERFEMO PELMV QEYTYR FEXLMRe &ELE YRXYO QIRIPIWEMOER OIQIPYX VYQEL XERKKE4ITIRKKYKEX HIRKER 8IVKYKEX XIPEL FIVYWELEFIVOYWJEEVEL XIXETM XMHEO FIVLEWMPe S&ELE 4IRKKYKEX

Penuntut Umum:
TEHE ARO WARUWU, SH.,MH
Terdakwa:
ALI RAHMAAT Alias ALI RAHMAT Alias ALI

Dikembalikan Kepada Saksi Sony Tehe Lase als. Ama Dewi; 6. Membebankan kepada Terdakwa membayar baiaya perkara sejumlah Rp.2.000,00 (dua ribu rupiah);

Dikembalikankepada yang berhak yaitu kepada Sony Tehe Lase alias Ama Dew;4.

;Bahwa Saksi kenal dengan Terdakwa dan tidak memiliki hubungankeluarga mauoun pekerjaan;Bahwa Saksi mengerti diperiksa dipersidangan sehubungan denganterjadinya pemukulan / penganiayaan;Bahwa yang menjadi korban adalah Sony Tehe Lase als. Ama Dewidan yang menjadi pelakunya adalag Elison Telaumbanua als.

Sbg).Bahwa Terdakwa mengerti diperiksa dan dimintai keterangandipersidangan sehubungan pemukulan / penganiayaan;Bahwa Terdakwa sendirian melakukan pemukulan / penganiayaan danyang menjadi korbannya adalah Sony Tehe Lase als. Ama Dewi tepatnyakejadian di warung milik Ali Jabar Gulo als.

Terdakwa dengan sengaja melakukanpenganiayaan yang menyebabkan Saksi Korban Sony Tehe Lase als. AmaDewi luka. Pada hari Selasa tanggal 02 Mei 2017 sekitar pukul 19.00 WibSaksi Korban datang ke rumah Saksi Ali Jabar Gulo alias Ama Dewi tidaklama kemudian datang Terdakwa.

Dikembalikan Kepada Pemiliknya Yang Berhak yaitu :Saksi Korban Sony Tehe Lase als.

QIPERKKEV OIXIRXYER WIFEKEMQERE ERKHMEXYV HER HMERGEQ TMHERE HEPEQ 4EWEP EJ EX .S 4EWEP 992S SE LYR XIRXERK2EVOSXMOE1IRMOFERK FELE XIVLEHET TIQFEGEER 7YVEX (EOEER XIVWIFYXXIVHEOE QIREXEOER OQIRKIVXM HER QIPEPYM 4TREWILEX , YOYORIJEQIR EXEOER XMHEO QIRKENYOEROIFIVEXER1IRMOFERK FELE YRXYO QIQFYOXMOER HEOEERRE XIVWIFYX QEOEEOWE 4IRYRXYX 9QYQ XIPEL QIRKENYOER EPEX FYOMYE SVERK WEOWM ERKFIVREQE66162 1%890) 77=1,%)0 *)6(2%2 (97=ERK QEWMRK QEWMRK XIPEL QIQFIVMOER OIXIVERKER HM FEEL WYQTELHM TIVWMHERKER JERK TEHE

MRM1IRMOFERK FELE WIPEMR MXY XIPEL TYPE HMFEGEOER OIXIVEWEKRSVERK WEOWM ERK FIVREQE 6382732 %/)62% EPMBW HEPEQ &IVMXE %GEVE4TQIVMOWEER WEOWM JERK WYHEL HMTERKKMP XERKKHHM HMOEVIREOERWEOWM ERK WYHEL HMTERKKMP WIGEVE 7EL SPIL .EOWE 4IRYRXYX XMBEOLEHMV HM TIVWMHERKER XERTE QIQFIVMOER EPEWER ERK WEL XIRXERK OIXMHEOLEHMVERR EXIVWIFYX1IRMOFERK FELE XIVLEHET OIXIVERKER WIQYE WEOWM XIVWIFYX HMEXEWTEHE TSOSORE XIPEL HMF TREVOER SPILXIVHEOE1IRMQFERK FELE XIVHEOE HM TIVWMHERKER XIPEL QIQFIVMOEROIXIVERKER JERK TEHE

