Tergugat masih kurang dewasa sebagai kepala keluarga dan masih seringbermain Play Stations; b. Tergugat serng berkata kasar terhadap Penggugat;c.

PUTUSANNomor 0458/Pdt.G/2019/PA.Prob.ZN at > 2KEM) VashDEMI KEADILAN BERDASARKAN KETUHANAN YANG MAHA ESAPengadilan Agama Probolinggo, yang memeriksa dan mengadiliperkaraperkara tertentu pada tingkat pertama, dalam persidangan Majelistelah menjatuhkan Putusan sebagai berikut, dalam perkara Cerai Gugatantara:PENGGUGAT, umur 47 tahun, agama Islam, pendidikan terakhir SLTA,pekerjaan Karyawan Stations Caf & Resto,tempat tinggal di Kota Probolinggo, sebagaiPenggugat;melawanTERGUGAT, umur 46 tahun, agama

Seluma telah terjadi pengambilan barangberupa 2 (dua) unit play stations, 19 (Sembilan belas) unit HP serta kartuperdana dan voucher pulsa; Bahwa Saksi tidak mengetahui sekira pukul berapa kejadian tersebutdikarenakan Saksi mengetahui kejadian tersebut melalui HP sekirapukul 08.30 Wib dan yang menghubungi Saksi adalah Sdr. DIDIFIRMANSYAH(pemilik counter) yang sebelumnya sudah mendapatberita dariSdr.

polisi.Menimbang, bahwa atas keterangan saksi tersebut terdakwamembenarkannya.Menimbang, bahwa Terdakwa YOHANES KRISOSTOMUS GATYAWICAKSANA dipersidangan telah memberikan keterangan yang padapokoknya sebagai berikut :Bahwa terdakwa telah menerima surat dakwaan dan telahmembenarkannya.Bahwa terdakwa tidak bersedia didampingi Penasihat Hukum.Bahwa pada hari Sabtu tanggal 7 Juni 2014 malam hari, TerdakwaGatya bermain ke kontrakan Jotawang Rt 02 Rw 01 BangunharjoSewon Bantul Yogyakarta, dan bermain PS (Play stations

AcaraPersidangan dianggap telah terangkum seluruhnya dalam putusan ini ;Menimbang, bahwa berdasarkan keterangan para saksi, keteranganTerdakwa dan memperhatikan barang bukti dan Berita Acara PemeriksaanLaboratoris Kriminalistik yang terlampir dalam berkas yang salingberhubungan dan bersesuaian maka diperoleh faktafakta yuridis sebagaiberikut :Bahwa pada hari Sabtu tanggal 7 Juni 2014 malam hari,GATYA main ke kontrakan Jotawang Rt 02 Rw O01Bangunharjo Sewon Bantul Yogyakarta, dan bermain PS(Play stations

Excl. connection of sensors Connection of various types of sensors to the Datahog datalogger.Include testing and coding Per type of sensor Solar energy system for meteo stations with a Datahog, consistingof a solar panel, control unit with batteries. Capacity 12V/1Ah/10W.Batteries are charged when solar radiation >80 W/m2.

)Manual IMS 4 Mechatronics subsystem SH50097D 1assembly (GB)Manual IMS 5 Mechatronics subsystem SH50097E 1processing (GB)Manual IMS 6 Mechatronics subsystem testing SH50097F 1(GB)Manual IMS 8 Mechatronics subsystem storage SH50097H 1(GB)Manual IMS 11.2 Mechatronic Subsystem IMS SH50097M 1manual disassembly with robot FS003 (GB)Manual IMS 11 Mechatronics subsystem SH50097N 1disassembly (GB)Manual IMS 2 sensor case manual (GB) SH50097W 1Manual IMS 26 Flexible manufacturing system SH50097S 1with 6 stations

systemsMeasuring instruments:Analog/digital multimeter, wattmeter and power CO51271Zfactor meterAccessories:Safety connection plug 19/4mm, black, with SO51269RtappingSafety connection plug 19/4mm, black S051269YSafety connection plug 19/4mm, red $051269USet of safety measurement cables 4mm (23pcs) SO51481LSafety measurement cable (4mm) 50cm red S051268K 141426a a a a2010 UnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnit Mobile Work Stations

Include testing and coding Per type of sensor Solar energy system for meteo stations with a Datahog,consisting of a solar panel, control unit with batteries. Capacity12V/1Ah/10W. Batteries are charged when solar radiation >80 W/m2.

