Bahwa pada penjelasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XII 64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition , Volume 3, dinyatakan : TheHeading covers, inter alia:(a)(b)(c)()(e)(1)Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivetsor similar devices;Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which areproduced in one piece usually attached to the base or platformby riveting;Slippers or mules without quarter or counter,the uppers ofwhich, being produced in one piece or assembled other than bystitching,

are attached to the sole by stitching;Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to thesole by plugs which lock into holes in the sole;Nonwaterproof footwear produced in one piece (for example,bathing slippers);12.

Berdasarkan CANADA BORDER SERVICE AGENCY, Custom Notice N484,Ottawa, 26 Nov 2002 dan CBSA Statement Of Reason , Ottawa 9Desember 2002The distinctive feature of waterproof footwear is that both the sole portionand the a portion of the upper, sufficient to give waterproof protection to thefoot, are incorporated into a single component which may be made of rubberor plastic.Diterjemahkan oleh Penerjemah Resmi Dan Tersumpah :Harry F.

Majelis berpendapat bahwa Pos 64.01 sampai dengan pos 64.05dibedakan berdasarkan bahan penyusun outer sole dan upper,Explanatory Noted Bab 64 Umum (B)** Menurut pendapat Pemohon Banding ( kami ) penyataan diatas kurangtepat karena berdasarkan Harmonized System :Pos 64.01 Waterproof footwear with outer soles and uppers of rubber orof plastic, the uppers of which are neither fixed to the sole norassembled by stitching, riveting, nailing, screwing, plugging orsimilar processes.Pos 64.02 Other footwear

syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengan carainjection moulding, karena untuk masuk sub pos 64.02 harusmemenuhi syarat pembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling, dipaku,disekrup, ditusuk atau dengan cara semacam itu.Bahwa pada penjelasan sub pos 64.02 pada halaman XII 64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition , Volume 3, dinyatakan : The Headingcovers, inter alia:(a) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orsimilar devices;(ob) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

areproduced in one piece usually attached to the base or platform byriveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter,the uppers of which,being produced in one piece or assembled other than bystitching, are attached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;Halaman 24 dari 27 halaman.

(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the soleby plugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced in one piece (for example,bathing slippers)Bahwa dengan Explanatory Notes, untuk sub pos 64.02 tersebut diatas, maka sandal jepit dan sandal yang diimpor Pemohon Bandingsekarang Pemohon Peninjauan Kembali dapat masuk sub pos 64.02,karena pada bab 64, sub pos yang paling tepat untuk sandal jepit dansandal adalah sub pos 64.02.Bahwa menurut Ketentuan Umum

Barang Dalam Persetujuan KerangkaKerja Mengenai Kerjasama Ekonomi Menyeluruh Antara NegaraNegara AnggotaAsosiasi BangsaBangsa Asia Tenggara Dan Republic Rakyat China), yaitu pada Annex 3"Rules Of Origin For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall be deemed to beoriginating and eligible for preferential concessions if they conform to the originrequirements under any one of the following:Products which

Articles collected there which can no longer perform their original purpose nor arecapable of being restored or repaired and are fit only for disposal or recovery ofparts of raw materials, or for recycling purpose(4; andJ.

Persetujuan Perdagangan Barang Dalam Persetujuan KeranKerja Mengenai Kerjasama Ekonomi Menyeluruh Antara NegaraNegara Anggota AsosBangsaBangsa Asia Tenggara Dan Republic Rakyat China), yaitu pada Annex 3 "RulesOrigin For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall be deemed tcoriginating and eligible for preferential concessions if they conform to the orrequirements under any one of the following:Products which

Articles collected there which can no longer perform their original purpose norcapable of being restored or repaired and are fit only for disposal or recovery of pof raw materials, or for recycling purpose(4; andk.