TSOSORE WIFEKEMQERE XIVQYEX HER XIVGEXEX HMHEPEQ &IVMXE SGEVE 4IVWMHERKER HER HMERKKET XIVQYEX WIPIRKOETRE WIVXEQIVYTEOER FEKMER ERK XMHEO XIVTMWELOER HEVM TYXYWER TIVOEVE MRM1IRMOFERK FELE HM TIVWMHERKER XIPEL HMENYOER HER HMTIVPMLEXOERFEVERK FYOXM FIVYTE1IRMQOFERK FELE WIPERNYXRE WIXIPEL TIQIVMOWEER HMR EXEOERWIPIWEM QEOE WIWYEM HIRKER OIXIRXYER HM HEPEQ 4EWEBP EX LYVYJ E/9,4 QEOE .EOWE 4IRYRXYX 9QOYQ XIPEL QIRKENYOER XYRXYXER TMHEREXIVLEHET XIVHEOE ERK HMFEGEOER HM TIVWMHERKER JERK TEHE TSOSOREQSLSR

TSOSORJE QSLSR OITEHE 1ENIPMW,BOMQ YRXYO QIRNEXYLOER TYXYWER JERK WIVMRKER VMRKERRE OITEHEXIVHEOE OEVIRE XIVHEOE FIVOIMRKMRER YRXYO WIQFYL HEVM OIXIVKERXYRKEROITEHE KERNE XIVWIFYX1IRMQOFERK FELE XIVLEHET 4IQFIPEER 4PIHSM HEVM 4IREWILEX,YOYQ XIVHEOE QEOE .EOWE 4IRYRXYX Y9YOQYQ QIRERKKETMRE WIGEVE PMWER ERK TEHE TSOSORE XIXET TEHE 8YRXYXER4MHERER E1IRMOQFERK FELE FIVHEWEVOER EPEX EPEX FYOXM JERK WEL JERKHMENYOER HM TIVWMHERKER FIVYTE OIXIVERKER TEHE WHOKMVERKERXIVHEOE HER HMOYEXOER HIRKER EPEX FYOXM

4IRYRXYX 9QYQOWIFEKEMQERE XIVWIFYX HMEXEW HMWYWYR HEPEQ FIRKRYWIVREXMZI QEOEQIVYTEOER OIFIFEWER FEKM l1ENIPMW ,EOMQ YRXYO QIQMPML HEOEER ERKQERE JERK EOER HMTIVXMOFERKOER HER HMFYOXMOER HIRKER QIRHEWEVOERTEHE JEOXE JEOXE LYOYO ERK HMTIVSPIL HMTIVWMHERKER1IRMOFERK FELE YRXYO MXY Il1ENIPMW ,EOMQ EOER QIOQTIVXMOQFERKOERHER OQIQFYOXMOER (EO EER /T TEXY EMXY QIPERKKEV OIXIRXYERWIFEKEMQERE ERK HMEXYV HER HMERGEQ TMHERE HEPEQ 4EWEPEEX 54EWEP 99 2S SE LYR XIRXERK 2EVOSXMOE JERK QIQTYREM YRWYVYRWYV JERK TEHE

Penuntut Umum:
TEHE ARO WARUWU, SH.,MH
Terdakwa:
ANWAR SHADYQ TANJUNG Alias SIDIK Bin KOTA TANJUNG

., Bob Sadiwijaya S.H.M.H. masingmasing sebagai Hakim Anggota,yang diucapkan dalam sidang terbuka untuk umum pada hari itu juga dibantu,oleh Antoni Gunawan Putra Butar Butar SH, Panitera Pengganti padaPengadilan Negeri Sibolga, serta dihadiri oleh Tehe Aro Waruwu, S.H.., M.H.,Penuntut Umum dan Terdakwa;Hakim Anggota, Hakim Ketua,Tetty Siskha, S.H.M.H. Alex T.M.H.

Penuntut Umum:
TEHE ARO WARUWU, SH.,MH
Terdakwa:
NURMAINA BORU SIMATUPANG Alias MAINA Alias UMAK YUSNI

., Panitera Pengganti pada Pengadilan Negeri Sibolga, sertadihadiri oleh Tehe Aro Waruwu, S.H.,M.H., Penuntut Umum dan Terdakwa.Hakim Anggota, Hakim Ketua,Obaja David J. H. Sitorus, S.H. Martua Sagala, S.H.M.H.Marolop W. P. Bakara, S.H.Panitera Pengganti,Punia Hutabarat, S.H.Halaman 19 dari 19 Putusan Nomor 27/Pid.Sus/2019/PN Sbg