Include testing and coding Per type of sensor Solar energy system for meteo stations with a Datahog,consisting of a solar panel, control unit with batteries. Capacity12V/1Ah/10W. Batteries are charged when solar radiation >80 W/ UnitUnitUnitSetUnitUnitUnit Unit Hal. 135 dari 172 hal. Put. No. 1292 K/Pid.Sus/2013 m2.

Bahwa terdakwa telah beberapa kali melakukan perbuatan dengan modusyang sama yaitu menyuruh orang lain menyewa playstations besertakelengkapannya dan TV dengan menggunakan identitas milik orang lainnamun Play stations dan TV terebut tidak di kembalikan,Menimbang, pada hari Senin tanggal 18 Januari 2021 wib sekira pukul12.00 wib Rental Aladin Game JI. Galunggung No. 69 Kav. 12 Kel. GadingkasriKec.

hari Jumat tanggal 18 Nopember 2011, sekira pukul 20.00. wibbertempat di rumah saksi di Desa Pulo Tinggi Kecamatan Pasie raya KabupatenAceh jaya saksi kehilangan berupa barang, emas dan celengan berisi uang ;Bahwa pada Sabtu tanggal 19 Nopember 2011 sekira jam. 12 wib saksi bersamadengan isteri saksi bernama Astuti pulang dari meulaboh dan terus kerumah,sesampainya dirumah saksi melihat didalam rumah dan kamar sudah berantakandan melihat celengan berisikan uang sudah tidak ada lagi, HP dan Play Stations

Include testing and coding Per type of sensor 1 - Solar energy system for meteo stations with a Datahog, consisting of a solar panel, control unit with batteries. Capacity 12V/1Ah/10W. Batteries are charged when solar radiation >80 W/m2.

5 Mechatronics sub-system processing (GB) SH5009-7E 1 Unit308 Manual IMS 6 Mechatronics sub-system testing (GB) SH5009-7F 1 Unit309 Manual IMS 8 Mechatronics sub-system storage (GB) SH5009-7H 1 Unit310 Manual IMS 11.2 Mechatronic Subsystem IMS manual disassembly with robot FS003 (GB) SH5009-7M 1 Unit311 Manual IMS 11 Mechatronics sub-system disassembly (GB) SH5009-7N 1 Unit312 Manual IMS 2 sensor case manual (GB) SH5009-7W 1 Unit313 Manual IMS 26 Flexible manufacturing system with 6 stations

1 Unit Measuring instruments: 341 Analog/digital multimeter, wattmeter and power-factor meter CO5127-1Z 1 Unit Accessories: 342 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, black, with tapping SO5126-9R 5 Unit343 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, black SO5126-9Y 20 Unit344 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, red SO5126-9U 10 Unit345 Set of safety measurement cables 4mm (23pcs) SO5148-1L 1 Unit346 Safety measurement cable (4mm) 50cm red SO5126-8K 4 Unit Mobile Work Stations

Excl. connection of sensors Connection of various types of sensors to the Datahog datalogger.Include testing and coding Per type of sensor Solar energy system for meteo stations with a Datahog, consisting ofa solar panel, control unit with batteries. Capacity 12V/1Ah/10W.Batteries are charged when solar radiation >80 W/m2. Totally chargedbattery gives a power supply for the logger of approx. 7 wk.

