Putusan Nomor 839/B/PK/PJK/2016claims, participating in profits, as well as income from othercorporate rights which is subjected to the same taxation treatmentas income from shares by the laws of the State of which thecompany making the distribution is a resident;Commentary Art.10 paragraf 28Payments regarded as dividends may include not onlydistributions of profits decided by annual general meetings ofshareholders, hut also other benefits in money or money'sworth, such as bonus shares, bonuses,

Normally, distributions by acompany which have the effect of reducing the membershiprights, for instance, payments constituting a reimbursement ofcapital in any form whatever, are not regarded as dividends;Commentary Art.10 paragraf 29The benefits to which a holding in a company confer entitlementare, as ageneral rule, available solely to the shareholdersthemselves.

Putusan Nomor 839/B/PK/PJK/2016claims, participating in profits, as well as income from othercorporate rights which is subjected to the same taxation treatmentas income from shares by the laws of the State of which thecompany making the distribution is a resident;Commentary Art.10 paragraf 3 (28)Payments regarded as dividends may include not onlydistributions of profits decided by annual general meetings ofshareholders, but also other benefits in money or money'sworth, such as bonus shares, bonuses

The reliefs provided in theArticle apply so long as the State of which the paying company isa resident taxes such benefits as dividends. It is immaterialwhether any such benefits are paid out of current profits made bythe company or are derived, for example, from reserves, ..profits of previous financial years.

Normally, distributions by acompany which have the effect of reducing the membershiprights, for instance, payments constituting a reimbursement ofcapital in any form whatever, are not regarded as dividends;Commentary Art.10 paragraf 3 (29)The benefits to which a holding in a company confer entitlementare, aS a general rule, available solely to the shareholdersthemselves.

pencetakan melalui perendamane perakitan melalui vulkanisasie penyatuan dan pemvulkanisasiane pengetasan berflekuensi tinggie perekatanBahwa berdasarkan Canada Border Service Agency, Custom Notice N484,Ottawa, Nov 26, 2002 dan Canada Border Service Agency, StatementOf Reason , Ottawa, December 9, 2002;The distinctive feature of waterproof footwear is that both the sole portionand the a portion of the upper, sufficient to give waterproof protection to thefoot, are incorporated into a single component which

tahan airberarti alas kaki yang disebutkan dalam pos tersebut, yang dirancang untuk melindungi dari penetrasi air atau cairan lainnya,tanpa memperdulikan apakah alas kaki tersebut semuladirancang untuk tujuan tersebut atau tidak;Canada Borders Service Agency, Statement Of Reason, OttawaNov Dec 9 2002The distinctive feature of waterproof footwear is that both the soleportion and the a portion of the upper, sufficient to givewaterproof protection to the foot, are incorporated into a singlecomponent which

kelihatanmemenuhi syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengan cara injectionmoulding, karena untuk masuk pos 64.02 harus memenuhi syaratpembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling, dipaku, disekrup, ditusukatau dengan cara semacam itu;Bahwa pada penjeiasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XIl 64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan: The Headingcovers, inter alia:(a) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orsimilar devices;(6) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

are producedin one piece usually attached to the base or platform by riveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter, the uppers of which,being produced in one piece or assembled other than by stitching,are attached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consisting of straps across the instep and counter or heelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the sole byplugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced

No.291 K/Pid/ 201428dengan sesama warga masyarakat dengan mengingat adanya alasanpembenar menurut hukum).Code Civil Perancis mengaturnya dalam titel IV Chapter IJ artikel 1382sampai dengan artikel 1386 dengan judul Delicts and QuasiDelicts.Dalam artikel 1382 dikatakan bahwa :Any act whatever of man which causes damage to another obliges himby whose fault it accorred to make reparatioKemudian mengenai tanggung jawab terhadap kelalaian atau kuranghatihati di atur dalam artikel 1383 sebagai berikut

:Each one is liable for the damage which he causes not only by his ownact but also by his negligence or imprudenceSelanjutnya artikel 1384 menentukan :He is liable not only for the damage which he caused by his own act ,but also for that which is caused by the act of persons for whom he isresponsible, or by things which he has in his keepingArtikel 1382, 1383 dan 1384 Code Civil Perancis tersebut sama persisbunyinya dengan pasal 1365, 1366 dan 1367 KUH Perdata.Konsep perbuatan melawan hukum dalam

Tort is a civil wrong for which the remedy is a common law actionfor unliquidated damages and which is not exclusivey the breach ofcontract or a breach of a trust or other merely equitable obligationSir P. Wienfield mengatakan bahwa :Tortious liability arises from the breach of duty primarily fixed by law,such duty is towards persons generally and its breach is redressible byan action for unliquidated damagesL.B.