TSOSORJE QIVEWE FIVWEPEL HER QIRIWEPWIVXE FIVNERNM XMHEO EOER QIRKYPERKM PEKM TIVFYEXERRE HER QSLSR OIVMRKERLYOYQER1IRMQFERK FELE XIVHEOE HMENYOER OI TIVWMHERKMRM XIPEL HMHEOESPIL 4ITRYRXYX 9YOYOHIRKER HEOEER WIFEKEM FIVMOYX4VMOEMV&ELE ME XIVHEOE /%62383 EPMEW 8383/ FMR /%6.323 TEHE LEVM/EQMW XERKKEP TITXIQFIV WIOMXEV TYOYP ;MF EXEY WIXMHEOXMHEORE TEHE WYEXY EOXY HEPEQ FYPER 7ITXIQFIV 8ELYR FIVXIQTEXHM .EPER /,KYW 7EPMQ 2S 6X 6 /IPYVELER &PMRHYRKER/IGEQEXER &SRHSSWS /EFYTEXIR &SRHSSWS EXEY WIXMHEO

Bdw.XIVWIFYX TEHE WEOWM QIPEOYOER TIRIPMHM@HR XIVHEOE HMHEPEQFIRKOIP WITIHE QOMPMORE WIHERK QIRNYEP EXEY QIPEJERM TIQFIPMTIRSQFSO NYHM NIRMW XSKIP HIRKER QIPEPYM LERH TLSRI ZOU OWMERTEVE WEOWM QIRERKOET XIVHEOE HER TEHE WEEX HMXERKOET HEVM XIVHEOEHMWMXE FEVERK FYOXM FIVYTE WEXY PIOQFEV OIVXE TIRKIPYEVER RSQSVXSKIP HER YERK WINYQPEL 6T WIVXE WEXY FYEL LERH TLSRI2SOME < HER XIVHEOE QIRKEOYM TIVQEMRER NYHM ERK HMPEOYOER XIVHEOEXIVWIFYX EHEPEL HIRKER GEVE XIVHEOE YRXYO QIRIVMQE TIQFIPMER HEVMTIQFIPM

QIRHETEX MRJSVOQEWMXIVWIFYX TEHE WEOWM QIPEOYOER TIRIPMHM@HR XIVHEOE HMHEPEQFIRKOIP WITIHE QOMPMORE WIHERK QIRNYEP EXEY QIPEJERM TIQFIPMTIRSQFSO NYHM NIRMW XSKIP HIRKER QIPEPYM LERH TLSRI ZOU QOWMERHal. 5 dari 19 hal.

EOXY WEOWM OQIPEOYOER TIRERKOETER XIVLEHETXIVHEOE /EVXSRS %SPMEW 8SXSO &MR /EVNSRSM XIVWIFYX FIVWEQE &VMKI&YHMERXSHER &VMTOE =SSO =YPMWXMEVWSe &ELE WEOWM QIPEOYOER TIRERKOETER XIVLEHET XIVHEOE 7YQELPE) JIRHM EPMEW 4IRHM XIVWIFYX TEHE LEVM /EQMWERKKEPTITXIQFIV t .EQ ;MFHal. 7 dari 19 hal.

LEVM MXY NYKE SHWOMQ /IXYE HIRKERHMHEQTMRKM SPIL OIHYE ,EOMQ %RKKSXHMFERXY SPIL 79/%6( 4ERMXIVE4TRKKERXM TEHE 4IRKEHMPER 2IKIVM &SRHSSWS HIRKER HMLEHMVM SPIL (%=923: )2(%62 7, ly 4ATRYRXYX 90YQ TEHE /INEOWEER 2IKIVM&SRHSSWS HER 8IVHEOE,EOMQ %RKKSXE XWF,EOMQ /IXYE XWF6V (%, 43) 62313.) /8 7, +) () =90%68,% 7, 1,79&632837, 1,4ERMXIVE 4IRKKERXM XWFHal. 27 dari 19 hal.

49897%22SQSV 4( & 42 4(+()1 /)%(0%2 &)6(%7%6/%2 /)89,%2%32 =32+ 1%,% )7%4TRKEHMPER 2IKIVM /IPEW % 4EHERK ERK QIRKEHMPM TIVOEVE TIVOEVETMHERE TEHE TIRKEHMPER XMRKOEX TIVXEQE HIRKER EGEVE TIQIVMOWEER FMEWEXIPEL QIRNEXYLOER TYXYWER WIFEKEM FIVMOYX HEPEQ TIVOEVE XIVHEOE2EQE PIRKOET %&( %0 %12 440 %&(8IQTEX PELMV 4EHERK9QYV 8KP OELMV SELYR STVMP.IRMW /IPEQMR OEOM PEOM/IFERKWEER RHSRIWME8IQTEX XMRKKEP .POYFYO &EY 8MQYV &IVSO 7MXIFE 2S 68 6; /IG2ERKKEPS /SXE 4EHERKSKEQE WPEQ4IOIVNEER .