PerdaganganBarang Dalam Persetujuan Kerangka Kerja Mengenai Kerjasama EkonomiMenyeluruh Antara NegaraNegara Anggota Asosiasi BangsaBangsa Asia TenggaraDan Republic Rakyat China), yaitu pada Annex 3 "Rules Of Origin For The TheAseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall be deemed tobe originating and eligible for preferential concessions if they conform to the originrequirements under any one of the following:Products which

Articles collected there which can no longer perform their original purpose nor are capable of beingrestored or repaired and are fit only for disposal or recovery of parts of raw materials, or for recyclingpurpose(4; andk.

waters of that Party, provided that that Party has the rights to exploit such wateseabed and beneath the seabed in accordance with international law;g) Products of sea fishing and other marine products taken from the high seasvessels registered with a Party or entitled to fly the flag of that Party;h) Products processed and/or made on board factory ships registered with a Partyentitled to fly the flag of that Party, exclusively from products referred toparagraph (g) above;i) Articles collected there which

Persetujuan Perdagangan Barang Dalam Persetujuan Keran;Kerja Mengenai Kerjasama Ekonomi Menyeluruh Antara NegaraNegara AngeAsosiasi BangsaBangsa Asia Tenggara Dan Republic Rakyat China), yaitu pada Anne"Rules Of Origin For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall be deemed tooriginating and eligible for preferential concessions if they conform to the orirequirements under any one of the following:Products which

Articles collected there which can no longer perform their original purpose norcapable of being restored or repaired and are fit only for disposal or recoveryparts of raw materials, or for recycling purposes; andj.

Barang Dalam PersetujuanKerangka Kerja Mengenai Kerjasama Ekonomi Menyeluruh Antara NegaraNegara Anggota Asosiasi BangsaBangsa Asia Tenggara Dan RepublicRakyat China), yaitu pada Annex 3 "Rules Of Origin For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall bedeemed to be originating and eligible for preferential concessions if theyconform to the origin requirements under any one of the following:Products which

of that Party, provided that that Party has the rights toexploit such waters, seabed and beneath the seabed in accordance withinternational law.Products of sea fishing and other marine products taken from the high seas byvessels registered with a Party or entitled to fly the flag of that Party.Products processed and/or made on board factory ships registered with aParty or entitledto fly the flag of that Party, exclusively from products referred to inparagraph (g) above.Articles collected there which

Proyek PISP (Participatory Irrigation Sector Project)Dalam kontrak disebutkan halhal sebagai berikut :This Contract (hereinafter called the "Contract") is made on the 6thday of the month of December, 2006 between, on the hand,Directorate General of Water Resources (DGWAR), Ministry of PublicWorks, Republic of Indonesia (hereinafter called the "Client") and, onthe other hand a Joint Venture consisting of the following entities,each of which will be jointly and severally liable to the Client for all

Putusan Nomor 1068/C/ PK/PJK/2014Sedangkan dalam General Condition of Contract juga dijelaskanbahwa "Joint Venture" means a Consultant which compries two ormore Peartners each of wich will be jointly and severally liable to theClient for all the Consultant's obligations under the Contract.a) Dasar HukumUndangUndang Nomor 18 Tahun 2000 tentang Perubahan KeduaAtas UndangUndang Nomor 8 Tahun 1983 tentang PajakPertambahan Nilai Barang Dan Jasa Dan Pajak Penjualan AtasBarang MewahPasal 16B ayat (1) :

Proyek PISP (Participatory Irrigation Sector Project)Dalam kontrak disebutkan halhal sebagai berikut :This Contract (hereinafter called the Contract) is made on the 6thday of the month of December, 2006 between, on the hand,Directorate General of Water Resources (DGWR), Ministry of PublicWorks, Republic of Indonesia (hereinafter called the Client) and, onthe other hand a Joint Venture consisting of the following entities, eachof which will be jointly and severally liable to the Client for all theConsultants

DDC Consultants (hereinafter collectivellycalled the Consultant).Sedangkan dalam General Condition of Contract juga dijelaskanbahwa Joint Venture means a Consultant which compries two ormore Peartners each of wich will be jointly and severally liable to theClient for all the Consultants obligations under the Contract.a) Dasar HukumHalaman 10 dari 16 halaman.