Where an enterprise of a Contracting State carries on business in theother Contracting State through a permanent establishment situatedtherein, there shall in each Contracting State be attributed to thatpermanent establishment the profits which it might be expected to make ifit were a distinct and separate enterprise engaged in the same or similaractivities under the same or similar conditions and dealing whollyindependently with the enterprise of which it is a permanentestablishment.3.

In the determination of the profits of a permanent establishment, thereshall be allowed as deductions expenses which are incurred for thepurposes of the permanent establishment, including a reasonableallocation of executive and general administrative expenses incurred forthe purposes of the enterprise as a whole, whether in the ContractingState in which the permanent establishment is situated or elsewhere.4.

Where profits include items which are dealt with separately in otherArticles of this Agreement, thrn the provisions of those Articles shall notbe affected by the provisions of this Article.dalam terjemahan bebas yaitu:Halaman 9 dari 29 halaman. Putusan Nomor 168/B/PK/PJK/2016. Laba suatu perusahaan dari Negara pihak hanya akan dikenakan pajakdi Negara itu kecuali jika perusahaan itu menjaiankan usaha di Negarapihak lainnya melalui suatu bentuk usaha tetap.

Jika laba termasuk unsur yang diatur secara tersendiri pada pasalpasallain dalam Persetujuan ini, maka ketentuan pasalpasal tersebut tidakakan terpengaruh oleh ketentuanketentuan Pasal ini;Bahwa disamping itu itu sesuai Commentary on Article 12 OECD Model,paragraph 11.2 dinyatakan:This type of contract thus differs from contracs for the provision of services,in which one of the parties undertakes to use the customary skills of hiscalling to execute work himself for the other party Payments made under

If the activity is not one for which the independententerprise would have been willing to pay or perform for itself, the activityHalaman 17 dari 29 halaman.

berdasarkantax treaties, sehingga tidak dapat digolongkan sebagai devidenterselubung sebagaimana didalilkan dalam koreksi Terbanding(sekarang Termohon Peninjauan Kembali) Karena akan menimbulkandouble heaving sebagaimana yang dimuat dalam Article 10.3 P3BIndonesia Thailand yang menyatakan bahwa : The term dividendsas used in this Article means income from shares, mining shares,founders shares or other rights (not being debtclaims), participating inprofits, as well as income from other corporate rights which

is subjectedto the same taxation treatment as income from shares by the laws of theState of which the company making the distribution is a resident;Terjamahan dalam Bahasa Indonesia :Istilah "dividen" seperti yang dimaksud dalam Pasal ini berartipendapatan dari sahamsaham, sahamsaham pertambangan,sahamsaham pendiri atau hakhak lain (bukan suratsurat piutang) yangikut serta dalam pembagian laba, begitu juga pendapatan dari hakhakperseroan lainnya yang diperlakukan sama dalam pengenaan pajaknyasebagai

berdasarkantax treaties, sehingga tidak dapat digolongkan sebagai devidenterselubung sebagaimana didalilkan dalam koreksi Terbanding(sekarang Termohon Peninjauan Kembali) karena akan menimbulkandouble heaving sebagaimana yang dimuat dalam Article 10.3 P3BIndonesia Thailand yang menyatakan bahwa: The term dividends asused in this Article means income from shares, mining shares, founders'shares or other rights (not being debtclaims), participating in profits, aswell as income from other corporate rights which

is subjected to thesame taxation treatment as income from shares by the laws of the Stateof which the company making the distribution is a resident;Terjamahan dalam Bahasa Indonesia:Istilan dividen" seperti yang dimaksud dalam Pasal ini berartipendapatan dari sahamsaham, sahamsaham pertambangan,sahamsaham pendiri atau hakhak lain (bukan suratsurat piutang) yangikut serta dalam pembagian laba, begitu juga pendapatan dari hakhakperseroan lainnya yang diperlakukan sama dalam pengenaan pajaknyasebagai