HER QIQFEJEV HIRHE WIFIWEV 6THIPETER VEXYW NYEX VYTMELWYFWMHEMV HYE FYPER TIRNEVE1IREXEOER FEVERK FYOXM FIVYTEWEXY /ERXSRK TPEWXMO EVRE LMXEQ HM HEPEQRE FIVMWM@ERY TEOIX HMHYKE 2EVOSXMOE NIRMW KERNE HM FEPYX HEPEQ PEOFER OYRMRK HIRKER FIVEXHIPETER VEXYW XYNYL TYPYL WEXY OSQE WIOFMRERWEXY YRMX ,ERHTLSRI QIVO 0+ EVRELMXEQ (MVEQTEW YRXYO HM QYWREOERLIQFIFERM XIVHEOE YRXYO QIQFEEV FMEJE TIVOEVE WIFIWEV 6TWIVMFY VYTMEL8IPEL QIRHIRKEV TIQFIPEER HEVM TIREWMLEX LYOYQ XIVHEOE HERXIVHEOE WIGEVE PMWER JERK TEHE

JEOWM 1% Z2=/IXIVERKERE HMFEGEOER HM TIVWMHERKER TEHE TSOSORE QIRIVERKOERWIFEKEM FIVMOYX &ELE WEOWM QIRKIVXM FELE TIVOEVE TMHEREXIVWIFYX XIVNEHM TEHE LEVM 7EFXY XERKKEP %TVMP TYOYP7MF HMWEQTMRK VYQEL WEOWM %SFHM SPSQMR 4KP SFHM HM .POYFYO &EYV8MOYV &IVSO 7MXIFE 2S 68 6; /IG RERKKEPS 4EHERK &ELEFIREV ERK HMXERKEOET SPIL 4SPMWM EHEPEL EVKE WEOWMe &ELE FIREV XIVHEOE HMXERKEOET WIXIPEL XIQER XIVHEOEHMXERKOET XIVPIFML HELYPY &ELE FIREV WI EOXY TIRERKOETER HMXIQYOER/ERXSRK TPEWXMG EVRE LMXEQ HMHEPEQRE

&ELE FIREV WIPEMR 2EVOSFE TSPMWM NYKE QIRMXE WEXY FYEL ,T OK EVRELMXEQ HER WEXY YRMX WITIHE QSXSV 1IVO ,SRHE &IEX 2S TSP &&HEVM XIVHEOE &ELE FIREV XIVHEOE EHEPEL TIRNYEP EEQ HM TEWEV 6EJETEHERK &ELE FIREV FEVERK FYOXM ERK HMTIVPMELXOER HMTIVWMHERKER/IXIVERKER WEOWM HMFIREVOER SPIL XIVHEOE 7EOWM *6 (%97/IXIVERKERE HMFEGEOER HM TIVWMHERKER TEHE TSOSORE QIRIVERKOERWIFEKEM FIVMOYX &ELE WEOWM QIRKIVXM FELE TIVOEVE TMHERE XIVWIFYXXIVNEHM TEHE LEVM 7EFXY XERKKEP %TVMP LYOYP 7;MF HMWEOQTMRKVYQEL WEOWM %FHM

DEDAEWEXERKKEP 30XSFIV SPIL OEQM=97 )2(%6 7, WIFEKEM ,EOMQ /IXYE1ENIPMW17 +6 &%79/ 7, HER (2%3,%=%8 7=3*=% 7, 1, QEWMRKQEWMRK WIFEKEM ,EOMQ %RKKSXE4YXYWER QERE HMYGETOER TEHE LEVM MXY NYKE HEPEQ

4989724MH & 42 1KK()1 /)%(0%2 &)6(%7%6/%2 /)89,%2%52 =%2+ 1%,% )7%4TRKEHMPER 2IKIVMEKIPERK ERK QIQIVMOWE HER QIRKEHMPMTIVOEVE TMHERE TEHE XMRKOEX TIVXEQE HIRKER EGEVE TIQIVMOWEER FMEWEXIPEL QIRNEXYLOER TYXYWER WIFEKEM FIVMOYX HEPEQ TIVOEVE EXEW REOQEXIVHEOE2EQE PIRKOETSIQTEX OELMV9QYV 8KP OELMV.IRMW /IPEQMR/IFERKWEERSIOTEX XMRKKEPSKEOE4TRHMHMOER4TOIVNEER89;%0=3 &2 &9(.323 SPO1EKIPERKSELYR .