No. 6/PID.SUS/2013/PT.BTN 7431431531631731831932032132232332432532632732832933033133233333474 stations (GB) SQuickCharts:Quick Chart: IMS 1.2 Transport system with DC drive $062051(GB) AQuick Chart: IMS 3 Mechatronics Selection subsystem $062051(GB) CQuick Chart: IMS 4 Mechatronics Assembly subsystem $062051(GB) DQuick Chart: IMS 5 Mechatronics Process subsystem (GB) SO62051EQuick Chart: IMS 6 Mechatronics Testing subsystem (GB) SO62051FQuick Chart: IMS 8 Mechatronics Storage subsystem (GB) SO62051HQuick

Assistant: Design and operation of $028003 1 Unitphotovoltaic systems A Measuring instruments: 341 Analog/digital multimeter, wattmeter and powerfactor CO5127 1 Unitmeter 1ZAccessories:342 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, black, with tapping S$051269 5 UnitR343 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, black S$051269 20 UnitY344 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, red S$051269 10 UnitU345 Set of safety measurement cables 4mm (23pcs) S$051481 1 UnitL346 Safety measurement cable (4mm) 50cm red SO51268 4 UnitK Mobile Work Stations

Excl. connection of sensors Connection of various types of sensors to the Datahog datalogger.Include testing and coding Per type of sensor Solar energy system for meteo stations with a Datahog, consisting ofa solar panel, control unit with batteries. Capacity 12V/1Ah/10W.Batteries are charged when solar radiation >80 W/m2.

AMeasuring instruments:Analog/digital multimeter, wattmeter and powerfactor CO5127meter 1Z = UnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnitUnit 121 Accessories:342 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, black, with tapping $05126915 UnitR343 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, black S$051269/20 UnitY344 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, red $051269/10 UnitU345 Set of safety measurement cables 4mm (23pcs) $051481/1 UnitL346 Safety measurement cable (4mm) 50cm red S0512684 UnitKMobile Work Stations

Manual IMS 26 Flexible manufacturing system with 6 stations (GB) 1 UnitSH50097SQuickCharts:314. Quick Chart: IMS 1.2 Transport system with DC drive (GB) SO6205 1 Unit1A315. Quick Chart: IMS 3 Mechatronics Selection subsystem (GB) SO6205 1 Unit1C316. Quick Chart: IMS 4 Mechatronics Assembly subsystem (GB) 1 Unit$062051D317. Quick Chart: IMS 5 Mechatronics Process subsystem (GB) SO6205 1 Unit1E318. Quick Chart: IMS 6 Mechatronics Testing subsystem (GB) SO6205 1 Unit1F319.

Solar energy system for meteo stations with a Datahog,consisting of a solar panel, control Unit with batteries.Capacity 12V/1Ah/10W. Batteries are charged when solarradiation >80 W/m2. Totally charged battery gives a powersupply for the logger of approx. 7 wk.45. Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometer + PC SetMerk/Type: Hitachi/Z 200046. Lemari Asam UnitMerk/Type: Lokal47. Rotary evaporator SetMerk/Type: Stuart/RE301+RE3022C48. Ashing Oven Unit Hal. 98 dari 184 hal. Put.

Manual IMS 26 Flexible manufacturing system with 6 stations 1 Unit(GB) SH50097SQuickCharts:314. Quick Chart: IMS 1.2 Transport system with DC drive (GB) 1 UnitS062051A315. Quick Chart: IMS 3 Mechatronics Selection subsystem (GB) 1 Unit$062051C316. Quick Chart: IMS 4 Mechatronics Assembly subsystem (GB) 1 Unit$062051D317. Quick Chart: IMS 5 Mechatronics Process subsystem (GB) 1 Unit$062051E318. Quick Chart: IMS 6 Mechatronics Testing subsystem (GB) 1 Unit$062051F 319.

Safety measurement cable (4mm) 50cm red SO51268K 4 UnitMobile Work Stations Regenerative Energy:347. Complete Aluminium table with experiment frame 3 level, 1 Unit Hal. 110 dari 184 hal. Put. No. 2146 K/Pid.Sus/2013 1500x800x760 mm ST72003T 348. Monitor holder for flat screen monitor of weight up to 5kg,VESA 1 Unit75 ST80104L 349. Power console, Three phase, 1500mm, 3x230V, emergency. 1 Unitshutdown, 2x 4 earthed sockets, 30mA RCD ST70081N Accessories: 350.