Putusan Nomor 3206/B/PK/Pjk/20181213.1(b) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which areproduced in one piece usually attached to the base or platformby riveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter,the uppers ofwhich, being produced in one piece or assembled other than bystitching, are attached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are

attached to thesole by plugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced in one piece (for example,bathing slippers).

pada saat pemeriksaanbernilai USD.3.007.894 ditambah USD.133.205, sehingga menjadi USD.3.141.099dibulatkan menjadi USD.3.141.100 (sesuai nilai sengketa versi Majelis);bahwa berdasarkan bunyi pasal 10 ayat (1) dari Perjanjian penghindaran pajak berganda(P3B) Indonesia dan Amerika , disebutkan bahwa :"Where a resident of one of the Contracting State and any other person are related andwhere such related person make arrangements or impose conditions between themselveswhich are different from those which

would be made between independent persons, anyincome, deductions, credits, or allowances which would, but for those arrangements or anyconditions, have been taken into account in computing the income (or loss) of, or the taxpayable by, one of such persons.

belumkelihatan memenuhi syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengancara injection moulding, karena untuk masuk pos 64.02 harusmemenuhi syarat pembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling,dipaku, disekrup, ditusuk atau dengan cara semacam itu;Bahwa pada penjelasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XII 64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan: The Headingcovers, inter alia:(a) Skiboots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orsimilar devices;(b) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

areproduced in one piece usually attached to the base or platformby nveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter, the uppers ofwhich, being produced in one piece or assembled other than bystitching, are attached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the soleby plugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced

Barang Dalam PersetujuanKerangka Kerja Mengenai Kerjasama Ekonomi Menyeluruh Antara NegaraNegara Anggota Asosiasi BangsaBangsa Asia Tenggara Dan RepublicRakyat China), yaitu pada Annex 3 "Rules Of Origin For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall bedeemed to be originating and eligible for preferential concessions if theyconform to the origin requirements under any one of the following:Products which

of that Party, provided that that Party has the rights toexploit such waters, seabed and beneath the seabed in accordance withinternational law.Products of sea fishing and other marine products taken from the high seas byvessels registered with a Party or entitled to fly the flag of that Party.Products processed and/or made on board factory ships registered with aParty or entitledto fly the flag of that Party, exclusively from products referred to inparagraph (g) above.Articles collected there which

Persetujuan Perdagangan Barang Dalam Persetujuan KeranKerja Mengenai Kerjasama Ekonomi Menyeluruh Antara NegaraNegara Anggota AsosBangsaBangsa Asia Tenggara Dan Republic Rakyat China), yaitu pada Annex 3 "RulesOrigin For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall be deemed toriginating and eligible for preferential concessions if they conform to the orrequirements under any one of the following:Products which

Articles collected there which can no longer perform their original purpose norcapable of being restored or repaired and are fit only for disposal or recover:parts of raw materials, or for recycling purpose(4; andk.

Persetujuan Perdagangan Barang Dalam Persetujuan KeranKerja Mengenai Kerjasama Ekonomi Menyeluruh Antara NegaraNegara Anggota AsosBangsaBangsa Asia Tenggara Dan Republic Rakyat China), yaitu pada Annex 3 "RulesOrigin For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall be deemed tcoriginating and eligible for preferential concessions if they conform to the orrequirements under any one of the following:Products which

Articles collected there which can no longer perform their original purpose norcapable of being restored or repaired and are fit only for disposal or recovery of pof raw materials, or for recycling purpose(4; andk.

No. 424 PK/Pdt/2007"'Party' or Parties is not defined in Article 1 but is applied in theheading of the Contract as defining Batubara, the party to which theGovernment of the Republic of Indonesia is successor as the 'Party ofthe First Part' and ourselves as the Party of the Second Part with bothentities together referred to as 'the Parties.

In our view, this makes itclear beyond doubt that it is only ourselves and the Government of theRepublic of Indonesia which is a contract party and entitled to invokethe right to refer to arbitration to the ICSID disputes falling within theparameters of Article 23.1 for settlement.In addition, and this follows on from the points which we made abovein relation to the purported claimant, whom we would submit is plainlya nonparty to the KPC Contract, the named Second to SeventhRespondents are similarly

not party to the KPC Contract and aretherefore not capable of being bound by any agreement reached byourselves and the Government of the Republic of Indonesia to referdisputes which may arise between us and us alone to arbitrationbefore the ICSID.We would urge the Secretary General therefore to refuse to registerthe Request for Arbitration on the basis that arbitration proceedingshave been commenced by an entity which is not a party to the KPCContract and therefore not entitled to invoke provisions

No. 424 PK/Pdt/2007in dispute from the Republic of Indonesia which is signatory to theConvention. Whatever the status of the Claimant, in respect of whichwe make no admission, plainly it is not a Contracting State, it has notbeen designated a subdivision thereof and, in terms of establishingwhatever rights the Claimant may have to pursue a claim for allegedbreach of contract to which it is not on the face a party, this is not amatter which should be determined in arbitration before ICSID."