Barang Dalam Persetujuan Kerangka Kerja Mengenai Kerjasama Ekonomi MenyeluruhAntara NegaraNegara Anggota Asosiasi BangsaBangsa Asia Tenggara Dan Republic Rakyat China),yaitu pada Annex 3 "Rules Of Origin For The The AseanChina Free Trade Area", dinyatakan:Rule 2: Origin CriteriaFor the purposes of this Agreement, products imported by a Party shall be deemed to be originating andeligible for preferential concessions if they conform to the origin requirements under any one of thefollowing:Products which

Articles collected there which can no longer perform their original purpose nor are capable ofbeing restored or repaired and are fit only for disposal or recovery of parts of raw materials, orfor recycling purpose(4; andk.

kelihatanmemenuhi syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengan cara injectionmoulding, karena untuk masuk pos 64.02 harus memenuhi syaratpembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling, dipaku, disekrup, ditusukatau dengan cara semacam itu;Bahwa pada penjelasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XII64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan: The Headingcovers, inter alia:(m) Skiboots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orsimilar devices;(n) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

are producedin one piece usually attached to the base or platform by riveting;(0) Slippers or mules without quarte or counter, the uppers of which,being produced in one piece or assembled other than by stitching,are attached to the sole by stitching;Halaman 16 dari 20 halaman.

(p) Sandals consiting of straps acroos the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(q) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the sole byplugs which lock into holes in the sole;(r) Nonwaterproof footwear produced in one piece (for example,bathing slippers);Bahwa dengan Explanatory Notes, untuk pos 64.02 tersebut di atas,maka sandal jepit dan sandal yang diimpor Pemohon Banding sekarangPemohon Peninjauan Kembali dapat masuk pos 64.02, karena dalamBab 64, pos

Pemerintah Jepang dinyatakan:Pasal 9:"Where :a. an enterprise of Contracting State participates directly or indirectly inthe management, control or capital of an enterprise of the otherContracting State, orb. the same persons participate directly or indirectly in the management,control or capital of an enterprise of a Contracting State and anenterprise of the other Contracting State;and in either case conditions are made imposed between the twoentreprises in their commercial or financial relations which

differ fromthose which would be made between independent enterprises, then anyprofits which would, but by reason of those conditions, have accrued toone of the enterprises but by reason of those conditions, have not soaccrued, may be included in the profits of that enterprise and taxedaccordingly6. bahwa pada paragraf 6.8 Chapter VI OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelinedinyatakan Patents are basically concerned with the production ofgoods.7. bahwa Pemohon Peninjauan Kembali (semula Terbanding) melakukankoreksi

Jepang:Pasal 9:"Where :c. an enterprise of Contracting State participates directly orindirectly in the management, control or capital of anenterprise of the other Contracting State, ord. the same persons participate directly or indirectly in themanagement, control or capital of an enterprise of aContracting State and an enterprise of the otherContracting State;and in either case conditions are made imposed between thetwo entreprises in their commercial or financial relations whichdiffer from those which

would be made between independententerprises, then any profits which would, but by reason ofthose conditions, have accrued to one of the enterprises butby reason of those conditions, have not so accrued, may beincluded in the profits of that enterprise and taxed accordinglyHalaman 16 dari 24 halaman.