Manual IMS 26 Flexible manufacturing system with 6 stations (GB) 1 UnitSH50097SQuickCharts:314. Quick Chart: IMS 1.2 Transport system with DC drive (GB) 1 UnitS062051A315. Quick Chart: IMS 3 Mechatronics Selection subsystem (GB) 1 Unit$062051C316. Quick Chart: IMS 4 Mechatronics Assembly subsystem (GB) 1 Unit$062051D317. Quick Chart: IMS 5 Mechatronics Process subsystem (GB) 1 Unit$062051E318. Quick Chart: IMS 6 Mechatronics Testing subsystem (GB) 1 Unit$062051F319.

antara Pemohon dan Termohon pernah bertengkar di rumah bersamaketika Pemohon mau meminta Buku Nikah, namun tidak diberikan olehTermohon.Bahwa saksi mendengar Pemohon mengatakan Termohon anjing, melakukanhubungan seksual di depan anak dan Termohon menjawab bahwa ia tidur didepan.Bahwa saksi dapat mendengar pertengkaran, antara Pemohon dan Termohon,karena suara handphon tersebut dikeluarkan melalui speaker.Bahwa selama berpisah Pemohon pernah datang ke rumah Termohon, namunPemohon hanya bermain play stations

Malahan justru sebaliknya yang disebabkan antara lain:Pemohon masih bersifat kekanakkanakan karena Pemohon merupakan anaktunggal dan kurang bertanggung jawab dan tidak mau mandiri; .....................Pernah Pemohon membentak, menampar, dan menyeret Termohon ketika waktuMaghrib dicari di tempat bermain Play Stations ...........esccessceeseeseeeeeeeeeneeeeneeesBahwa memang benar terakhir Senin tanggal 16 Mei 2011, (bukan tanggal 23 Mei2011) Saya meninggalkan rumah orangtua Pemohon dan tinggal di

Include testing and coding Per 1type of sensor Solar energy system for meteo stations with aDatahog, consisting of a solar panel, control unit withbatteries. Capacity 12V/1Ah/10W. Batteries arecharged when solar radiation >80 W/m2. Totallycharged battery gives a power supply for the logger ofapprox. 7 wk.

75Literature:ManualIMS 1.2 Converyor belt DC (GB)Manual IMS 3 Mechatronics subsystemsorting (GB)Manual IMS 4 Mechatronics subsystemassembly (GB)Manual IMS 5 Mechatronics subsystemprocessing (GB)Manual IMS 6 Mechatronics subsystemtesting (GB)Manual IMS 8 Mechatronics subsystemstorage (GB)Manual IMS 11.2 Mechatronic SubsystemIMS manual disassembly with robotFS003 (GB)ManualIMS 11 Mechatronics subsystemdisassembly (GB)Manual IMS 2 sensor case manual (GB)Manual IMS 26 Flexible manufacturingsystem with 6 stations

Include testing and coding Pertype of sensor Solar energy system for meteo stations with aDatahog, consisting of a solar panel, control unit withbatteries. Capacity 12V/1Ah/10W. Batteries arecharged when solar radiation >80 W/m2.

GB)307 ManuallIMS 5 Mechatronics subsystem SH50097E 1 Unitprocessing (GB)308 ManualIMS 6 Mechatronics subsystem SH50097FL 1 Unittesting (GB)309 ManuallIMS 8 Mechatronics subsystem SH50097H 1 Unitstorage (GB)310 Manual IMS 11.2 Mechatronic Subsystem SH50097M 1 UnitIMS manual disassembly with robotFS003 (GB)311 ManualIMS 11 Mechatronics subsystem SH50097N 1 Unitdisassembly (GB)312 ManuallIMS 2 sensorcase manual(GB) SH50097W 1 Unit313 ManualIMS 26 Flexible manufacturing SH500979 1 Unitsystem with 6 stations

Interactive Lab Assistant: Design and S028003A) 1operation of photovoltaic systemsUnitMeasuring instruments:341 Analog/digital multimeter, wattmeterand CO51271Z 1powerfactor meter UnitAccessories:342 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, black, SO51269R 5 Unitwith tapping343 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, black $051269Y 20 Unit344 Safety connection plug 19/4mm, red $051269U 10 Unit345 Setofsafetymeasurementcables4mm SO51481L 1 Unit(23pcs)346 Safety measurement cable (4mm)50cm SO51268K) 4 UnitredMobile Work Stations

Seluma telah terjadi pengambilan barangberupa 2 (dua) unit play stations, 19 (Sembilan belas) unit HP serta kartuperdana dan voucher pulsa;Bahwa Saksi tidak mengetahui sekira pukul berapa kejadian tersebutdikarenakan Saksi mengetahui kejadian tersebut melalui HP sekirapukul 08.30 Wib dan yang menghubungi Saksi adalah Sdr. DIDIFIRMANSYAH(pemilik counter) yang sebelumnya sudah mendapatberita dariSdr.