EOWE 4TRYRXYX 9O0YQHMTIVWMHERKER JERK TEHE TSOSORJE QIQSLSR EKEV LENIPMW ,EOMQ JERKQOIQIVMOWE TIVOEVE MRM QIQYXYWOER WIFEKEM FIVMOYX1IRJEXEOER 89;%0=3 &2 &9(.323 SPQ FIVWEPEL QIPEOYOERXMRHEO TMHERE 4TRGYVMER HEPEO IPYEVKE WIFEKEMQEREHMHEOEOER .EOWE 4IRYRXYX 9OYQO HEPEQHEOEER1IRNEXYLOER TMHEREOITEHE XIVHEOE 89;%0=3 &2 &9(.323SPQ HIRKER TMHERE TIRNEVE WIPEQE 8YNYL FYPERHMOYVERKMWIPEQE XIVHEOE HEPEQ XELERER HIRKER TIVMRXEL XIVHEOEXIXET HMXELER1IREXEOER FEVERK FYOXM FIVYTE: WEXY FYEL OETXST QIVO %SWYW

RSQSVWIVM ( 23< HMOIQFEPMOER OITEHE WEOWM SHI 6ER4VEHERE1IRIXETOER EKEV XIVHEOE HMFIFERM QOIOFEJEV FMEJE TIVOEVEWIFIWEV 6T HYE VMFY VYTMELT7IXIPEL QIRHIRKEV TIQFIPEER XIVHEOE WIGEVE PMWER HEPEOTIVWMHERKER JERK QIREXEOER TIVQSLSRERE EKEV HMNEXYLM LYOYQERJERK WIVMRKER VMRKERRE OEVIRE XIVHEOE QIRIWEPM TIVFYEXERREHER FIVNERNM XMHEO EOER QIRKYPERKM TIVFYEXERRJE XIVWIFYX1IRMOFERK FELE XIVHEOE XIVWIFYX XIPEL HMENYOER OIQYOETIVWMHERKER HIRKER HEOEBERXYRKKEPWIFEKEM FIVMOYX&ELE E XIVHEOE 89;%0=3 &2 &9(.323 %PQ TEHE

LEVMIMRKKY XERKKEP TITXIQFIV WIOMVE TYOYP ;MF EXEYWIXMHEO XMHEORE TEHE FYPER 7ITXIQFIV FIVXIQTEX HM /T8SINSWEVM68 6; /TP 1EKIVWEVM /IG1IEKIPERK 7IPEXER /SXE 1EKIPERK EXEYWIXMHEO XMHEORE HMMPEEL LYOYQ 4IRKEHMPER 2IKIVM 1EKIPERKXIVHEOE XIPEL QIRKEOQFMP WIWYEXY FEVERK JERK WIPYVYLRJE EXEYWIFEKMER OITYRJEER SVERK PEMR HIRKER QEOWYH YRXYO HMQMPMOM WIGEVQIPEER LEO NMOE ME EHEPEL OIPYEVKE WIHEVEL EXEY WIQIRHE FEMCHEPEQ KEVMW PYVYW QEYTYR KEVMW QOIRJMOQTERK HIVENEH OILBEBREXIVLEHET SVERK MXY LERJE QYRKOMR

HMEHEOERR TIRYRXYXER NMOE EHETIRKEHYER JERK XIVOIRE OINELEXERERK HMPEOYOER HIRKER GEVE GEVEWIFEKEM FIVMOYX&ELE ME XIVHEOE 89;%0=3 &2 &9(.323 PQ TEHE EOXY HERXIQTEX XIVWIFYX HMEXEW FIVEEP XIVHEOE FIVXEQY OIVYQEL WEOWMOSVFER OEVIRE WIFEKEM WEYHEVE HER TEHE WEEX VYQEL HMXMRKKEP SPIOSVFER OIQYHMER XIVHEOE QEWYO OEQEV PEPY QIRKEOQFMPWEXY FYELPETXST QIVO SWYW EVRE LMXEQ RSOSV WIVM ( 23< ERKHMXEVYL HMHEPEQ OEFQEV XERTE MNMR WILMRKKE OSVFER QIRKEPEQM OIVYKMEWIOMXEV 6T )QOTEX NYXE VYTMEL41TVFYEXER XIVHEOE