Canada Borders Service Agency, Statement Of Reason,Ottawa Nov Dec 9 2002:The distinctive feature of Waterproof Footwear is that both the sole portionand the a portion of the upper, sufficient to give waterproof protection to thefoot, are incorporated into a single component which may be made of rubberor plastic, diterjemahkan ciri khas alas kaki tahan air adalah kedua bagiansol dan bagian atasnya mampu memberikan perlindungan tahan air terhadapkaki, terbentuk dalam komponen tunggal yang terbuat dari

Putusan Nomor 513/B/PK/PJK/2016foot, are incorporated into a single component which may be made of rubberor plastic, diterjemahkan ciri khas alas kaki tahan air adalah kedua bagiansol dan bagian atasnya mampu memberikan perlindungan tahan airterhadap kaki, terbentuk dalam komponen tunggal yang terbuat dari karetatau plastik.Berdasarkan fakta, uraian di atas, dan sesuai dengan ketentuan hukumyang berlaku, terbukti dan tidak terbantahkan lagi bahwa Termohon PeninjauanKembali tidak tepat dalam mengklasifikasikan

memenuhisyarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengan cara injection moulding, karenauntuk masuk pos 64.02 harus memenuhi syarat pembuatannya dengan caradijahit, dikeling, dipaku, disekrup, ditusuk atau dengan cara semacam itu;Bahwa pada penjelasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XII 64021 ExplanatoryNotes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan: The Heading covers, Inter alia:(a) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orSimilar devices;(b) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

are produced inone piece usually attached to the base or platform by riveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter, the uppers of which, beingproduced in one piece or assembled other than by stitching, areattached to the sole by stitching;Halaman 30 dari 33 halaman.

(d) Sandals consisting of straps across the instep and counter or heel strapattached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the sole byplugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced in one piece (for example, bathingslippers);Bahwa dengan Explanatory Notes, untuk pos 64.02 tersebut di atas, makasandal jepit dan sandal yang diimpor Pemohon Banding sekarang PemohonPeninjauan Kembali dapat masuk pos 64.02, karena pada bab 64,

Products which are wholly obtained of produced as set out anddefined in Rule 3, orb. Products not wholly produced or obtained provided that the saidproducts are eligible under Rule 4, Rule 5 and Rule 6:Rule 3" Wholly Obtained "Within the meaning of Rule 2 (a), the following shall be consideredas wholly produced or obtained in a party:(a) Plant! and plant products harvested, picked or gathered there;(b) Live animals?

Party, provided that thatParty has the rights to exploit such waters, seabed and beneaththe seabed in accordance with international law,(g) Products of sea fishing and other marine products taken fromthe high seas by vessels registered with a Party or entitled toSly the flag of that Party,(h) Products processed and/or made on board factory shipsregistered with a Party or entitled to fly the flag of that Party,exclusively from products referred to in paragraph (g) above,(i) Articles collected there which

Articles collected there which can no longer perform their originalpurpose nor are capable of being restored or repaired and are fit only fordisposal or recovery of parts of raw materials, or for recyclingpurposes4, andj.

air berarti alas kaki yang disebutkan dalam pos tersebut, yang dirancang untuk melindungi dari penetrasi air atau cairan lainnya, tanpamemperdulikan apakah alas kaki tersebut semula dirancang untuk tujuantersebut atau tidak.Canada Borders Service Agency, Statement Of Reason,Ottawa Nov Dec 9 2002:The distinctive feature of waterproof footwear is that both the sole portionand the a portion of the upper, sufficient to give waterproof protection to thefoot, are incorporated into a single component which

memenuhisyarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengan cara injection moulding, karenauntuk masuk pos 64.02 harus memenuhi syarat pembuatannya dengan caradijahit, dikeling, dipaku, disekrup, ditusuk atau dengan cara semacam itu;Bahwa pada penjelasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XII 64021 ExplanatoryNotes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan: The Heading covers, Inter alia:(a) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orSimilar devices;(b) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

are produced inone piece usually attached to the base or platform by riveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter, the uppers of which, beingproduced in one piece or assembled other than by stitching, areattached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consisting of straps across the instep and counter or heel strapattached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the sole byplugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced

Berdasarkan CANADA BORDER SERVICE AGENCY, Custom Notice N484,Ottawa, 26 Nov 2002 dan CBSA Statement Of Reason , Ottawa 9Desember 2002The distinctive feature of waterproof footwear is that both the sole portionand the a portion of the upper, sufficient to give waterproof protection tothe foot, are incorporated into a single component which may be made ofrubber or plastic.Diterjemahkan oleh Penerjemah Resmi Dan Tersumpah :Harry F.

Majelis berpendapat bahwa Pos 64.01 sampai dengan pos 64.05 dibedakanberdasarkan bahanpenyusun outer sole dan upper , Explanatory Noted Bab64 Umum (B)Menurut pendapat pemohon banding ( kami ) penyataan diataskurang tepat karena berdasarkan Harmonized System :Pos 64.01 Waterproof footwear with outer soles and uppers of rubber orof plastic, the uppers of which are neither fixed to the sole norassembled by stitching, riveting, nailing, screwing, plugging orsimilar processes.Pos 64.02 Other footwear

memenuhi syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengan caraInjection moulding, karena untuk masuk pos 64.02 harusmemenuhi syarat pembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling, dipaku,disekrup, ditusuk atau dengan cara semacam itu.11.Bahwa pada penjelasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XII 64021 ExplanatoryNotes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan : TheHeading covers, Inter alia: (g) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets or similardevices;(h) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

are produced in onepiece usually attached to the base or platform by riveting;(i) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter,the uppers of which, beingproduced in one piece or assembled other than by stitching, are attachedto the sole by stitching;(j) Sandals consiting of straps across the Instep and counter or heelstrapattached to the sole by any process;(k) Thongtype sandals In which the thongs are attached to the sole by plugsHalaman 21 dari 24 halaman.

kelihatanmemenuhi syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengan cara injectionmoulding, karena untuk masuk Pos 64.02 harus memenuhi syaratpembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling, dipaku, disekrup, ditusuk ataudengan cara semacam itu;Bahwa pada penjelasan Pos 64.02 pada halaman XIl 64021 ExplanatoryNotes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan : The Heading covers, inter alia:(a) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orsimilar devices;(ob) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

are produced inone piece usually attached to the base or platform byriveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter,the uppers of which, beingproduced in one piece or assembled other than by stitching, areattached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter or heel strapattached to the sole by any process;Halaman 18 dari 21 halaman.

(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the sole byplugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced in one piece (for example, bathingslippers);Bahwa dengan Explanatory Notes, untuk Pos 64.02 tersebut di atas,maka sandal jepit dan sandal yang diimpor Pemohon Bandingsekarang Pemohon Peninjauan Kembali dapat masuk Pos 64.02, karenapada Bab 64, pos yang palingsandal adalah Pos 64.02;Bahwa menurut Ketentuan Umum Mengintrepretasi Harmonized Systemtepat untuk

Pemerintah Singapura, antara lain diatur halhalsebagai berikut:Pasal 5 angka 7 :An enterprise of a Contracting State shall not be deemed to have apermanent establishment in the other Contracting State merely because itHalaman 9 dari 19 halaman Putusan Nomor 487/B/PK/PJK/2016carries on business in that other State through a broker, generalcommission agent or any other agent of an independent status, wheresuch persons are acting in the ordinary course of their businessPasal 10:Dividends paid by a company which

owner of the dividendsthe tax so charged shall not exceed:10% of the gross amount of the dividends if the recipient is a companywhich owns directly at least 25% of the capital of the company paying thedividends;15% of the gross amount of the dividends in all other cases.The competent authorities of the Contracting States shall by mutualagreement settle the mode of application of these limitations.The provisions of this paragraph shall not affect the taxation of thecompany on the profits out of which

the dividends are paid.The term "dividends" as used in this Article means income from shares orother rights, not being debtclaims, participating in profits, as well asincome from other corporate rights which is subject to the same taxationtreatment as income from shares by the laws of the State of which thecompany making the distribution is a resident.6.

Putusan Nomor 840/B/PK/PJK/2016laws of the State of which the company making the distribution is aresident;Commentary Art.10 paragraf 28Payments regarded as dividends may include not only distributionsof profits decided by annual general meetings of shareholders, hutalso other benefits in money or money's worth, such as bonusshares, bonuses, profits on a liquidation and disguised distributions ofprofits.

Normally, distributionsby acompany which have the effect of reducing the membership rights,for instance, payments constituting a reimbursement of capital in anyform whatever, are not regarded as dividends;Commentary Art.10 paragraf 29The benefits to which a holding in a company confer entitlement are,as ageneral rule, available solely to the shareholders themselves.Should, however, certain of such benefits be made available topersons who are not shareholders within the meaning of companylaw, they

ashareholder; this is the case, for example, where the recipient is arelative of the shareholder or is a company belonging to the samegroup as the company owning the shares;Bahwa UN Model Tax Convention on Income and Capital,menyatakan:Article 10The term "dividends" as used in this Article means income fromshares, "jouissance" shares or "jouissance" rights, mining shares,founders shares or other rights, not being debtclaims, participatingin profits, as well as income from other corporate rights which

issubjected to the same taxation treatment as income from shares by thelaws of the State of which the company making the distribution is aresident;Halaman 23 dari 48 halaman.

Normally, distributionsby acompany which have the effect of reducing the membership rights,for instance, payments constituting a reimbursement of capital in anyform whatever, are not regarded as dividends;Commentary Art.10 paragraf 3 (29)The benefits to which a holding in a company confer entitlement are,as a general rule, available solely to the shareholders themselves.Should, however, certain of such benefits be made available topersons who are not shareholders within the meaning of companylaw,

memenuhi syarat kedua karena pembuatannya dengan carainjection moulding, karena untuk masuk pos 64.02 harus memenuhisyarat pembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling, dipaku, disekrup,ditusuk atau dengan cara semacam itu.Bahwa pada penjelasan pos 64.02 pada halaman XII 64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition , Volume 3, dinyatakan : The Headingcovers, inter alia:(a) Ski boots consisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orsimilar devices;(6) Clogs without quarter or counter, the uppers of which

are producedin one piece usually attached to the base or platform by riveting;(c) Slippers or mules without quarter or counter,the uppers of which,being produced in one piece or assembled other than by stitching,are attached to the sole by stitching;Halaman 19 dari 23 halaman.

(d) Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the soleby plugs which lock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced in one piece (for example,bathing slippers)Bahwa dengan Explanatory Notes, untuk pos 64.02 tersebut di atas,maka sandal jepit dan sandal yang diimpor Pemohon Bandingsekarang Pemohon Peninjauan Kembali dapat masuk pos 64.02,karena pada bab 64, pos

No. 424 PK/Pdt/2007"'Party' or Parties is not defined in Article 1 but is applied in theheading of the Contract as defining Batubara, the party to which theGovernment of the Republic of Indonesia is successor as the 'Party ofthe First Part' and ourselves as the Party of the Second Part with bothentities together referred to as 'the Parties.

In our view, this makes itclear beyond doubt that it is only ourselves and the Government of theRepublic of Indonesia which is a contract party and entitled to invokethe right to refer to arbitration to the ICSID disputes falling within theparameters of Article 23.1 for settlement.In addition, and this follows on from the points which we made abovein relation to the purported claimant, whom we would submit is plainlya nonparty to the KPC Contract, the named Second to SeventhRespondents are similarly

not party to the KPC Contract and aretherefore not capable of being bound by any agreement reached byourselves and the Government of the Republic of Indonesia to referdisputes which may arise between us and us alone to arbitrationbefore the ICSID.We would urge the Secretary General therefore to refuse to registerthe Request for Arbitration on the basis that arbitration proceedingshave been commenced by an entity which is not a party to the KPCContract and therefore not entitled to invoke provisions

No. 424 PK/Pdt/2007in dispute from the Republic of Indonesia which is signatory to theConvention. Whatever the status of the Claimant, in respect of whichwe make no admission, plainly it is not a Contracting State, it has notbeen designated a subdivision thereof and, in terms of establishingwhatever rights the Claimant may have to pursue a claim for allegedbreach of contract to which it is not on the face a party, this is not amatter which should be determined in arbitration before ICSID."

Kaltim Prima Coal)sendiri menyatakan dalam surat tertanggal 15 Mei 2006 bahwa :"'Party' or 'Parties' is not defined in Article 1 but is applied in theheading of the Contract as defining Batubara, the party to which theGovernment of the Republic of Indonesia is successor as the Party ofthe First Part' and ourselves as the Party of the Second Part with bothentities together referred to as 'the Parties.

Pasal 9.3 itu sendiri antara lain menyatakan:except as otherwise provided in Appendix P, late payments by either party shallbear interest at the Late Payment Interest Rate from the date on which suchpayment was originally due until the date that such payment was made,Bahwa dalam kenyataannya, Pemohon Banding, karena satu dan lain hal, tidakdapat melunasi pembelian tenaga listrik dari PT. Paiton Energy.

Paiton EnergyCompany dengan Perusahaan Umum Listrik Negara: "except asotherwise provided in Appendix P, late payments by either partyshall bear interest at the Late Payment Interest Rate from the dateon which such payment was originally due until the date that suchpayment was made (bahwa bunga dapat dikenakan atasketerlambatan pembayaran yang dikenakan' sejak tanggalseharusnya dilakukan pembayaran sampai tanggal dibayarkannyahutang listrik swasta tersebut), bukan berkaitan dengan transaksiPeminjaman

Article 9.3 Late Payments:Except as as otherwise provided in Appendix P, latepayments by either Party shall bear interest at the LatePayment Interest Rate from the date on which suchpayment was originally due until the date that suchpayment was made;b.

Appendix P Invoicing and Payment Procedures:"Broken contract" shall have the meaning set forth inSection 7 (c);"Reference Banks" shall mean, collectively, at least three(3) banks designated as such by PLN from time to time(one of which shall at all times be Bank Indonesia or anysuccessor central bank for the Republic of Indonesia),subject to approval of Seller, which shall not beunreasonably withheld, provided that any change in thedesignation of a Reference Bank with respect to anyBilling Period

Paiton Energy, sedangkan ketentuanmengenai keterlambatan pembayaran atas transaksi jualbelinya (hutang pembelian) masih diatur dalam Pasal 9.3 LatePayments Power Purchase Agreement yang berbunyi: Exceptas as otherwise provided in Appendix P, late payments byeither Party shall bear interest at the Late Payment InterestRate from the date on which such payment was originally dueuntil the date that such payment was made; (bahwa bungadapat dikenakan atas keterlambatan pembayaran yangdikenakan sejak tanggal

Berdasarkan CANADA BORDER SERVICE AGENCY, Custom Notice N484,Otlawa, 26 Nov 2002 dan CBSA Statement Of Reason , Ottawa 9Desember 2002The distinctive feature of waterproof footwear is that both the sole portionand the a portion of the upper, sufficient to give waterproof protection tothe foot, are incorporated into a single component which may be made ofrubber or plastic ;Halaman 11 dari 25 halaman. Putusan Nomor 1076/B/PK/PJK/2014Diterjemahkan oleh Penerjemah Resmi Dan Tersumpah :Harry F.

lainnya,Canada Customs bahwa ciri khas alas kaki kedap air adalah keduabagian sol dan bagian atasnya mampu memberikan perlindungan kedapairterhadap kaki.3.Majelis berpendapat bahwa Pos 64.01 sampai dengan pos 64.05 dibedakanberdasarkan bahanpenyusun outer sole dan upper, Explanatory Noted Bab64 Umum (B)+ Menurut pendapat Pemohon Banding (kami) penyataan diataskurangtepat karena berdasarkan Harmonized System:Pos 64.01 Waterproof footwear wth outer soles and uppers of rubber orof plastic, the uppers of which

kelihatanmemenuhi syarat kKedua karena pembuatannya dengan cara injectionmoulding, karena untuk masuk sub pos 64.02 harus memenuhi syaratpembuatannya dengan cara dijahit, dikeling, dipaku, disekrup, ditusukatau dengan cara semacam itu.Bahwa pada penjelasan sub pos 64.02 pada halaman XII 64021Explanatory Notes, Fifth Edition, Volume 3, dinyatakan : The Headingcovers, inter alia:(a) Ski boots conSisting of several moulded parts hinged on rivets orsimilar devices;(b) Clogs wthout quarter or counter, the uppers of which

are producedin one piece usually attached to the base or platform by riveting;(c) Slippers or mules wthout quarter or counter, the uppers of which,being produced in one piece or assembled other than by stitching,are attached to the sole by stitching;(d) Sandals consiting of straps across the instep and counter orheelstrap attached to the sole by any process;(e) Thongtype sandals in which the thongs are attached to the sole byplugs whichlock into holes in the sole;(f) Nonwaterproof footwear produced