Hi Class V for Teacher Station, EnglishVersion (IK1800T ) Unit 1 9.693.695 9.693.695HiClass V for Teacher control panelTeacher External BoxEzcontrol Software for control functionCable Accessories :1 set 600 600.00HiClass V for Student Stations, EnglishVersion ( IK2200S) Unit 10 4.606.095 46.060.950HiClass V Student External BoxHiClass V IK180 Teacher External Box Unit 1 4.606.095 4.606.095HiClass V Data Repeater ( IK288 ) Unit 1 6.177.800 6.177.800Multimedia Centralized Control System (IK3000V )

Hi Class V for Teacher Station, EnglishVersion (IK1800T )HiClass V for Teacher control panelUnitTeacher External BoxEzcontrol Software for control functionCable Accessories :1 set 600 600.009.693.6959.693.695 HiClass V for Student Stations, EnglishVersion ( IK2200S)HiClass V Student External BoxUnit104.606.09546.060.950 HiClass V IK180 Teacher External Box Unit4.606.0954.606.095 HiClass V Data Repeater ( IK288 ) Unit6.177.8006.177.800 Multimedia Centralized Control System (IK3000V )Cable Accessories

Hi Class V for Teacher Station, EnglishVersion (IK1800T ) Unit 1 9.693.695 9.693.695HiClass V for Teacher control panelTeacher External BoxEzcontrol Software for control functionCable Accessories :1 set 600 600.00 HiClass V for Student Stations, EnglishVersion ( IK2200S) Unit 10 4.606.095 46.060.950HiClass V Student External Box HiClass V IK180 Teacher External Box Unit 1 4.606.095 4.606.095 HiClass V Data Repeater ( IK288 ) Unit 1 6.177.800 6.177.800 Multimedia Centralized Control System (IK3000V

Bahwa selama berpisah Pemohon pernah datang ke rumah Termohon,namun Pemohon hanya bermain play stations bersama anak dan tidakmenginap, dan Pemohon selalu pamit bila pergi keluar rumah.2. Saksi Il, umur 48 tahun, agama Islam, Pekerjaan Buruh Tani, tempattinggal di RT.024.RW.07 desa Jepara Wetan, Kec. Binangun, Kab. Cilacap,saksi bersumpah menurut Agama Islam bahwa saksi akan memberikanketerangan dengan sebenarnya, tiada lain dari yang sebenarnya.

Hi Class V forTeacher Station,English Version(IK 1800T)Hi Class V forTeacher ControlPanel TeacherExternalBoxEzcontrol Softwarefor controlfunctionCableAccessories1 set 600 600.00Unit9.693.69859.693.695 Hi Class V forStudent Stations,English Version(IK 2200S)Hi Class V StudentExternal BoxUnit104.606.09S46.060.950 Hi Class V IK 180Teacher ExternalBoxUnit4.606.0954.606.095 Hi Class V DataRepeater (IK 288)Unit6.177.8006.177.800 MultimediaCentralizedControlSystem (IK 3000V)CableAccessories IK 3000multimedia

No.2223 K/Pid.Sus/2010 for controlfunctionCableAccessories1 set 600 600.00 Hi Class V forStudent Stations,English Version(IK 2200S) Unit 10 4.606.09 46.060.950Hi Class V Student SExternal Box Hi Class V IK 180Teacher External Box Unit 1 4.606.09 4.606.0955Hi Class V DataRepeater (IK 288) Unit 1 6.177.80 6.177.8000MultimediaCentralizedControl Unit 1 6.786.49 6.786.495System (IK 3000V) 5CableAccessories IK 3000multimediacentralcontroller 1.8M AV cablex4 1.5M VGAcable x4 1.2M AudioExternal Cablex1 1.0M

Hi Class V for Teacher Station, EnglishVersion (IK1800T ) Unit 1 9.693.695 9.693.695HiClass V for Teacher control panelTeacher External BoxEzcontrol Software for control functionCable Accessories :1 set 600 600.00HiClass V for Student Stations, EnglishVersion ( IK2200S) Unit 10 4.606.095 46.060.950HiClass V Student External BoxHiClass V IK180 Teacher External Box Unit 1 4.606.095 4.606.095HiClass V Data Repeater ( IK288 ) Unit 1 6.177.800 6.177.800Multimedia Centralized Control System (IK3000V )

Hi Class V for Teacher Station, EnglishVersion (IK1800T ) Unit 1 9.693.695 9.693.695HiClass V for Teacher control panelTeacher External BoxEzcontrol Software for control functionCable Accessories :1 set 600 600.00 HiClass V for Student Stations, EnglishVersion ( IK2200S) Unit 10 4.606.095 46.060.950HiClass V Student External Box HiClass V IK180 Teacher External Box Unit 1 4.606.095 4.606.095 HiClass V Data Repeater ( IK288 ) Unit 1 6.177.800 6.177.800 Multimedia Centralized Control System (IK3000V

Of Inspection)

English Version (IK 1800T),Komputer Server, Laboratorium Komputer dan DisplayMonitoring Labor, Sistem Informasi Akademik (SIA)Berbasis Web Online, Networking (LAN) danPeripheral, diperoleh sebagai berikut: Harga JumlahVo Sat (Rp.)Jenis / Spesifikasi Barang Sat (Rp.)Hi Class V for Teacher Station, Uni 9.693.69 9.693.695English Version ( IK1800T ) t 1 5HiClass V for Teacher controlpanel Teacher External BoxEzcontrol Software for controlfunctionCable Accessories1 set 600 600.00HiClass V for Student Stations

English Version ( IK1800T ) t 1 5HiClass V for Teacher control panel Teacher External BoxEzcontrol Software for controlfunctionCable Accessories1 set 600 600.00 HiClass V for Student Stations, Uni 4.606.09 46.060.950English Version ( IK 2200S) t 10/5HiClass V Student External BoxHiClass V IK 180 Teacher Uni 4.606.09 4.606.095External Box t 1 5HiClass V Data Repeater ( IK Uni 6.177.80 6.177.800288 ) t 1 0Multimedia Centralized Control Uni 6.786.49 6.786.495System ( IK 3000V ) t 1 5Cable AccessoriesIK

English Version ( IK1800T ) t 1 5HiClass V for Teacher controlpanel Teacher External BoxEzcontrol Software for controlfunctionCable Accessories1 set 600 600.00HiClass V for Student Stations, Uni 4.606.09 46.060.950English Version ( IK 2200S) t 10/5HiClass V Student External BoxHiClass V IK 180 Teacher Uni 4.606.09 4.606.095External Box t 1 5 63 HiClass V Data Repeater ( IK288 )Uni6.177.8006.177.800 Multimedia Centralized ControlSystem ( IK 3000V )Cable AccessoriesIK 3000 multimedia centralcontroller1.8M

(Rp.)Jenis / Spesifikasi Barang t l (Rp.)9,693 ,69HiClass V for Teacher Station, Un 9,693, 51 English Version ( IK1800T ) it 1 695HiClass V for Teacher controlpanel Teacher External BoxEzcontrol Software for controlfunctionCable Accessories1 set 600 600.0046,060,95HiClass V for Student Stations, Un 4,606, 02 English Version ( IK2200S) it 10 095HiClass V Student ExternalBox4,606,09HiClass V IK180 Teacher Un 4,606, 53.

Setelahpertemuan pertama tersebut, Penggugat dan Tergugat 3 telah beberapakali menjalin hubungan bisnis, antara lain pada tahun 2004, Penggugatdiminta oleh Tergugat 3 melalui perusahaannya yang bernama D.G.Jones & Partners Hongkong untuk mengerjakan estimasi biaya untukmengganti seluruh aset dari China Light and Power, Hongkong, termasukpover stations, substations, maintenance depots, dan lain sebagainya.Selanjutnya, pada atau sekitar tahun 2011, Penggugat menerimatawaran dari Tergugat 3 untuk membantu