Kaltim Prima Coal)sendiri menyatakan dalam surat tertanggal 15 Mei 2006 bahwa :"'Party' or 'Parties' is not defined in Article 1 but is applied in theheading of the Contract as defining Batubara, the party to which theGovernment of the Republic of Indonesia is successor as the Party ofthe First Part' and ourselves as the Party of the Second Part with bothentities together referred to as 'the Parties.

Persetujuan Perdagangan Barang Dalam Persetujuan KeranKerja Mengenai Kerjasama Ekonomi Menyeluruh Antara NegaraNegara Anggota AsosBangsaBangsa Asia Tenggara Dan Republic Rakyat China), yaitu pada Annex 3 "RulesOrigin For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall be deemed tcoriginating and eligible for preferential concessions if they conform to the orrequirements under any one of the following:Products which

Articles collected there which can no longer perform their original purpose norcapable of being restored or repaired and are fit only for disposal or recovery of pa00mMenimbangmengingatof raw materials, or for recycling purpose(4; andk.

pencetakan melalui perendamane perakitan melalui vulkanisasie penyatuan dan pemvulkanisasiane pengetasan berflekuensi tinggie perekatanBahwa berdasarkan Canada Border Service Agency, Custom Notice N484,Ottawa, Nov 26, 2002 dan Canada Border Service Agency, StatementOf Reason , Ottawa, December 9, 2002;The distinctive feature of waterproof footwear is that both the sole portionand the a portion of the upper, sufficient to give waterproof protection to thefoot, are incorporated into a single component which

tahan airberarti alas kaki yang disebutkan dalam pos tersebut, yang dirancang untuk melindungi dari penetrasi air atau cairan lainnya,tanpa memperdulikan apakah alas kaki tersebut semuladirancang untuk tujuan tersebut atau tidak;Canada Borders Service Agency, Statement Of Reason, OttawaNov Dec 9 2002The distinctive feature of waterproof footwear is that both the soleportion and the a portion of the upper, sufficient to givewaterproof protection to the foot, are incorporated into a singlecomponent which

kelihatanmemenuhi syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengan cara injectionmoulding, karena untuk masuk pos 64.02 harus memenuhi syaratpembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling, dipaku, disekrup, ditusukatau dengan cara semacam itu;Bahwa pada penjeiasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XIl 64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan: The Headingcovers, inter alia:(a) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orsimilar devices;(6) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

are producedin one piece usually attached to the base or platform by riveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter, the uppers of which,being produced in one piece or assembled other than by stitching,are attached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consisting of straps across the instep and counter or heelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the sole byplugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced

(b) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which areproduced in one piece usually attached to the base or platformby nveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter,the uppers ofwhich, being produced in one piece or assembled other thanby stitching, are attached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to thesole by plugs which lock

memenuhi syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengancara injection moulding, karena untuk masuk pos 64.02 harusmemenuhi syarat pembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling,dipaku, disekrup, ditusuk atau dengan cara semacam itu;Bahwa pada penjelasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XII 64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition , Volume 3, dinyatakan : TheHeading covers, inter alia:(a) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivetsor similar devices;(b) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

areproduced in one piece usually attached to the base or platformby riveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter, the uppers ofwhich, being produced in one piece or assembled other than bystitching, are attached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the soleby plugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced

belumkelinatan memenuhi syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengancara injection moulding, karena untuk masuk pos 64.02 harusmemenuhi syarat pembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling,dipaku, disekrup, ditusuk atau dengan cara semacam itu;Bahwa pada penjelasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XIl 64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan TheHeading covers, inter alia:(a) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivetsor similar devices;(6) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

areproduced in one piece usually attached to the base or platformby riveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter, the uppers ofwhich, being produced in one piece or assembled other than bystitching, are attached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to thesole by plugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced