. : 2164523689 dated 29.08.2016, tentang SCAFFOLDING untuk Boiler 2,senilai Rp.270.000.000. ;Bahwa, atas dan atau terhadap Pekerjaan Pekerjaan yang berdasar pada PO( Purchase Order ) No. : 2164523167 dated 23.08.2016 , yang NilainyaRp. 5.307.578.313, , Dan PO. No. : 2164524360 dated 05 / 09 / 2016, yangNilainya Rp.3.122.576.931,,serta ditambah dengan PO.

. : 2164524360 dated 05 / 09 /2016 serta BERITA ACARA SERAH TERIMA , NO: 12 / MUT IP / BAST / XI /2016 , Pada Hari Rabu , Tanggal 23 November 2016, untuk dan atas Kontrak / PONo. : 2164523167 dated 23.08.2016 , antara PT. INDOPORLEN dan PT. MEISOUTAMA TEHNIKA. Bahwa, dalam Proses Penyelesaian bahagian dari Scope Pekerjaan sebagaimanatertuang Dalam: PO No. : 2164523167 dated 23.08.2016 dan PO No.2164524360 dated 05/09/2016, yang keduanya dirunut / didasari pada Proposal /Quotation dari PT.

No. : 2164523167 dated 23.08.2016dan PO. No. : 2164524360 dated 05/09/2016, yang keduanya dirunut/didasaripada Quotation dari PT. MEISO UTAMA TEHNIKA No : 014/QUO/MUTIP/Vill/rev.3/2016 dated 18/07/2016 dan Quotion No : 023 / MUT IP/VIII/15.Rev.dated 23/08/2016; yang dalam Pelaksanaan Pekerjaannya, oleh Pihak PT.INDOPORLEN (TERGUGAT), menyerahkannya kepada Pihak PT. INDOPORLENSAKTI (Yang Nota Bene adalah anak Perusahaan PT.

dated 05/09/2016, yang keduanya dirunut / didasari pada Quotation dari PT.

MEISO UTAMATEHNIKA No : 014 / QUO / MUT IP / VIII / rev.3 / 2016 dated 18/07/2016 danQuotion No : 023 / MUT IP / VIII /15.Rev. dated 23 /08/2016;Halaman 9 dari 30 Putusan Nomor 107/PDT/2018/PT.BDG17.

MENGADILI: Menerima dan mengabulkan Gugatan Penggugat untuk sebagian; Menyatakan Perjanjian Hutang Piutang dengan Pembayaran secara Angsuran tertanggal 15 November 2017 (Deferred Payment Agreement dated November 15th, 2017) adalah sah dan mengikat Penggugat dan Tergugat; Menyatakan Tergugat telah melakukan wanprestasi (cidera janji) terhadap Perjanjian Hutang Piutang dengan Pembayaran secara Angsuran tertanggal 15 November 2017 (Deferred Payment Agreement dated November 15th, 2017);

Menghukum Tergugat untuk membayarkan tunggakan pembayaran sebesar Rp 8.727.531.581,- (delapan milyar tujuh ratus dua puluh tujuh juta lima ratus tiga puluh satu ribu lima ratus delapan puluh satu Rupiah); Menghukum Tergugat untuk membayar bunga sesuai dengan Perjanjian Hutang Piutang dengan Pembayaran secara Angsuran tertanggal 15 November 2017 (Deferred Payment Agreement dated November 15th, 2017) sebesar Rp 1.314.408.598,- (satu milyar tiga ratus empat belas juta empat ratus delapan ribu

25 Nopember2013 for eivil end ossoeicted work ( PO No.4504837655) den PerjanjianSubcontract Agreement dated 28 Januan 2014.

Asuransi BhaktiBhayangkara) adalah sehubungan dan merupakan jaminan dariSUBCONTRACT AGREEMENT DATED 25 NOVEMBER 2013 FOR CIVILAND ASSOCIATED WORK DENGAN PO 4504837655 DANSUBCONTRACT AGREEMENT DATED 28 JANUARI 2014 FOR CIVILAND ASSOCIATED WORK DENGAN PO 4504938357 yang sematamataditerbitkan untuk kepentingan atau keuntungan Penggugat selaku penerimamanfaat.Halaman 17 dari 33 Putusan Nomor. 28/Pdt.G/2017/PN.PbrBahwa berdasarkan Surat Keputusan Bank Indonesia No.23/88/KEP/DIR jo.Surat Edaran Bank Indonesia

AGREEMENT DATED 28 JANUARI 2014 FOR CIVILAND ASSOCIATED WORK DENGAN PO 4504938357.Bahwa hubungan hukum bukan saja antara Penggugat dan Turut Tergugattetapi juga melibatkan Bank Riau serta Turut Tergugat.SUBCONTRACT AGREEMENT DATED 25 NOVEMBER 2013 FOR CIVILAND ASSOCIATED WORK DENGAN PO 4504837655 DAN SUBCONTRACTAGREEMENT DATED 28 JANUARI 2014 FOR CIVIL AND ASSOCIATEDWORK DENGAN PO 4504938357 TIDAK MEMENUHI SYARAT FORMILTERTENTU SEBAGAIMANA DIWAJIBKAN OLEH UNDANGUNDANG,MAKA KEDUA SUBCONTRACT AGREEMENT

Bahwa oleh karena subcontract agreement dated 25 november 2013 forcivil and associated work dengan po 4504837655 dan subcontractagreement dated 28 januari 2014 for civil and associated work dengan po4504938357 tersebut batal demi hukum maka seluruh JaminanPelaksanaan baik yang diterbitkan oleh Bank Riau maupun Tergugat yangmerupakan Perjanjian Ikutan (Accesoir) juga harus dinyatakan Batal DemiHukum.B.

28 Januari 2014 for civil and associated work dengan PO4504938357 ;Bahwa Jangka waktu pekerjaan SUBCONTRACT AGREEMENT DATED 28JANUARI 2014 FOR CIVIL AND ASSOCIATED WORK DENGAN PO4504938357 yang berlokasi di Ngabang dimulai dari tanggal pelaksanaan29 Januari 2013 hingga delapan (8) bulan kedepan sehingga penyelesaianpekerjaan jatuh pada tanggal 29 September 2013 ;Bahwa Jangka waktu pekerjaan SUBCONTRACT AGREEMENT DATED 25NOVEMBER 2013 FOR CIVIL AND ASSOCIATED WORK DENGAN PO4504837655 yang berlokasi

PIHAK I,CHARLIE USFUNAN, male, an Advocate who having office at Jalan Gunung BromoXI No. 8, Banjar/Lingkungan Panca Kerta,Kelurahan Tegal Kerta, KecamatanDenpasar Barat, Kota Denpasar ProvinsiBali, in this case act for and on behalf ofGRAEME ROBERT SMITH, male, borninIvanhoe, 16" of September 1953, 65years of age, AustralianholderN9813280, Entrepreneurin this instance(sixty five)Citizen, passport numberchoosing a legal domicile in his legalattorney's office, pursuant to Special Powerof Attorney dated

07 April 2018 and hasbeen registered at The Registrar of theDenpasar District Court dated June, 29"2018 agreement,hereinafter referred to as the "1" PARTY",attached to this DANAND NYOMAN PILUANI, perempuan, lahir diMayong tanggal 27 Juli 1977, umur 41empat puluh satu) tahun, Warga NegaraIndonesia, pemegang Kartu Tanda Penduduk(KTP) nomor 5108026707770003, pekerjaanWiraswasta, beralamatdiJalan RayaPemogan Gang Nusa I Blok B Denpasar,Dusun Dukuh Tangkas, Kelurahan Pemogan,Kecamatan Denpasar Selatan

,dated 11 December 2017, which legallybinding (inkracht van gewijsde): 2.

SHM No. 10223/ Desa Pemogan,Measurement Letter Number 05428/Pemogan/ 2013 dated 22 January2013, Land Plot IdentificationNumber (NIB) 22.09.03.10.07404,in the area of 84 m2 (eighty foursquaremeters), registered inthename of the 2" Party;2.

PASAL 7ARTICLE 7 Para Pihak sepakat untuk menuangkanPerjanjian ini dalam Akta PerdamaianThe Parties agreed to enter this Agreementinto a Deed of Settlement (Dading) before (Dading) dihadapan Majelis Hakim Perkara the Judges of Civil Case No.Perdata No. 617/Pdt.G/2018/PN.Dps., 617/Pdt.G/2018/PN.Dps., dated 11 July tertanggal 10 Juli 2018 di Pengadilan NegeriDenpasar2018 at the Denpasar District Court.

TENTANG ALASAN DAN DASAR HUKUM GUGATAN;Halaman 8 dari 46 Putusan Perdata Gugatan Nomor 263/Pdt.G/2020/PN BtmBAHWA SUDAH ADA ITIKAD TIDAK BAIK DARI TERGUGAT PADASAAT SHAREHOLDERS AGREEMENT DATED 12'H AUGUST 2016DITANDATANGANI OLEH PENGGUGAT, KARENA DINYATAKAN AKANDIBUAT TERJEMAHAN BAHASA INDONESIANYA 30 HARI SEJAKTANGGAL SHAREHOLDERS AGREEMENT BERDASARKAN POINT17.2 (b), NAMUN TERNYATA HAL TERSEBUT TIDAK DILAKUKAN;SEHINGGA SHAREHOLDERS AGREEMENT DATED 12!

Namun ternyata Shareholders Agreement dated q2th August2016 yang melibatkan Penggugat dibuat dalam Bahasa inggris, dengandalih atau alasan Shareholders Agreement dated a2th August 2016,akan dibuat pula versi Bahasa Indonesianya dalam jangka waktu 30 (tigapuluh) hari terhitung sejak tanggal Shareholders Agreement danselanjutnya versi bahasa indonesianya tersebut ditandatangani kembalioleh Penggugat dan Tergugat sebagaimana disepakati pada Point17.2(b) dari Shareholders Agreement dated aath August

Bahwa akibat tidak diterjemahkannya Shareholders Agreementdated 12th August 2016 dalam Bahasa Indonesia dan tidak puladitandatangani oleh Penggugat dan Tergugat, mengakibatkanShareholders Agreement dated a2th August 2016 bertentangan denganPasal 31 ayat (1) dan (2) UndangUndang No. 24 Tahun 2009 tentangBendera, Bahasa, Lambang Negara, dan Lagu Kebangsaan Jo Pasal 26(1), (2), dan (3) Peraturan Presiden Nomor 63 Tahun 2019 TentangPenggunaan Bahasa Indonesia;SHAREHOLDERS AGREEMENT DATED 12'H auGUST

Fotokopi Shareholder Agreement dated 12th August, 2016 by andbetween Ching Chiat Kwong as Oxley Batam Pte. Ltd. and Poni Madjukie asPT. Karya Indo Batam, diberi tanda P1a;2. Fotokopi Terjemahan Shareholder Agreement dated 12th August, 2016 byand between Ching Chiat Kwong as Oxley Batam Pte. Ltd. and PoniMadjukie as PT. Karya Indo Batam, diberi tanda P1b;3.

Karya Indo Batam yang ditunjukkan aslinyatersebut sama dengan bukti yang diajukan oleh Tergugat bukti TLa tentangFoto copi Shareholder Agreement dated 12th August, 2016 antara PT. KaryaIndo Batam dengan Oxley Batam Pte.

& Progress Report Nomor: 00154SM/A1/2014 tanggal 4sampai dengan tanggal 6 November 2014;42) Laporan Pengawas Pembangunan Kapal Coal Loading BargeAnugrah Lautan Luas, Pengawasan tahap 4 Oktober 2014 olehKantor Jasa Penilai Publik Rizki Djunaedy & Rekan;43) Asli Surat Nomor 167/EXT/ALLFIN/MDR/XII/2014 tanggal 22Desember 2014;44) Asli Project Progress Report tanggal 14 November 2014 yangditandatangani oleh ISAO TERAOKA (President Director Teraoka TTLPTE LTD) di sebelah bawah kanan;45) Asli Invoice dated

15th Desember 2014 yang ditandatangani olehISAO TERAOKA (President Director Teraoka TTL PTE LTD);46) Asli laporan Pengawas Pembangunan Kapal Coal Loading BargeAnugrah Lautan Luas, Pengawasan tahap Il 23 Desember 2014oleh Kantor Jasa Penilai Publik Rizki Dijunaedy & Rekan;47) Asli Project Progress Report tanggal 27 Februari 2015 yangditandatangani oleh ISAO TERAOKA (President Director Teraoka TTLPTE LTD) di sebelah bawah kiri;Halaman 7 dari 29 halaman Putusan Nomor 101 K/PID/201948) Asli Invoice dated

Bank Mandiri (Persero) Tbk berupaCertificate Of Insurance The American Club dated 30st March 2015expiry 29th March 2016;58) Foto kopi yang dimiliki PT. Bank Mandiri (Persero) Tbk berupaCertificate Marine Hull Confirmation Of Cover Nomor COC069/MH/III/2015 dated 31st March 2015, periode 30th March 2015sampai dengan 30th March 2016;Dikembalikan kepada saksi ADRA HATMOKO MARTOWARDOJO;1) Asli Aplikasi/Setoran Transfer/Kliring/Inkaso tanggal 11/8/2014 dariPT.

Bank Mandiri (Persero) Tok berupa CertificateOf Insurance The American Club dated 30st March 2015 expiry 29thMarch 2016;58) Foto kopi yang dimiliki PT.

Bank Mandiri (Persero) Tok berupaCertificate Of Insurance The American Club dated 30st March 2015expiry 29th March 2016;Foto kopi yang dimiliki PT. Bank Mandiri (Persero) Tbk berupaCertificate Marine Hull Confirmation Of Cover Nomor COC069/MH/III/2015 dated 31st March 2015, periode 30th March 2015sampai dengan 30th March 2016;Dikembalikan kepada saksi ADRA HATMOKO MARTOWARDOUJO;1)Asli Aplikasi/Setoran Transfer/Kliring/Inkaso tanggal 11/8/2014 dariPT.

JoNumber 6 / EKS / 2018 / PN.Dps dated April 16, 2018 which was issuedon the basis of a wrong and wrong application, the Stipulation Number224 / Pdt.G / PN.Dps. Jo Number 6 / EKS / 2018 / PN.Dps dated 16 April2018 is a legal defect, therefore it is very reasonable legally to benullified;.

JoNumber 6/EKS/2018/ PN.Dps dated April 16, 2018, appointedDetermination Number 224/Padt.G/2014/PN.Dps. JoNo.6/EKS/2018/PN.Dps dated April 16, 2018, or at least suspendEstablishment No.224/Pdt.G/2014/PN.Dps. Jo Number 6 / EKS /2018 / PN.Dps dated April 16, 2018;9.

Decision of the Denpasar HighCourt No. 132 / PDT / 2015 / PT.Dps dated October 7, 2015 Jo.

Denpasar High Court Decision No.132 / PDT / 2015 / PT.Dps dated 7October 2015 Jo.

Jo Number 6 /EKS / 2018 / PN.Dps dated April 16, 2018 according to the Aquo case;2.

PutusanPengadilanPajak NomorJenis PajakTahun PajakPokok SengketaMenurutTerbandingPut 43263/PP/M.1/12/2013PPh Pasal 232008bahwa yang menjadi pokok sengketa adalah koreksi atas Dasar Pengenaan Pajak PajakPenghasilan Pasal 23 Masa Pajak Januari s.d Desember 2008 sebesar Rp89.480.500.000,00;bahwa berdasarkan Addendum No. 1 Aircraft Lease Agreement dated 10 Oktober 2007between PT XXX dan PT Energy Spectrum ada klausul yang menyatakan "pihak leese (PTXXX) tidak diperkenankan untuk menghentikan kontrak

Description 1305.151.501 Accum.Depr ATR 425002129.279.192 Other Liabilities2306.273.003 Energy Spectrum4101.415.509 Other exps1301.151.501 Cost 89.480.500.000 bahwa dalam proses keberatan Pemohon Banding menunjukkan Addendum No. 1 AircraftLease Agreement dated October 10, 2007 tertanggal 22 Oktober 2007 yang memuat klausulantara lain :Termination The lessee does not allowed to terminate the lease agreement, unlesstermination compensation shall be paid to lessor based on the following schedule andminimum

Namun sampai dengan batas waktu yang telah ditentukan, PemohonBanding tidak memberikan jawaban atas permintaan keterangan tersebut; Koreksi Penelaah Keberatan Koreksi Wajib Pajak Dalam proses pemeriksaan, Wajib Pajak telah memberikan dan menjelaskan dokumenAddendum ll Aircraft Lease) Addendum Il Aircraft Lease Agreement kepada timAgreement (Dated October 13lh) pemeriksa dan penelaah keberatan namun kami tidakOctober, 2007) tertanggal 19 menerima bukti penyerahan dokumen dari tim pemeriksa,November

Dokumen padatanggal 26 Juli 2010 dari penerima Kanwil DJP Jakarta Khusus bernama Bapak Jehan selakuAnggota Tim Penelaah Keberatan;bahwa sehingga pernyataan dari Tanggapan Terbanding yang menyebutkan "Wajib Pajak sudahmenyetor dan melaporkan PPh 23 atas sewa ATR setiap bulannya tidak dapat dibuktikan" , PemohonBanding menyatakan pernyataan tersebut tidak benar dan Pemohon Banding dapat membuktikandengan Tanda Terima Dokumen;bahwa menurut Terbanding berdasarkan Addendum No. 1 Aircraft Lease Agreement dated

10.395.295 adalah penalty atas pembatalan kontrak, yang merupakan objekPPh Pasal 23,bahwa Pemohon Banding melakukan perjanjian sewa menyewa dengan PT Energy Spectrum sesuaiAircraft Lease Common Terms Agreement tanggal 10 Oktober 2007;bahwa sesuai dengan perjanjian sewa menyewa Pemohon Banding melakukan pembayaran sewasetiap bulannya sebesar US$ 125.000, yang dimulai dari bulan Januari 2008, namun berhenti sampaidengan pembayaran yang kesepuluh;bahwa berdasarkan adendum I Aircraft Lease Agreement dated

50,000,000)dated 17 July 1993 (the Amendment No. 3).Amendment No. 2 To Fiduciary Transfer Agreement (In Respect of ALoanUS$ 27,500,000) Dated April 14 1997 yang ditandatangani olehHalaman 9 dari 61 halaman Putusan Nomor 14/Pdt/2021/PT.DKITergugat Konpensi (SIL) dan Turut Tergugat Konpensi II (MC) yangdilegalisasi oleh Notaris Popie Savitri Martosuhardjo Pharmanto, S.H.

Amendment To Restructuring Agreement Dated 29 August 2001 (US$27.500.000) tanggal 30 Agustus 2001 yang ditandatangani oleh pihakTergugat Konpensi (SIL) dan Turut Tergugat Konpensi II (MC).2.30.

Amendment To Restructuring Agreement Dated 29 August 2001 (US$50.000.000) tanggal 30 Agustus 2001 yang ditandatangani oleh pihakTergugat Konpensi ! (SIL) dan Turut Tergugat Konpensi II (MC).2.32.

Amendment To Restructured Guaranty Facility Agreement Dated 29August 2001 (US$ 27.500.000) tanggal 30 Agustus 2001 yangditandatangani pihak Tergugat Konpensi (SIL) dan Turut TergugatKonpensi II (MC).2.34.

Amendment To Restructured Guaranty Facility Agreement Dated 29August 2001 (US$ 50.000.000) tanggal 30 Agustus 2001 yangditandatangani oleh pihak Tergugat Konpensi (SIL) dan TurutTergugat Konpensi II (MC).2.36.

Jo Number 6 / EKS/2018 / PN.Dps dated April 16, 2018 wasdeclared null and void by law or at least suspended;.

Number 224 / Pdt.G / PN.Dps.Jo Number 6 / EKS / 2018 / PN.Dps dated April 16, 2018 which was issuedon the basis of a wrong and wrong application, the Stipulation Number 224 /Padt.G / PN.Dps.

Jo Number 6 / EKS / 2018 / PN.Dps dated 16 April 2018 isa legal defect, therefore it is very reasonable legally to be nullified;.

Decision of the Denpasar High Court No. 132 / PDT / 2015 /PT.Dps dated October 7, 2015 Jo.

Decision of the Denpasar HighCourt No. 132 / PDT / 2015 / PT.Dps dated October 7, 2015 Jo.

For the reasons set out above I award as follows:a.I declare that the Exclusive licence agreement between the parties dated23 January 2007 ("the Agreement") is a valid agreement which isbinding on the parties;I confirm the declarations made in my award on Jurisdiction dated 14June 2010, namely that:1.il.iii.Clause 15 of the Exclusive Licence Agreement dated 23 January2007 between the Claimants and the Respondents constitutes a validand binding arbitration agreement between the parties;My appointment

as sole arbitrator by the President of the CharteredInstitute of Arbitrators on 12 May 2010 was valid and effective sothat the arbitral tribunal is properly constituted;I have jurisdiction to determine the claimant's claim referred toarbitration pursuant to its notice of Arbitration dated 25 March 2010and request for the appointment of an Arbitrator dated 4 May 2010;I declare that the first respondent is in breach of the Agreement in thefollowing respects:1.il.failing to issue the second letter

For the reasons set out above paragraph 71 of my award is amended to readas follows (the only changes being to subparagraphs (f) and (g):a I declare that the Exclusive licence agreement between the parties dated 23January 2007 ("the Agreement") is a valid agreement which is binding on the parties;b I confirm the declarations made in my award on Jurisdiction dated 14 June2010, namely that:i.

I have jurisdiction to determine the claimant's claim referred toarbitration pursuant to its notice of Arbitration dated 25 March 2010and request for the appointment of an Arbitrator dated 4 May 2010;c.

Addendum to final award dated 8 September 2010 tertanggal 7 Oktober2010 cq. adendum putusan akhir;b.

Emirsyah Satar 1518June 201252 RE RR53 RE transfer funds54 RE transfer instruction dated May 14, 201455 RE Transfer letter28100956 RE transfer usd 120 toA57 RE trsf toH & W58 RE trsf to SCB59 RE TT Dated April 760 RE TT dated Dec. 1461 RE TT dated Mar. 1362 RE TT dated Mar. 2763 RE TT dated May 2064 RE TT Dated Oct 31 and Nov. 165 RE TT dated Sept 166 RE TT dated 20.11.13 21.11.1367 RE UNCHECKED FD UPLIFTMENT68 RE upstars account69 RE RollsRoyce Magazine70 Scan71 Sponsor Letter for Visa Application72

Transfer dated 04 Jan 201773 Transfer Instruction74 Transfer to Pak Wahjudo75 TT Aug. 28 and 3076 TT Dated April 777 TT dated August 2978 TT Dated Dec. 2779 TT dated Feb 2080 TT dated Jan 2281 TT Dated June 1382 TT Dated June 683 TT dated March 2984 TT dated May 2085 TT Dated May 2286 TT Dated May 2787 TT dated May 588 TT dated Nov. 2189 TT Dated Sept. 17 Halaman 132 Putusan Nomor 19/Pid.SusTPK/2020/PT.DKI 90 TT Dated Sept. 2491 TT Dated Sept. 692 RE Q400 Summary Garuda Indonesia93 Artikel dan Iklan

Dec. 27Re TT Dated June 6Re TT dated Nov. 21Re TT Dated Oct 31 and Nov. 1 Halaman 134 Putusan Nomor 19/Pid.SusTPK/2020/PT.DKI Re TT dated 20.11.13 21.11.13rekening transferRevised Reservation June 8transfer 175K to scb H2H4Q92, yang berisi dokumen :TT Dated 5 and 6 DecRe lIpad Pak TiknoRe lpad Pak Tikno (2) 499 1 (Satu) buah flashdisk merk HP warna metalik, Model:v250w, Kapasitas: 8 GB, Kode: GYO8G, yang terdapatlogo Garuda yang datanya telah di ekstract ke dalamCakram Optik CD : D313RE04141991LH

EmirsyahSatar 1518 June 201252) 52RERR53) 53 RE transfer funds54) 54 RE transfer instruction dated May 14, 201455) 55 RE Transfer letter28100956) 56 RE transfer usd 120 toA57) 5/7 REtrsftoH&W58) 58 RE trsf to SCB59) 59 RETT Dated April 760) 60RETT dated Dec. 1461) 61RETT dated Mar. 1362) 62 RETT dated Mar. 2763) 63 RETT dated May 2064) 64RETT Dated Oct 31 and Nov. 165) 65 RETT dated Sept 166) 66RETT dated 20.11.13 21.11.1367) 67 RE UNCHECKED FDUPLIFTMENT68) 68 RE upstars account69) 69 RE RollsRoyce

Magazin70) 70 Scan71) 71 Sponsor Letter for Visa Application72) 72 Transfer dated 04 Jan 201773) 73 Transfer Instruction74) 74 Transfer to Pak Wahjudo75) 75 TT Aug. 28 and 3076) 76TT Dated April 730 RE 7.1.11 Halaman 244 Putusan Nomor 19/Pid.SusTPK/2020/PT.DKI 77) 77 TT dated August 2978) 78TT Dated Dec. 2779) 79 TT dated Feb 2080) 80TT dated Jan 2281) 81TT Dated June 1382) 82 TT Dated June 683) 83 TT dated March 2984) 84TT dated May 2085) 85 TT Dated May 2286) 86TT Dated May 2787) 87 TT dated May

Bahwa penerima bunga adalah pemilik manfaat (beneficialowner);Bahwa berdasarkan Subordinated Loan Agreement datedMarch 31, 1995; Amendment Nomor. 1 to Subordinated LoanAgreement dated January 31, 1996; Amended and RestatedHalaman 21 dari 27 halaman.

Putusan Nomor 1740/B/PK/PJK/2016Sponsor Subordination Agreement dated January 30, 1996"Capital Indonesia Power CV"; Amended and RestatedSponsor Subordination Agreement dated January 30, 1996"Mission Energy Asia Pte Ltd"; Sponsor SubordinationAgreement dated May 1, 1997 "Paiton Power Financing BV"dan Indenture between Paiton Energy Funding BV and TheFuji Bank and Trust Company dated March 25, 1996;Guarantee dated March 25, 1996 made by PT Paiton Energy infavor of The Fuji Bank and Trust Company diketahui

Jika bunga tersebut dibayarkan atas hutang yang dibuat untukjangka waktu lebih dari 2 (dua) tahun atau yang dibayarkansehubungan dengan penjualan kredit perlengkapan industri,dagang, atau ilmu pengetahuan;Bahwa berdasarkan Subordinated Loan Agreement dated March31, 1995; Amendment Nomor. 1 to Subordinated Loan Agreementdated January 31, 1996; Amended and Restated SponsorSubordination Agreement dated January 30, 1996 "CapitalIndonesia Power CV"; Amended and Restated SponsorSubordination Agreement

dated January 30, 1996 "Mission EnergyAsia Pte Ltd"; Sponsor Subordination Agreement dated May 1,1997 "Paiton Power Financing BV" dan Indenture between PaitonEnergy Funding BV and The Fuji Bank and Trust Company datedMarch 25, 1996; Guarantee dated March 25, 1996 made by PTPaiton Energy in favor of The Fuji Bank and Trust Companydiketahui bahwa jangka waktu pinjaman adalah lebih dari 2 (dua)tahun;Halaman 22 dari 27 halaman.

Emirsyah Satar1518 June 2012(52) 52 RERR(53) 53 RE transfer funds(54) 54 RE transfer instruction dated May 14, 2014(55) 55 RE Transfer letter281009(56) 56 RE transfer usd 120 toA(57) 57 RE trsf toH& W(58) 58 RE trsf to SCB(59) 59 RE TT Dated April 7(60) 60 RE TT dated Dec. 14(61) 61 RE TT dated Mar. 13(62) 62 RE TT dated Mar. 27(63) 63 RE TT dated May 20(64) 64 RE TT Dated Oct 31 and Nov. 1(65) 65 RE TT dated Sept 1(66) 66 RE TT dated 20.11.13 21.11.13(67) 67 RE UNCHECKED FD UPLIFTMENT(68) 68 RE

upstars account(69) 69 RE RollsRoyce Magazine(70) 70 Scan(71) 71 Sponsor Letter for Visa Application(72) 72 Transfer dated 04 Jan 2017(73) 73 Transfer Instruction(74) 74 Transfer to Pak Wahjudo(75) 75 TT Aug. 28 and 30(76) 76 TT Dated April 7(77) 77 TT dated August 29(78) 78 TT Dated Dec. 27(79) 79 TT dated Feb 20(80) 80 TT dated Jan 22(81) 81 TT Dated June 13 Hal. 128 Putusan Nomor 22/Pid.SusTPK/2020/PT.DKI. (82) 82 TT Dated June 6(83) 83 TT dated March 29(84) 84 TT dated May 20(85) 85 TT Dated

May 2, 2014093143Naples & Naples FlorenceIndonesia. pdf liquidation Hal. 130 Putusan Nomor 22/Pid.SusTPK/2020/PT.DKI. (25) Re Bombardier Attestation Certificate forPayments(26) Re Bukti transfer(27) RE Copy Paspor Pak Emir(28) RE draft Memo untuk Pak Emirsyah Satar(29) Re FW(30) RE Hi(31) RE Transfer(32) Re transfer 175K to scb(33) RE TT Aug. 28 and 30(34) Re TT dated August 29(35) Re TT Dated Dec. 27(36) Re TT Dated June 6(37) Re TT dated Nov. 21(38) Re TT Dated Oct 31 and Nov. 1(39) Re TT dated

Emirsyah Satar 1518 June 2012(52) 52 RE RR(53) 53 RE transfer funds(54) 54 RE transfer instruction dated May14, 2014(55) 55 RE Transfer letter281009(56) 56 RE transfer usd 120 toA(57) 57 RE trsf toH & W(58) 58 RE trsf to SCB(59) 59 RE TT Dated April 7(60) 60 RE TT dated Dec. 14(61) 61 RE TT dated Mar. 13(62) 62 RE TT dated Mar. 27(63) 63 RE TT dated May 20(64) 64 RE TT Dated Oct 31 and Nov. 1(65) 65 RE TT dated Sept 1(66) 66 RE TT dated 20.11.13 21.11.13(67) 67 RE UNCHECKED FDUPLIFTMENT(68) 68 RE

upstars account(69) 69 RE RollsRoyce Magazine(70) 70 Scan(71) 71 Sponsor Letter for VisaApplication(72) 72 Transfer dated 04 Jan 2017(73) 73 Transfer Instruction(74) 74 Transfer to Pak Wahjudo(75) 75 TT Aug. 28 and 30(76) 76 TT Dated April 7(77) 77 TT dated August 29(78) 78 TT Dated Dec. 27(79) 79 TT dated Feb 20(80) 80 TT dated Jan 22(81) 81 TT Dated June 13(82) 82 TT Dated June 6(83) 83 TT dated March 29(84) 84 TT dated May 20(85) 85 TT Dated May 22(86) 86 TT Dated May 27(87) 87 TT dated May 5

Bahwa PEMOHON PKPU dan TERMOHON PKPU sepakatmengadakan pejanjian Jual Beli Kapal dan Pengoperasian Kapal,sebagaimana ternyata dalam perjanjian:1) Nota Perjanjian tertanggal 10 Oktober 2016/ Memorandum ofAgreement dated 10th October 2016 (Nota Perjanjian), (BUKTIP5A dan P5B): 2) Perjanjian Kerjasama tertanggal 10 Oktober 2016/ CoOperationAgreement dated 10th October 2016 (Perjanjian Kerjasama), (BUKTI P6A dan P6B);3) Perubahan 1 tertanggal 31 Januari 2017/ Amendement 1 dated 31stJanuary 2017, (Perubahan

1), (BUKTI P7A dan P7B); 4) Perubahan 2 tertanggal 1 Maret 2017/ Amendement 2 dated 1stMarch 2017 (Perubahan 2), (BUKTI P8A dan P8B); Hal 3 dari 64 hal Putusan Nomor 153/Pdt.SusPKPU/2019/PN.Niaga Jkt.Pst5)Perubahan 3 tertanggal 1 Juni 2018/ Amendement 3 dated 1st June2018 (Perubahan 3), (BUKTI P9A dan P9B); Untuk selanjutnya secara bersamasama disebut Perjanjian Jual BeliKapal dan Pengoperasian Kapal; B.

6 Maret 2017/ Amendement A dated 6thMarch 2017 (Perubahan A), (BUKTI P11A dan P11B) dan; Perjanjian Untuk Penyediaan Layanan Dukungan Berbasis DiPantai tertanggal 28 Februari 2017/ Agreement for the Provision ofShoreBased Support Services dated 28th February 2017(Perjanjian Untuk Penyediaan Layanan Dukungan Berbasis DiPantai), (BUKTI P12A dan P12B); C.

Staff Services dated 1st February 2017, diberi tanda : P. 11B; 1 (satu) set fotokopi Perubahan A tertanggal 6 Maret 2017, diberi tanda : P. 12A; 1 (satu) set fotokopi Amendement A dated 6th March 2017,diberi tanda : P. 12B; 1 (satu) set fotokopi Perjanjian Untuk Penyediaan Layanan DukunganBerbasis Di Pantai tertanggal 28 Februari 2017, diberi tanda : P. 13A;1 (Satu) set fotokopi Agreement for the Provision of ShoreBased SupportServices dated 28th February 2017, diberi tanda : P. 13B; 1 (satu) set

fotokopi Perjanjian Sewa HiPlough tertanggal 1 Maret 2017, diberi tanda : P. 14A; 1 (satu) set fotokopi HiPlough Hire Agreement dated 1st March 2017,diberi tanda : P. 14B; 1 (satu) set fotokopi Perjanjian Untuk Penyediaan Perlaatan PendukungRangkaian Survei tertanggal 15 Maret 2017, diberi tanda : P. 15A;1 (satu) set fotokopi Survey Suite Agreement dated 15th March 2017, diberi tanda : P. 15B; 1 (satu) set fotokopi Nota Perjanjian tertanggal O1 Juni 2018,diberi tanda : P. 16A; 1 (satu) set fotokopi

Dated 17 July 1993 (/n Respect ofHalaman 41 dari 476 hal.

2(US$27,500,000.00) To TheLoan Agreement dated 17July 1993, dated 14 April1997vide bukti54a.1Pvide buktiP11.a 12.Amendment To The LoanAgreement Dated 17 July1993 (In Respect of TheLoan in the Amount ofUS$27,500,000.00) dated 29August 2001vide bukti P9bvide buktiP12 13.

Nomor 1697 K/Pdt/2015 14.Addendum(US$50,000,000.00) To TheLoan Agreement dated 17July 1993, dated 14 April1997Nomor 2vide bukti P54bvide buktiP13 15.Terjemahan dari AddendumNomor 2(US$50,000,000.00) To TheLoan Agreement dated 17July 1993, dated 14 April1997vide bukti P54b.1vide buktiP13.a 16.Amendment To The LoanAgreement Dated 17 July1993 (In Respect of TheLoan in the Amount ofUS$50,000,000.00) dated 29August 2001vide bukti P9dvide buktiP14 17 Terjemahan dari AmendmentTo The Loan AgreementDated

Addendum Nomor 2 (US$27,500,000) to the LoanAgreement dated 17 July1993, dated 14 April 1997 vide bukti P54a vide buktiP11 Halaman 334 dari 476 hal. Put.

2 (US$50,000,000) to the LoanAgreement dated 17 July1993, dated 14 April 1997vide bukti54bvide buktiP13 15.Terjemahan dari AddendumNomor 2 (US$ 50,000,000)to the Loan Agreementdated 17 July 1993, dated 14April 1997vide bukti54b.1vide buktiP13.a 16.Amendment To The LoanAgreement Dated 17 July1993 (In Respect of TheLoan in the Amount of US$50,000,000) dated 29 August2001vide bukti9dvide buktiP14 17.

Istaka Karya (Persero), a limited liabilitycompany established under the Laws of the Republic. ofIndonesia by virtue of Notarial Deed No. 1, dated 1 April1986 and its revised Deed No. 95 dated 12 April 1986, bothare drawn before Imas Fatiah, $.H., Public Notary InJakarta, subsequently approved by the Minister of Justiceof the Republic of Indonesia in a Decree No.

Ca23474.H.T.01.04.Th 86 dated 7 May 1986 and also publishedin the State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesiasupplement No. 1038, dated 29 August 1986. the Company'sArticles of Association have been amended several times,most recently by virtue of Notarial Deed No. 112 dated 19March 1993 executed before Imas Fatimah, S.H., NotaryPublic in Jakarta, approved by the Minister of Justice ofthe Republic of Indonesia in a Decree No.

C23474.H.T.01.04.Th 86 dated 7 May 86 and also published inthe State Gazette of the Republic of Indonesia SupplementNo. 1038, dated 29 August 1986. the Company's Articles ofAssociation have been amended several times, most recentlyby virtue of Notarial Deed No. 112 dated 19 March 1993executed before Imas Fatimah, S.H., Notary Public inJakarta, approved by the Minister of Justice of theRepublic of Indonesia in a Decree No. C28513.HT.01.04.Th.93.

Istaka Karya(Persero), a limited liability company established underthe laws of the Republic of Indonesia by virtue ofNotarial Deed No. 1, dated 1 April 1986 and its revisedDeed No. 95 dated 12 April 1986, both are drawn beforeImas Fatiah, SH. Public Notary In Jakarta, subsequentlyapproved by the Minister of Justice of the Republic. ofIndonesia in a Decree No.

C23474.H.T.01.04Th 86 dated 7May 1986 and also published in the state Gazette of theRepublic of Indonesia suplement No. 1038. dated 29 August1986. the Company's Articles of fociation have beenamended several times, most recently by virtue of Notarialeed No. 112 dated 19 March 1993 executed before ImasFatimah. S.H., Notary Public in Jakarta, approved by theMinister of Justice of the Republic of Indonesia in aDecree No.

By Pass Ngurah Rai No. 2001,Simpang Dewa Ruci, Kuta, Badung, Bali.Act for and on behalf of Jordana Renee Loren based on the special power of attorney dated 17January 2014.

No. 972/K.WNA/2009 dated 28October 2009. From the marriage was born a child named Asia Avani Matthews on 23November 2013 in Denpasar, Bali in accordance with the Excerpt Of Birth Certificate no.No. 52/UM.WNA/2009 (hereinafter referred to as the Child)2. Whereas the First Party and the Second Party were stated divorce according to the Excerptof Decision of the District Court Denpasar No.20/Pdt.G/2011/PN. Dps dated 4 Januari2012;3.

dimohonkan banding dengan perbaikan karena tidak dicantumkannya mengenai eksepsi Tergugat dalam amar putusan, sehingga amar selengkapnya berbunyi sebagai berikut ;

DALAM EKSEPSI;

- Menolak Eksepsi Pembanding/Tergugat;

DALAM POKOK PERKARA;

1. Menerima dan mengabulkan gugatan Penggugat untuk sebagian;
2. Menyatakan Perjanjian Hutang Piutang dengan Pembayaran secara abgsuran tertanggal 15 Nivember 2017 (Deferred Payment Agreement dated

November 15^th,2017) adalah sah dan mengikat Penggugat dan Tergugat;

satu ribu lima ratus delapan puluh satu rupiah);

M E N G A D I L I :

1. Mengabulkan gugatan Penggugat sebagian;
2. Menyatakan Tergugat telah melakukan Wanprestasi;
3. Menyatakan bahwa Proforma Invoice, Seller Reff: 01A/PI/GPI-SMI/X/2021, Buyer Reff: 002138-Dated 10/12/2021, tanggal 12 Oktober 2021 sebesar 23,520 USD, Proforma Invoice, Seller Reff: 01

/PI/GPI-SMI/X/2021, Buyer Reff: 002139 Dated 10/12/2021, tanggal 12 Oktober 2021 sebesar 24,794 USD,dan seluruh korespondensi melalui email dan percakapan WhatsApp, adalah sah secara hukum;